Re:VPNs are not the solution to a policy problem
by dredmorbius on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @11:42AM
(#13987346)
Re your final sentence, there's a possible third option (though your second has merits): coming up with both rules (law) and guidance (rights, ethics, morality) based on what improves the overall common weal.
Another archaic concept, I fear, most days.
Re:VPNs are not the solution to a policy problem
by lucideer on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @06:12PM
(#13991102)
I guess I was conflating the latter two...
In my mind:
ethics = definition of what improves the common weal
law (should)= enforcement of said ethics
Re:VPNs are not the solution to a policy problem
by dredmorbius on Thursday March 30, 2017 @12:50AM
(#13993006)
Hrm. I'm wondering now if there's a possible ethical case for actions which don't improve the common weal. Or how to resolve conflicts between short-term present vs. long-term future outcomes, or other conflicts -- say, you classic Trolley Problem.
I also wanted to note that your dismissal of Fundamental Rights is a good point. I'm finding far more agreement with the Pragmatists (Dewey, James, etc.) than various Natural / Fundamental Rightists. If only because any idiot can jump up and claim "This is My Fundamental Right" and ... all rational discussion stops.
The idea of basing our sense of right on what is law, rather than basing the laws we write on our sense of right seems to be bafflingly common.