News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by redsummer on Sunday April 02, 2017 @02:10PM (#14018227)
Utah is more like what the US used to be like. Demographically, it's like early 60s America. Whiter, higher social trust, more Christian, neighborly, higher work ethic, higher rates of marriage, more kids, fewer illegitimate kids, no grievance industry etc. Many of these factors are looked down on by people of a certain political outlook. Seen as regressive. And yet they're happier in Utah.

The Mormons try harder to keep on the straight and narrow because their religion is less authentic - it's made up by a couple of PT Barnum types, rather than centuries of tradition. You don't need to try hard if you're resting on a thousand years of tradition.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=371&v=7q6brMrFw0E

Perhaps the lesson is that you should join the most absurd religion (or invent your own) and then make up for its absurdity strive to live a good life in order to prove the effectiveness of the religion.

Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by Dobbs on Sunday April 02, 2017 @02:36PM (#14018317)
On the other hand Utah has one of the higher suicide rates in the country[1], and leads the country in use of antidepressants[2].

Despite being tongue-in-cheek I think the lesson is not so cut and dry. In my personal, anecdotal experience, a lot of the behavior in Utah is forced to keep up the image of a particular life style.

1: https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm6345a10.htm 2: http://articles.latimes.com/2002/feb/20/news/mn-28924

Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by thedevil on Sunday April 02, 2017 @09:38PM (#14020082)
My personal experience is consistent with your second point.

But I'd be careful about making conclusions from the suicide/antidepressant statistics. It's shown to be highly correlated to altitude. I've included a couple links from google search to demonstrate the point.

That being said, the Mormon/LDS church does cause some psychological hardships for certain groups such as LGBT and ex-mormons... at least in my anecdotal experience.

suicide rate map: http://akinokure.blogspot.com/2015/03/higher-suicide-rates-o...

altitude map: http://weather.unisys.com/usgs/

Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by coryfklein on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @05:30PM (#14037398)
How do you account for the uptick in the suicide rate since the introduction of the Mormon policy of excommunicating gays and disallowing their children from baptism? The altitude certainly didn't increase...
Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by ScottBurson on Sunday April 02, 2017 @03:55PM (#14018713)
A joke I heard once is that entering Provo you see a sign: "Have a Nice Day. It's the Law."
Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by cookiecaper on Sunday April 02, 2017 @03:37PM (#14018619)
Statistics about Utah must always be taken with a grain of salt, even larger than is typically appropriate for gross/large-scale generalizations. People know that Utah stats are seen as a proxy for the success and/or failure of Mormonism and will distort findings to accommodate their agenda.

A quick example of this is that after Prop 8 passed in CA, a "study", using data sourced from a single, unnamed "top 10 pay site vendor" was published claiming that Utah had the highest incidence of online porn use in the US. That myth stuck for a while, but PornHub started releasing state-by-state traffic reports on its blog and have repeatedly and clearly debunked it. By those numbers, Utah regularly ranks in the bottom 10 states for online porn use.

Regarding depression, Mormon leaders explicitly encourage people to seek mental health treatment if/as necessary, and actively work to destigmatize the use of antidepressants, so increased use in Utah should not be a surprise. Leaders have told them it's OK, so they proceed without the guilt that may be unresolved in other areas.

Just conjecture here, but maybe a correlation between suicide and antidepressant use is a signal that antidepressants are inadequate and/or, at least in some cases, potentially counterproductive, rather than a signal that the populace is less happy vs. the baseline.

Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by narrowrail on Sunday April 02, 2017 @05:54PM (#14019258)
I've had so many jack-mormon friends over the last 20 years. We'd drink beer and whiskey, and smoke a joint. Anti-depressants are straight-up drugs. It's like removing the fructose from fruit and leaving the fiber. The mormons I've known that were still devout wouldn't even consume caffeine.

Edit: Over the last 30 years my 3 best ski days were at Solitude, Snowbird, and Alta. I just wish you all had more realistic laws for beer and weed.

Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by themodelplumber on Sunday April 02, 2017 @02:39PM (#14018338)
As a Mormon, allow me to suggest that the logic underlying your comment re:less authenticity strikes me as kinda PT Barnum in its own special way. I mean, I am used to receiving informed tips on the history of my church from those who know better than me, but the other high-wire mental gymnastics here, well, hope we got a nice net underneath.
Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by hackuser on Sunday April 02, 2017 @05:45PM (#14019203)
> Mormons try harder to keep on the straight and narrow because their religion is less authentic - it's made up by a couple of PT Barnum types

This would be outrageous to day about Jews, Lutherans, Muslims ... Mormons are not a special case. At the least, if criticizing other people's religion, offer something that demonstrates thought and contributes value, not just a cheap insult, and show some respect.

Mormon's origin stories are no more unbelievable than other religions', full of angels, the voice of God, ascensions to heaven, reincarnation, etc. People just give more the other stories more leeway because they are the status quo.

> Whiter, higher social trust, more Christian, neighborly, higher work ethic, higher rates of marriage, more kids, fewer illegitimate kids, no grievance industry etc. Many of these factors are looked down on by people of a certain political outlook.

This is a great example of a common problem of political dialog and ideas. It's not real.

Which "people" does this refer to, specifically? Can you name one? Can you cite specific statements by a popular group that corroborates what you are saying? These "people" created in the mind of the commenter, who then criticizes figments of his/her own imagination.

I'm not saying that to pick on the commenter, but to point out that everyone has the tendency of creating somewhat paranoid, imaginary representations of the "other" - 100% dogmatic adherents to political ideologies, hyperbolic, incorporating all the bad things we hear about these other people. Real people are complex (and not even internally consistent), generally good willed toward you, and don't object to things like high marriage rates and kids with parents.

Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by dorian-graph on Sunday April 02, 2017 @04:23PM (#14018860)
> The Mormons try harder to keep on the straight and narrow because their religion is less authentic

What you're saying goes against the premise of the church—it being the ancient religion that was lost, and then restored, hence ".. in latter days". In fact, this pattern is common throughout scripture (Bible, Book of Mormon, etc.) where the people fall into what's called apostasy, things are lost, and then it's returned again.

Someone else has already commented on your line about the absurdity, otherwise I would've said something similar.

Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by amyjess on Sunday April 02, 2017 @02:41PM (#14018346)
Except that teen suicides in Utah are up. Way up. As in it's tripled in the past decade. And one of the factors is the Mormon church's notorious hostility towards LGBT youth: http://kutv.com/news/local/is-utahs-youth-suicide-rate-linke...

Utah has the 5th highest teen suicide rate in the country: https://www.equalityutah.org/issues/lgbt-youth

More: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/benjamin-knoll/is-the-recent-r... http://www.thenewcivilrightsmovement.com/johnwright/utah_s_y...

Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by cookiecaper on Sunday April 02, 2017 @03:49PM (#14018676)
As far as churches go, the Mormon church does not have "notorious hostility" toward LGBT persons, and does everything it can to give hope to youth who feel they may be part of that group.

It is true that Mormons maintain a doctrine that forbids homosexual behavior. Other than giving that up, they've done everything they can to be welcoming and accepting of gay people, regularly encouraging members to be civil, kind, and sympathetic to those who engage in homosexual behavior, despite disagreements with reference to the propriety of the conduct.

Gay people can and do attend church services, and are included in church activities insofar as their personal compliance with worthiness standards allows. The Church has emphasized repeatedly that homosexual proclivities or temptations themselves are not sinful.

Gay couples even attend church as couples, and the congregation is expected to be warm and non-judgmental.

See https://mormonandgay.lds.org/ .

Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by suresk on Sunday April 02, 2017 @05:25PM (#14019119)
I think claiming that the LDS church hasn't been hostile toward LGBT people is pretty disingenuous, much like claiming they haven't been historically explicitly racist towards black people.

One doesn't have to much more than a google search for "Lds gay quotes" to find a long history of negative teachings from church leaders about gay people. The church recently expended a ton of time and effort to attempt to block gay people from being able to be married. The church had policies about gay behavior (even non-sexual in nature) at its universities until recently. It has had a role in forced gay conversion therapy, which is a horrendous practice.

Even setting aside official teachings, church members in Utah have been incredibly hostile towards gays in the past. I grew up Mormon, and I heard all the things people said about gay people. I worked at the LDS church, where I overheard 2 other employees bemoaning the fact that it was 'probably illegal' to bring a machine gun to a planned gay rally in SLC and mow down all the gays there. Others who were there just chuckled and mumbled about political correctness. I wish I could say that attitudes like that were the exception, rather than the rule.

I appreciate that the church leaders are trying to take a much more moderate approach, and I know there are a lot of church members who work hard to treat LGBT people appropriately and work to make it more accepted by others, and it is really encouraging to see some of the changes over the past 5 years. I do think, however, it is wrong to pretend that the LDS church hasn't contributed to the problem, and I think even the current teaching of "hey, so god decided to tell us that you actually can't change your sexuality, so it is cool if you are gay, but we still think it is kind of icky, so don't do gay stuff" is really hard for someone in that situation. Can you put yourself in their shoes for a minute, and think about how you'd feel in that situation?

Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by cookiecaper on Sunday April 02, 2017 @05:54PM (#14019259)
The issue is that "hostility toward" is interpreted differently.

I want to be clear that I am not pretending, and do not intend to pretend, that the Church condones homosexual behavior. Nor do I intend to pretend that the Church ever will condone homosexual behavior, because I think they're doctrinally forbidden from doing so (whereas there was no explicit doctrinal barrier re: priesthood eligibility or plural marriage).

The difference is that Mormons do not consider themselves more hostile toward homosexual behavior than they consider themselves hostile toward other types of sinful behavior, and as detailed above, the leadership goes to lengths to try to ensure that everyone understands that those who practice homosexuality should be treated with the same civility and respect to which anyone else is entitled.

Pro-gay activists, however, interpret "hostility" to mean any disagreement whatsoever with their activities and demands, up to and including disagreement with the demand that these activities enjoy state sponsorship via marital benefits.

We have to accept that there is a basic moral disagreement here. No one is trying to hide that or say it doesn't exist, or imply that it is going to disappear.

The difference is that Mormons are trying to maintain friendly and civil relations despite that, and trying to encourage people to be sympathetic to the homosexual POV without abandoning their moral standards. Meanwhile, the activists on the other side do everything in their power to lay the blame for suicide, death, and many other massive social malignancies on religion, history, culture, politics, and anything else that disagrees with them.

Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by ScottBurson on Sunday April 02, 2017 @04:10PM (#14018792)
Well, maybe things are in the process of changing, but gay Mormons will not feel completely comfortable until the doctrine forbidding homosexual behavior is consigned to the dustbin of history. You can't say that the behavior is forbidden without having some residue of the belief that homosexuality is inherently sinful, and that residue has impact on people no matter how much you paper over it by trying to be "warm and non-judgmental".

From the FAQ accessible via your link: Identifying as gay may mean you experience same-sex attraction but choose not to act on these feelings.

Yes, and it might also mean that you experience same-sex attraction which is returned and which you choose to act on gleefully! This page is trying to sound non-judgmental, but it shows its true feelings when it says things like this, without allowing for the obvious alternative. And if you think the subtext isn't heard, guess again!

Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by bobthechef on Sunday April 02, 2017 @06:21PM (#14019392)
The idea that desires and attractions must be acted on is an incredibly immature position, sexual or not. Determining if, when, how much, and in what way you should act on your appetites, attractions, or desires is part of what being a mature adult is about. You also seem to be suggesting that disordered attractions can't exist, as if they are infallible, unquestionable, even divine in origin, or that you've somehow given same-sex attraction dispensation that does not extend to other attractions regarded as disordered. People do distinguish between same-sex attraction and the gay lifestyle and there are plenty of people who have the former but do not live out the latter because they believe that pleasure, consent, and social approval do not determine whether something is morally good or not (note that this is not an intrinsically religious question, but one belonging to ethics).

It is unfortunate that subjects such as these cannot be discussed in a dispassionate and reasonable manner and that arguing or holding that the gay lifestyle is morally wrong is somehow an act of hatred or bigotry. If youths with same-sex attraction are indeed committing suicide at high rates in Utah, it makes sense to find out why and address that. It does not follow that they are committing suicide because the Mormon church holds the gay lifestyle as wrong and that therefore the church must change its position. If the moral (again, not religious) principles are true, then they aren't the problem.

Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by ScottBurson on Sunday April 02, 2017 @07:18PM (#14019589)
> "the gay lifestyle"

There's only one, is there? Stereotype, much?

I know several committed gay couples. Is that "the gay lifestyle" that you have in mind?

For one of them to cheat on their partner would be destructive, that's true. That applies independent of the genders involved, doesn't it?

As for singles who have made no commitments but still have sex with one another, is that more immoral if they're gay than if they're straight? I don't think it's immoral in either case, but if you do, I still don't see how gender preference enters into it.

Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by trcollinson on Sunday April 02, 2017 @04:38PM (#14018920)
Mormons also believe that any sexual relations outside of a legal, heterosexual marriage are a sin. I believe in this doctrine. I had many friends who found this doctrine hard to live by between that wanted to act on opposite-sex attraction with glee! I also found this doctrine REALLY hard. I wanted, really wanted, to act with some glee on some people I was attracted to and who were attracted to me. But I didn't. I dated, I got married, and now I have a happy marriage and family.

Would I have been judged? Maybe. Did I have fear of judgement? Maybe. I do know I felt there was a benefit to following this doctrine of celibacy and marriage. Did I judge my friends who didn't follow this? No I did not. Did they feel judged? Possibly, you'd have to ask them. I do know a number of them wish they had followed this doctrine when they did not in the past.

My point is, beliefs by their very nature can make people feel uncomfortable. Beliefs by their very nature can be very hard to live by. Should we remove them all? Where do we draw the line?

Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by ScottBurson on Sunday April 02, 2017 @07:46PM (#14019717)
> Beliefs by their very nature can be very hard to live by. Should we remove them all? Where do we draw the line?

A fair question, and one we must each ultimately answer for ourselves.

I'm glad your choices worked out for you. I had a number of sexual relationships before I got married. While there are certainly some particular encounters and entanglements I regret -- more the ones where I caused pain than where I felt pain -- there were also several I look back on fondly. Even though we weren't right for each other for the long run, we loved, we shared, we grew, and they are part of who I am now. I love my wife very much, but I'm still glad to have known others.

Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by DanBC on Sunday April 02, 2017 @04:52PM (#14018983)
> Where do we draw the line?

Beliefs that cause an increase in death by suicide probably need to be looked at to see if they're really that important.

Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by cookiecaper on Sunday April 02, 2017 @05:36PM (#14019166)
The myth that an external force can drive otherwise-sane people to suicide merely by disapproving of some of their behaviors needs to go.

It is, ironically, perpetuated to shame and humiliate political opponents, by insidiously attempting to saddle them with responsibility for the deaths of the depressed and mentally ill.

Healthy people do not commit suicide, and they certainly don't over issues as ethereal and inconsequential as some religion's disapproval. Just having any religion automatically makes you the target of more condemnation than not, because most religions reserve eternal bliss for their own members.

Furthermore, almost every religion preaches against theft, dishonesty, duplicity, extramarital sexual conduct of any kind, and a range of other basic moral violations that are consistently verboten throughout the history of the human family. People violate these things routinely and, despite the frequent imperatives issued and social pressures imposed to encourage compliance, somehow refrain from killing themselves.

If the argument is that it's about the typical human response to homosexual conduct being so negative that it drives people over the edge, I don't see how the Mormon church, or most other Christian churches, could have any culpability for that, since a universal Christian theme is redemption, forgiveness, and an ability to leave behind a past life of sin and error whenever one commits themselves to doing so.

Mormonism in particular, as described in the parent comment, makes an effort to be civil and polite, and to encourage families to fellowship and associate with their children and friends regardless of one's level of agreement with their personal choices, including their sexual choices.

That doesn't mean that one must endorse, accept, witness, or accommodate any and all behaviors, but it means that one should remain respectful and polite, treat others with dignity and decorum, and continue to have contact in a positive manner to the fullest extent possible.

The Church is compassionate and welcoming to sinners [read: humans] of all types. No special scrutiny or shame is applied to persons who are inclined to sin by engaging in homosexual behaviors vs. those are inclined to sin differently. Any type of sexual misconduct, heterosexual or homosexual, is forbidden by the Church and regularly preached against, and I guarantee you there are many more adulterous husbands feeling guilt and shame over the much-more-frequently discussed topic of marital fidelity than there are homosexuals feeling shame on the rather rare occasion that homosexuality is broached.

Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by ScottBurson on Sunday April 02, 2017 @06:35PM (#14019443)
Shame is indeed what this is all about.

> Healthy people do not commit suicide, and they certainly don't over issues as ethereal and inconsequential as some religion's disapproval.

You don't really seem to think your religion's tenets are "ethereal and inconsequential".

> If the argument is that it's about the typical human response to homosexual conduct being so negative that it drives people over the edge, I don't see how the Mormon church [...] could have any culpability for that

Then I encourage you to read more about the phenomenon.

Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by cookiecaper on Monday April 03, 2017 @04:08PM (#14026645)
>You don't really seem to think your religion's tenets are "ethereal and inconsequential".

Surely I do. Religion deals with the tangible only indirectly. It is focused on the supernatural. Religious condemnation, to the extent it occurs, is not material in reality.

If one truly believed they were doomed, they would want to live as long as possible and put off the anticipated divine punishment.

>Then I encourage you to read more about the phenomenon.

As you say, "shame is indeed what this is all about". The assumption that one is an ignoramus based on their disagreement with a popular belief is an attempt to humiliate people into silence.

I know the argument well. They are always variations of "the Church told me not to do something that I wanted to do. I told them that I couldn't help it, so I was going to do it anyway, and they said, 'Sorry, it's still against the rules.' This caused me untold anxiety and has made me suicidal." I'm not ignorant to such arguments; I simply do not find them credible.

Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by DanBC on Sunday April 02, 2017 @06:03PM (#14019297)
> The myth that an external force can drive otherwise-sane people to suicide merely by disapproving of some of their behaviors needs to go.

It's not a myth.

It's reasonably well established now that LGBT youth are at increased risk of suicide, and that the rates of death in LGBT youth are higher in areas that have lower acceptance of LGBT youth.

The rest of your post is full of inaccuracies about suicide. You need to read some more modern research. Here's a good place to start: http://research.bmh.manchester.ac.uk/cmhs

BTW: That "committed" word? That's a big signal.

Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by cookiecaper on Sunday April 02, 2017 @06:27PM (#14019418)
Restating the point does not constitute a rebuttal. I understand that there is a myth along these lines. The myth, of course, specifies that homosexuals feel oppression, which causes them to commit suicide.

I also understand that people have published documents to attempt to give support to this myth that suicide is correlated with the quantity of social approval.

This has several loose ends, like "How are LGBT youth identified, and is that method reliable, particularly with reference to the effect of puberty and hormonal changes on sexual inclinations?", "Are there other regional factors that are better explanations for the increased teen suicide rate? [e.g., areas with 'less social acceptance' for LGBT may also have increased poverty, decreased access to mental health services, etc.]", "Do we see this affect of suicide motivated solely by social approval among other groups, including those whose oppression and/or isolation is much more serious or intense?", and so on.

As with most publications dealing with controversial issues in the soft sciences, there is plenty of room for disagreement, and on inspection, it usually becomes clear that the publication is intended to promote a particular agenda or conclusion rather than to break through to new objective understandings or research. This is true across the spectrum, and it's why you have both left-wing and right-wing "think tanks".

This myth is a transparent political device intended to humiliate and silence those who'd disagree, and we've had weak enough backbones the last 30 years or so that we've allowed it to work.

EDIT: Your edit is a good example of the lecturing, elitist tone used in shame-based political opposition. It's funny that you single out the term "commit suicide" as some type of indicator, like we're to believe that suicide is not something that someone does, but rather a random accidental event.

Again, I fully understand that there are people who will wrap such absurd conclusions in dense, self-indulgent academic babble and pretend like this grants it credibility, but most people have a sense of connection to reality, a limit on their willing suspension of disbelief invoked by the academic credential, that disallows such disconnected, convoluted logic from taking hold.

The funny thing here is that the purveyors of these theories hardly realize the vast amount of religiosity that goes into their willingness to believe not just the unfalsifiable and supernatural, but the clearly hysterical and nonsensical conclusions that these groups and organizations emit.

Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by ScottBurson on Sunday April 02, 2017 @07:01PM (#14019524)
> This myth is a transparent political device intended to humiliate and silence those who'd disagree

No, it really isn't.

Try to imagine what it's like to be a teenager and realize you're gay. What if you had been gay? How would your parents have reacted? Your grandparents? Your friends? Wouldn't they have let you know, however subtly, that you had let them down, that you were no longer the same person to them, no longer someone they could feel proud of and close to? Even if they all made an effort to be outwardly polite -- and it would be remarkable if all of them did -- can't you see how that would make it even worse? Wouldn't you feel ashamed???

Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by cookiecaper on Sunday April 02, 2017 @05:13PM (#14019073)
Yeah, I mean, there is no doubt that there is a fundamental disagreement about homosexuality between Mormon doctrine (and religion in general) and the popular contemporary understanding.

The Church condemns a set of behaviors, not a state of being, mind, or attraction, so regardless of one's opinion on the origin or fixed condition of sexual attraction, there is no need to feel guilt for inclinations, inherent or no.

There is already ample theological justification for proclivities toward any sinful behavior, which we all have: Earth is a "fallen world", a testing ground where temptation must be presented to all and adequately resisted. This covers forbidden sexual activity, which is not limited to homosexuality, just as well as it covers any other inclination toward sinful or negative behaviors.

Unlike other issues that brought Mormonism into conflict with the prevailing social dogma, this is not flexible and should not be expected to change.

Despite all this, far from hunkering down and drawing exclusionary barriers, the Church is trying, as best as it can, to communicate that everyone is welcome in the "hospital for sinners" that the Church comprises.

Everyone fails to meet the standards that the Church defines along some axes, since Christ literally commands men to be perfect [0]. The goal is to get people accelerating and proceeding toward the ideal, and to provide support in their attempt to do so. Everyone is welcomed to that effort, with as much participation as they are willing to give.

[0] https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Matthew+5%3A48&...

Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by mythrwy on Sunday April 02, 2017 @04:10PM (#14018797)
So a gay couple is OK now as long as they don't actually do anything... gay? This must be new.

I guess Evergreen is done with then?

Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by austenallred on Sunday April 02, 2017 @02:43PM (#14018359)
As an obviously-biased Mormon I'm not sure the conclusion follows.

Certainly there are fantastical elements to my religion (as there are to all religions I know of), but we don't do what we do to compensate for that. We do what we do because we believe it.

Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by redsummer on Sunday April 02, 2017 @03:12PM (#14018481)
Perhaps not to compensate, but to validate. You would never feel compelled to act in a certain way because the sky is blue, or because water is wet. But if you have a political or religious belief, however absurd, you feel a compulsion to act.
Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by austenallred on Sunday April 02, 2017 @03:33PM (#14018587)
I don't see why that's a more logical conclusion than "I believe God wants me to do x therefore I do x"
Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by dorian-graph on Sunday April 02, 2017 @04:24PM (#14018862)
You're missing a fundamental part so I'll add it in, but even so, it's still incredibly simplified so as to push a certain derogatory view.

"I believe God wants me to do x because y therefore I do x because y and/or z"

Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by redsummer on Sunday April 02, 2017 @04:46PM (#14018957)
The y in that is the supernatural stuff - the story. I wouldn't go to see a movie if it didn't have a good story. I wouldn't go if it was just a list of facts. But that's what the dull modern atheists types want me to do in life.
Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by dorian-graph on Sunday April 02, 2017 @05:22PM (#14019108)
Funnily, my intent was to show that y was the dull stuff. Maybe another addition would be "I believe God wants me to do x because y, in the context of s, therefore I do x because y and/or z"?

For example, take a thing Mormons are commonly known for—not drinking alcohol. It came about in what we call the 'word of wisdom' [1] [2].

s := The story part would be "In consequence of evils and designs which do and will exist in the hearts of conspiring men in the last days, I have warned you, and forewarn you, by giving unto you this word of wisdom by revelation—"

x := don't drink (and other health related things like eating meat sparingly)

y := to be healthy in both body and mind/spirit

z := I have faith (faith is effectively trust in someone who has shown that they're trustworthy) in God

[1] https://www.lds.org/scriptures/dc-testament/dc/89?lang=eng

[2] https://www.lds.org/topics/word-of-wisdom?lang=eng&old=true

Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by redsummer on Sunday April 02, 2017 @05:55PM (#14019268)
I read the linked religious texts and the story doesn't seem compelling enough for me to stop drinking the Leffe at my elbow. The fictional story has to to good enough to resonate as a truth. Aesop had the right idea.
Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by dagw on Sunday April 02, 2017 @05:14PM (#14019076)
Lot's of religions have the "I believe God wants me to do x" component without their followers then actually doing X. Non of the Catholics I know, for example, are particularly catholic or overly christian in their day to day behaviour, while all the Mormons I know try very hard to be, well, Mormon.
Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by austenallred on Sunday April 02, 2017 @06:24PM (#14019405)
I'd guess that one of the differences comes in what we believe; specifically, Mormons believe that God still commands us and communicates with us today through chosen leaders - the Prophet and Twelve Apostles. We hear from them once every six months in what we call General Conference (curiously enough it concluded a couple hours ago). So they can add a level of recency and organization to commandments that might otherwise be more vague and ambiguous - e.g. "God wants each member to not eat one meal a week and donate that money to the poor" is a somewhat of a commandment for Mormons, and extends from God. Announcing that five new temples are to be built came from the Apostles today. For Catholics I don't believe most exact/actionable things are quite as direct.
Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by mythrwy on Sunday April 02, 2017 @04:05PM (#14018767)
To be fair PT Barnum types from thousands of years ago should be no more believable than PT Barnum types from 150 years ago.
Re:How Utah Keeps the American Dream Alive by redsummer on Sunday April 02, 2017 @04:25PM (#14018865)
True, but history produces a variety of personalities so a longer established religion will be more rounded. Schools of thought will generate opposing schools of thought etc. Like if you throw a tennis ball hard into a circular room it will end up going pretty much everywhere.