I just think there's a lot of people who will take any buzzword and angrily throw it at things they don't like.
I'm continually amazed by the things I see described as "political correctness", and "clickbait" or "virtue signalling" are all the same as "fake news" in common usage. They all translate as "stuff I don't like or agree with and is therefore bad" and any genuine meaning they may have once had has been stripped.
Well said. Are people savvy enough now to see through that?
Absolutely not. The internet has turned "I read it somewhere" factoids into a constant barrage of crap that is addictive and unfulfilling and kinda rage inducing. I'm hoping sometime in the future-ish that people will wise up, but its very hard when all of your media is tailor-made to keep you just pissed off to demand more.
Jump back before the web and Snopes and it was extremely difficult to even verify a story was fact or not. Facts usually meant going to a library and finding a book that was written years before. Even then, just establishing that the author's name was real was a long and very rough process.
I agree, we have come a very long way and are much better off today. This is hardly a crisis, just growing pains.
Exactly. So we (as a society) no longer have time to chew on things and think rationally. Instead, it's a race to speed of reaction / wit. It's an emotional race condition.
1) New media becomes the elite's puppet just like old media.
2) New technology will disrupt and destroy old and currently new media and create decentralized social media where fake news will be the norm and the elites will lose control of information.
3) New uncensored platform appears to appeal to a general need of people wanting to see what they want to see which again reopens the debate.
The first is more likely than the second. But for the first time in a very long time the second option has a chance.
2) already the case. it's called world of mouth. we just use technology to propagate it now. We never had so many chat apps, social networks, content sharing services, etc.
3) this I want to happen, but every attempt is not only hard to use, but also used for very illegal/immoral stuff that makes it the target of regulations, preventing it from becoming popular. And even if it ever reach popularity, it can cross a threshold making it full of trash like the previous medium, and we would have to restart again. Maybe we should create a system that is hard to get it, to prevent people that are not interested enough to come and trash it.
> Well said. Are people savvy enough now to see through that?
This is the obvious critique you could give any media that claims trying to filter out falsehoods.
You can either trust nobody (which many people have unfortunately decided to do) or listen to the various news providers and see who makes the better case for you to trust them.
I don't know that Google and Facebook makes a worse case than so many other outlets?
This is not something I can follow. Trump got the most screen time of any candidate, Clinton included (Sanders got the least of the top 4).
If the media was supposed to "stop" Trump, why did they pen so much ink and cut to Trump's random assertions in the middle of major policy positions of his adversaries.
Based purely on a "google fight" comparison of screentime, it was clear who the media wanted to win, and who would win.
Just saying Trump had more screen time is a small picture of what the media have been doing to Trump. The lack of screentime for Clinton was a benefit as we saw. We actually saw correlation with lower national polling the more screen time she got. The more she was under wraps (remember the LONG countdown since she had had a press conference, it had been something like 250 days I think). Many talking heads were saying that was on purpose.
Such a contrast to John Kerry's swiftboating... Somehow Trump repelled any smear attempts. Personality? Media? Society?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reagan%27s_Neshoba_County_Fair...
http://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php/Fake_news
There was some usage earlier in the 20th century, 1920 - 1950 or so.
https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=fake%20news&ye...
Fake news is an offshoot of the web being an advertising space with a seemingly unending supply of brain hacked human bots.
Facebook and google played a huge part in spreading clickbait and fake news titles and and now all of a sudden they are trying to "stop" it lofnl.
Getting your desired message heard and accepted is still a pretty strong motivator - though yes, this does deincentivize the purely 'fake news for profit' camp.
"simply"?
I don't use Twitter much. But was searching the term a while back and saw in Google auto-complete of "fake news " CNN poped up as the 4th line. And still does, I just checked. I found that fascinating for some reason. Here is a $1B+ in gross profit mass media business reduced to being the only explicitly named news company in the Google search suggestion box for "Fake News".
There is spin and editorial bias all around...
read between the lines and investigate the editorial and philosophical slant and you will see this very quickly.
Two recent examples.
* https://familyinequality.wordpress.com/2017/03/09/more-bad-r...
The media lost a lot of credibility from the second Iraq war which (almost to the publisher) they were cheering for. So when Washington Post (among others) started the Ra Ra for invasion of Syria to topple Assad more than a few eyebrows went up.
The public might be generally uninformed and uninterested but they aren't flat out stupid. And memory isn't quite as short as is apparently believed in some quarters.
This leaves an information vacuum. Which predictably is filled with anything that can match up with what people already "know" or otherwise want to believe.
Less is more when it comes to propaganda. Make it unreasonable and it all stops working.
I'd thrown quotes around the term to indicate some level of irony / metameaning: the term was intentionally borrowed and adapted, to make a point, and one which Chomsky's first readers would fairly likely have been aware of. Chomsky's use of the phrase has now almost certainly eclipsed Lippmann's, one of the occupational hazards of re-working this palimpsest of social consciousness we're all engaged in.
The moment I heard the word "fake news" I recognized it as the big red flag for this transitional period. As expected, the term was appropriated instantaneously by opposing political groups because we all at some subconscious level realize what is happening and understand just how powerful the term "fake news" can be right now. It perfectly eclipses with the idea of consumer retention in media organizations.
Part of what makes that idea so plausible to me is that there's no need for conspiracy. It's not the "mainstream media setting out to trick people" and it wouldn't be "google and facebook setting out to trick people." It's also not the government (or any other body) coercing the media into toeing some policy line.
The factors that result in "the manufacture of consent" are tangled and hard to pin down. Most of them boil down to internalized assumptions leading to the inability to think objectively about geopolitics.
* Traditional mass media has failed at manufacturing consent (stealing Chomsky's title here because I like the book and it fits). Election was lost to a TV personality even though mass media was supposed to prevent it. Google and Facebook didn't waste any time after noticing this market vacuum and signaled they are ready to be the new manufacturers of consent. "Pay us money and we'll properly inform people of your favorite brand/policy/candidate and block competing brands/candidates. Don't rely on TV news anymore. Come to us". That was a very good move on their part.
* Fake news term was a good PR term. It works well as a slogan, is short and very expressive. However it was appropriated by others. Disarming by appropriation is an interesting technique. So now the same media companies talking about fake news are defending themselves from being labeled as such. It went so far that WaPo journalist explicitly asked everyone to stop using the term as it apparently is backfiring too much: https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/style/its-time-to-r... I think studying how appropriation happened so quickly and effectively is worth it just as much as the effect of lizard people or chemtrails on the outcome of the election.