Both operate global advertising networks, even if you never log into Facebook or set up an account they are tracking you.(1)
And Google owns the largest mobile OS which is RIPE with tracking / profiling features.
MacOS and Windows 10 also track you, Apple seems a little better - theoretically - about leaking your privacy rights - but MSFT is humming right along not only building a massive data business, but also buying up companies like LinkedIn to improve their ability to target you based on how you're using their OS.
So I disagree on the "we have a choice" part.
You've got me on the "I pay my ISP" but that argument died when Cable started showing ads.
(1) http://bgr.com/2016/05/27/facebook-ads-tracking-non-users-pr...
ISPs are completely different in that they can track me (a) without my consent and (b) with no technical means for me to stop them.
Are you saying that it's ok for FB / Google / Ad Networks to track everything we do and create profiles without opting in SO LONG as I can find some way to block them?
If so I guess I'm not sure what I'm arguing with.
I don't pay Google or Facebook. I do pay my ISP.
That is why Google/Facebook get away with so much. Their users opted-in and gave consent for their information to be used in advertising. If people weren't happy they could choose to not use the website. I don't necessarily have that choice with my ISP especially since in many areas there is no competition.