News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The F-35 still has a long way to go by curt15 on Saturday April 01, 2017 @02:33PM (#14013420)
I wonder who doesn't regret cancelling the F-22. At least that airplane has the advantage of raw performance even if you take away its more high-tech features. An air force general once warned that "without the f-22 the f-35 will be irrelevant".
Re:The F-35 still has a long way to go by kevin_thibedeau on Saturday April 01, 2017 @02:42PM (#14013468)
The F35 is keeping far more people employed. That is its main purpose and it has been a resounding success. Its entire procurement process was designed to make it resistant to cancellation by farming everything out to a broad base of constituencies. It is now safely past that hurdle and can do its job as a money machine.
Re:The F-35 still has a long way to go by zachrose on Saturday April 01, 2017 @03:15PM (#14013630)
This explanation comes up in every thread about the F-35. While it has good explanatory power, it doesn't explain why the US couldn't have a non-dysfunctional procurement process that actually delivered effective planes.
Re:The F-35 still has a long way to go by rwallace on Saturday April 01, 2017 @06:45PM (#14014584)
My best guess would be that the people in charge of the juggernaut realize if you equip it with a steering wheel, if you create a way to fix it with regard to quality of output, that same steering wheel could also be used to fix it with regard to cost. In other words, the dysfunctional planes are just collateral damage of the corporate welfare program.
Re:The F-35 still has a long way to go by kevin_thibedeau on Saturday April 01, 2017 @03:20PM (#14013656)
The people controlling the purse strings like the dysfunctional system as it is. Nobody has the power to stop it. There was zero reason for Trump to end the sequester except to funnel more money into the MIC.
Re:The F-35 still has a long way to go by Roritharr on Saturday April 01, 2017 @04:51PM (#14014097)
The truly interesting question would be: How will countries without a broken procurement process compete? Will China be able to spend 0.1% on their new planes and get 1000% ROI?
Re:The F-35 still has a long way to go by ams6110 on Saturday April 01, 2017 @08:53PM (#14015066)
To paraphrase Upton Sinclair, it's difficult to change a process when the salaries of the people who could change it depend upon the status quo.
Re:The F-35 still has a long way to go by JustSomeNobody on Saturday April 01, 2017 @03:23PM (#14013670)
Companies are run by businessmen and not people who want to build extraordinary aircraft.
Re:The F-35 still has a long way to go by TenOhms on Saturday April 01, 2017 @08:54PM (#14015071)
That's awfully cynical, but maybe correct, though I have to believe that even the CEO of a giant defense contractor firm is proud of what they do.
Re:The F-35 still has a long way to go by typon on Sunday April 02, 2017 @09:16AM (#14017038)
You're so optimistic. The CEOs of large companies i know don't even pretend about having a higher purpose
Re:The F-35 still has a long way to go by throwanem on Sunday April 02, 2017 @10:39AM (#14017325)
Why do you have to believe that?
Re:The F-35 still has a long way to go by dTal on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @03:57AM (#14030457)
Planes? For 1.5 trillion dollars and counting I expect nothing less than a working fusion generator, or a moon base, or a proper rotating space station with AT&T videophones.

For reference, 1.5 trillion is more than double the Apollo and Space Shuttle programs, combined.

Re:The F-35 still has a long way to go by zaphirplane on Saturday April 01, 2017 @06:59PM (#14014641)
Have you considered a disinformation side to the equation. How did the Cold War bankrupt ussr ? Was it the Star Wars disinformation;)
Re:The F-35 still has a long way to go by jorvi on Saturday April 01, 2017 @03:09PM (#14013606)
I'm not terribly well-versed in defense contracts, but why don't these kind of massive things (that always go way over time) not have a clausul 'if you, as a developer, go X amount over time or X amount over budget, you foot the rest of the cost until delivery'. Would seem like a very prudent thing to do as a government, and there's still so much money in it I can't imagine defense contractors not going for it.
Re:The F-35 still has a long way to go by nradov on Saturday April 01, 2017 @03:32PM (#14013713)
Sure some defense contacts are firm fixed price with the vendor eating any cost overruns. But no rational defense contractor would ever agree to take on that level of risk for a program as complex as the F-35.

Look what happened to the Airbus A400M. They agreed to a fixed price, and then when the program ran away over budget they blackmailed the EU defense ministers into renegotiating by threatening to cancel the program, close factories, or even go bankrupt. It's just politically impossible to hold the line on these deals.

Re:The F-35 still has a long way to go by ryanmarsh on Saturday April 01, 2017 @03:22PM (#14013666)
I would guess that it's not the contractors fault as much as the clients. Maybe this is my bias from doing contract work and having horrible clients.
Re:The F-35 still has a long way to go by gozur88 on Sunday April 02, 2017 @05:37AM (#14016577)
They tried that in the '90s. A few contractors got into a bind, threw up their hands, and went bankrupt. From a budgetary standpoint that's fine, but when you're limping along with a platform you wanted to retire a decade ago or more (the marines have been stripping museum pieces for parts to keep Harriers in the air), you can't afford another twenty year development cycle.

IMO the F-35 is fine from a capability standpoint. It's just far too expensive.

Re:The F-35 still has a long way to go by Spooky23 on Saturday April 01, 2017 @09:30PM (#14015212)
I've worked for government agencies who've done stuff like that... albeit at a much smaller scale.

Big .gov orgs have a lot of leverage, because they can make or break the sales force.

The end result is that the vendor prices in the risk and overhead. Depending on the political situation and project, it may be worth paying that premium to displace the blame to the vendor. But for something like the F35, the cost is astronomical.

Re:The F-35 still has a long way to go by Gravityloss on Saturday April 01, 2017 @06:17PM (#14014485)
Then you couldn't change requirements. Or companies wouldn't bid. Or companies would go bankrupt.

But there have been some contracts (NASA commercial cargo to the space station) that have had fixed milestones for releasing money to contractor.

Re:The F-35 still has a long way to go by chrisseaton on Saturday April 01, 2017 @05:38PM (#14014327)
Would you sign a contract that looked like that?
Re:The F-35 still has a long way to go by jorvi on Saturday April 01, 2017 @11:55PM (#14015681)
I would find it very reasonable if entity X asks me to develop a fighter jet, X knows from experience that these programs always overrun, X asks me to make a realistic roadmap with some leeway built in, and then X says 'well, if you overshoot milestone 3 by more than one year you'll have to foot the rest of the cost until the next milestone'.
Re:The F-35 still has a long way to go by querulous on Sunday April 02, 2017 @12:27AM (#14015779)
so you agree, then tell X you ran out of money and are closing down the program. faced with choosing to lose a decade plus of progress or letting you out of that clause is no choice at all
Re:The F-35 still has a long way to go by jorvi on Sunday April 02, 2017 @01:23AM (#14015929)
Why not? You can't shutter the program because you're contractually obliged for X to deliver. At that point you either eat the cost and deliver or your company is destroyed by fines and/or bankruptcy. And again: sure, those types of contracts would be harsher than the current situation, but they're still so juicy I can't imagine companies not going for them. Currently it seems to just be a huge money tap for whatever contractor gets them, without any amount of oversight or accountability/liability.
Re:The F-35 still has a long way to go by manquer on Sunday April 02, 2017 @07:13AM (#14016764)
A bankruptcy would be costly to the bureaucrats just as much as to the companies and set you back to square 1 with time & money spent and little to show for it...
Re:The F-35 still has a long way to go by convolvatron on Saturday April 01, 2017 @09:23PM (#14015185)
whether or not its an effective use of money, i've always believed that it was a strategic interest to have all of these people at the ready.

frankly i'm sure that if it came to it, your average clip on tie beltway bandit employee would be more useless than 5 year old in time of war, but i think thats the thinking

Re:The F-35 still has a long way to go by kahnjw on Saturday April 01, 2017 @03:09PM (#14013608)
I'm sure some Russia hawks regret the DOD decision to cancel the F22, but the F35 was not intended to replace the F22, so this is a bit irrelevant. The two aircraft a developed for different uses. The F22 was designed for air to air superiority, while the F35 is a ground attack fighter. The F22 was cancelled because of bulging operating and production costs, and because air to air superiority is not something the military really needs given its current and foreseeable engagements.
Re:The F-35 still has a long way to go by valuearb on Sunday April 02, 2017 @02:43AM (#14016176)
This is revisionist BS. It was meant to do everything, yet it does everything poorly. Lousy fighter, lousy bomber, lousy ground attack plane. It's only good at being a standoff weapon, and far too expensive for that when drones can do it all better and far cheaper.
Re:The F-35 still has a long way to go by kahnjw on Sunday April 02, 2017 @12:44PM (#14017769)
Also, I'm not defending the plane. Obviously it has many problems, I'm merely pointing out that its use profile is different than the F22, and the notion that the F35 was ever intended to replace the F22 is an oversimplification of the DOD air dominance strategy. The F35 was meant to be a multirole fighter, but especially good at ground attack. The F22 RFP was sent out in 1986, when the country was still in the midst of the Cold War. The F22 was originally designed a response to the development new soviet fighters, which could out maneuver and out-hide F15s. The F35 was designed to replace aging fleets of multirole and ground attack fighters.

This isn't "revisionist BS." If you actually go back you'll find that the two planes were designed for different uses. The DOD may have dug themselves a hole while trying to sell the plane to taxpayers by saying it will do everything better than any other jet. That was not the original intent.

Re:The F-35 still has a long way to go by kahnjw on Sunday April 02, 2017 @12:27PM (#14017686)
Hard to say that the F35 was built for air to air dominance when it was designed to carry only two amraam air to air superiority missiles. The F22 can carry six.
Re:The F-35 still has a long way to go by okket on Saturday April 01, 2017 @03:25PM (#14013679)
14 years ago it sounded very much like the Joint Strike Fighter was going to replace the F22 (and the Harrier, etc.)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B7-LQDueYlk&t=11m20s

Re:The F-35 still has a long way to go by kahnjw on Saturday April 01, 2017 @03:30PM (#14013704)
I'll just refer you to the first few sentences of the wiki pages for each fighter :)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_Martin_F-22_Raptor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_Martin_F-35_Lightning...

Re:The F-35 still has a long way to go by protomyth on Saturday April 01, 2017 @10:00PM (#14015343)
Considering now the Air Force is going to have to budget money to fix the F-15C/D if they want it to keep flying.

http://m.aviationweek.com/defense/center-fuselage-rebuild-co...