News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Classroom Technology Is Costing More Than Its Worth (... by germinalphrase on Thursday March 30, 2017 @05:32PM (#13999069)
I'm a high school teacher. I've worked in rural/urban/suburban districts with wildly varied student demographics and school resources. The largest tech-related improvements to my teaching have not come from the availability of "edtech" - but from run of the mill productivity software (Email/Google Docs/etc) and students having reliable access to a computer/internet.

I wasn't familiar with K2 Audiovisual before reading the article, so the "free unlimited training" angle doesn't resonate; however, the base argument being made is sound. Our tools need to support the work we do; if they are a distraction or impediment then they will be ignored. I freely admit that there are some interesting edtech tools being developed, but too many of these tools introduce significant redundant labor, user friction, and/or force me to change my goals/processes to fit their vision of what school is supposed to be.

I have strong feelings on where I think things should go, but I'll just say that there is a lot of low hanging fruit in just helping teachers accomplish the things they already know how to do.

There are a lot of teachers out right now saying, "I know [Kid A] would benefit from [extension/scaffold/resource Y] - but there isn't time to make that from scratch". Teachers know they should be personalizing their curriculum, assessment, and instructional performance for what each kid needs. They will typically even know how to accomplish it.

They are logistically constrained from doing so and most edtech tools aren't offering solutions to the kinds of workflow problems that teachers face everyday.

Edit: I have been drilling down on some ideas with another HN member (andrewwhartion). Principally, focused on teacher workflow tools. Email is in profile.

Re:Why Classroom Technology Is Costing More Than Its Worth (... by panzagl on Thursday March 30, 2017 @05:47PM (#13999171)
Heck, I'd be happy if edtech companies could figure out Sunday evening is not the best time to do maintenance of their gradebook/lesson plan applications. Then I might even be able to convince my wife to get rid of her paper gradebook...
Re:Why Classroom Technology Is Costing More Than Its Worth (... by germinalphrase on Thursday March 30, 2017 @05:53PM (#13999220)
I remember getting locked out of our grade book one evening around 5:30-6. When I chatted with the IT guy the following day he said the edtech company didn't think teachers worked after 3 p.m. so some unannounced maintenance should be A-OK!
Re:Why Classroom Technology Is Costing More Than Its Worth (... by rattray on Thursday March 30, 2017 @06:25PM (#13999443)
> Teachers know they should be personalizing their curriculum, assessment, and instructional performance for what each kid needs. They will typically even know how to accomplish it.

I've been thinking about trying to build tools that let teachers create educational content (incl. formative assessment, etc) and share that content with each other.

Does that sound like what you have in mind? If so, would love to chat.

Re:Why Classroom Technology Is Costing More Than Its Worth (... by germinalphrase on Thursday March 30, 2017 @06:36PM (#13999506)
Creating educational content is a part of it, but (generally speaking) I think we tend to fetishize curriculum content because it's tangible and relatable. We've all seen curriculum content by virtue of being a student, but that doesn't provide a great deal of insight into what else a teacher does in their professional practice.

Curriculum content (or Planning, more generally) is a part of it, but so is lesson performance and assessment. It's a closed loop that should be feeding back on itself. Right now, I'm interested in how teachers could move from a 'creation' to a 'curation' mode of working to give them greater freedom to focus on the high touch elements of the job.

Shoot me an email. I'd be happy to chat more.