I'd say they're about neck and neck.
The Android Market policy is only great if you are from one of the few countries that can publish app on it. It amazes me that this aspect is always left out while discussing the topic.
Though I know it really doesn't solve the problem the fact that you aren't completely locked out of legitimate phones is nice.
Supported locations for distributing applications: http://www.google.com/support/androidmarket/bin/answer.py?hl...
Supported locations for merchants: http://www.google.com/support/androidmarket/bin/answer.py?an...
Android - Not the 1st choice of the greedy, too many compatibility issues, very open, makes the right moves for mindshare.
By this analysis, Android seems to be on a winning trajectory in the long run.