News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:America Needs Small Apartment Buildings by Nursie on Friday March 31, 2017 @02:32PM (#14006647)
>> So the owner/renter fraction doesn't as such directly change the amount of available property.

It changes the prices of properties. When existing owners have much easier access to cheap credit than potential owner-occupiers, they compete with these folks and push prices up. There is more demand to purchase. Not more demand for properties to live in, but more demand to purchase. First time and young buyers get priced out.

>> Rental prices

I wasn't talking about rental prices, I was talking about purchase prices.

The result is that instead of younger people paying a mortgage and gaining an asset over time, they are doing that for someone else.

Re:America Needs Small Apartment Buildings by mafribe on Saturday April 01, 2017 @03:29AM (#14011019)

   young buyers get priced out
It's good that younger people can't easily buy property. They have a substantially higher risk of financial irresponsibility. As dwellings are pretty much the biggest financial investment we make in our lifetimes, care is warrented. Dwellings should be purchased only by those who are very likely to be able to afford this -- even in the event of unplanned and costly life events like illness, children, the dwelling needing costly and unexpected repair etc. That's why stable job with good career prospects, married with children, being able to afford substantial deposit, being older, are good heuristics for who should by property.

Giving a mortgage to everyone encourages financial rectlessness, which lead to the financial crisis of 2007–2008.

Re:America Needs Small Apartment Buildings by Nursie on Saturday April 01, 2017 @07:50AM (#14011673)
>> It's good that younger people can't easily buy property.

No, it's not, and it's not even to the owner-occupier's benefit that the market inflates so much.

>> Dwellings should be purchased only by those who are very likely to be able to afford this

Young people can afford this, who the hell do you think is paying the buy-to-let mortgage crowd's mortgage? The fecking fairies?

>> That's why stable job with good career prospects, married with children, being able to afford substantial deposit, being older, are good heuristics for who should by property.

They're good heuristics for who should already have property, and already have a substantial sum paid down. Something unachievable if people cannot get started in their 20s.

>> Giving a mortgage to everyone encourages financial rectlessness, which lead to the financial crisis of 2007–2008.

I'm not advocating giving a mortgage to everyone, I'm advocating giving out fewer mortgages to those who wish to buy more homes - they're effectively leveraging cheap mortgages to get someone else to buy them a huge asset, and at the same time making that asset further out of reach for the person who is really paying for it.

Re:America Needs Small Apartment Buildings by mafribe on Saturday April 01, 2017 @09:35AM (#14012034)

   who the hell do you think is paying
Typically a collection of ever changing tenants, few of whom are in the position to manage, or even interested in managing a long-term investment like a dwelling.

   should already have property
Why? What's wrong with renting? As I said in a previous post, Chancellor Merkel in Germany rents.

   I'm advocating giving out fewer mortgages 
I'm advocating building enough dwellings, not doctoring with symptoms like restriction on mortgages, rent control, draconian building codes, zoning laws and the like. I find it supremely baffling that the obvious solution seems to be deeply unpopular.
Re:America Needs Small Apartment Buildings by Nursie on Saturday April 01, 2017 @10:29AM (#14012270)
>> Typically a collection of ever changing tenants, few of whom are in the position to manage, or even interested in managing a long-term investment like a dwelling

This is less frequently the case in the UK, as the inflated market keeps people renting for longer.

>> Why? What's wrong with renting?

A lot, if that's not where you want to be, and have seen the market mutate in the space of a few years from somewhere that was inclusive for most people earning a decent wage, to something reserved for few, or those who already have property.

>> I'm advocating building enough dwellings,

Good luck with that. Restriction of mortgage is not "doctoring the symptoms" when easing up on certain mortgage categories has been a major cause.

I haven't mentioned those other methods, I have no opinion on them.

Re:America Needs Small Apartment Buildings by mafribe on Saturday April 01, 2017 @12:28PM (#14012872)

    keeps people renting for longer.
That's perfectly compatible with moving a lot.

   A lot,
This has nothing to do with renting vs owning, or even with second mortgages, but is primarily because supply of dwellings did not keep up with demand. The UK, especially the greater London area, has seen a lot of immigration, and on top of that there is the ongoing reduction in family size. So more and more dwellings are needed, but supply has not kept up.

   Restriction of mortgage is not 
   "doctoring the symptoms" 
Yes it is, because it neither reduces demand for, nor increases supply of dwellings.
Re:America Needs Small Apartment Buildings by Nursie on Monday April 03, 2017 @07:20AM (#14021968)
>> That's perfectly compatible with moving a lot.

So what? People who don't want to move a lot find they must keep paying someone else's mortgage as they can't get their own.

>> Yes it is, because it neither reduces demand for, nor increases supply of dwellings.

If buying up housing is made, by whatever means, financially less attractive to those who already own homes then of course this tackles demand for purchases and allows more people who are forced into renting the ability to buy their own home.

Re:America Needs Small Apartment Buildings by mafribe on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @06:37AM (#14031188)

   as they can't get their own.
As I said, it's important that not everybody who might be able to afford monthly rates gets a mortgage, for otherwise you'd get too many defaults, leading to financial instability. And very few tenants rent for the whole duration (typically 25-30 years) of a mortgage.

Finally nobody needs to own their dwelling -- renting is fine. I rented most of my life, and so did German chancellor Merkel.

   someone else's mortgage
As I've pointed in previous posts, that's fine, for they provide a valuable service, that can be summarised as a "risk transfer". That needs compensation.

Finally you seem to think that there is a difference between a first and second mortgage: the first being given by magic first-mortgage-fairies out of the goodness of the lender's heart and the second out of sheer greed to oppress people like you. Well, I recommend a quick calculation how much you overpay on the property if you get a first mortgage, vis-a-vis a cash purchase.

   forced into renting the ability 
For some bizarre reason you (like many others I have discussed this subject with) are unwilling to admit that the price of dwellings whether paid by rent or mortgage repayment, is primarily (indeed almost exclusively) determined by supply/demand; the solution to high prices is to build more. It's almost like there is some deep-seated investment in the status-quo that is needed to stabilise your world-view. I recommend to let go of your deep seated resentment and instead learn about the social function of credit.
Re:America Needs Small Apartment Buildings by djmobley on Saturday April 01, 2017 @08:17AM (#14011771)
> Dwellings should be purchased only by those who are very likely to be able to afford this -- even in the event of unplanned and costly life events like illness, children, the dwelling needing costly and unexpected repair etc.

Highly leveraged buy-to-let empires are, on the other hand, the paragon of financial sensibility?

Much as private landlords are famed for keeping their properties in good repair?

Re:America Needs Small Apartment Buildings by mafribe on Saturday April 01, 2017 @09:42AM (#14012062)

   Highly leveraged buy-to-let empires
No, au contraire, house-acquisition should always come with a substantial deposit.