News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by blhack on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @11:50AM (#1398270)
Does apple not see how this will end up badly for them?

Apple, you're scaring off talented developers; soon the only people who will be left are people who can afford to have gobs and gobs of apps rejected.

Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by steveklabnik on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @12:08PM (#1398334)
Apple's thesis is that supply-side economics don't work. Get a ton of buyers in one place, and the supply will work itself out.

We'll see how it ends up.

Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by xexers on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @03:39PM (#1399113)
Ebay uses this tactic too. Ebay is very good to their buyers but can be ruthless with their sellers. If you google "ebay VERO" you will find thousands of sellers complaining.
Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by chc on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @05:28PM (#1399462)
Sounds like they took a page from Microsoft's playbook. I guess they'd know best how well it works.
Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by steveklabnik on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @05:54PM (#1399579)
Nope, Microsoft has been trying to do the opposite. Remember "DEVELOPERS DEVELOPERS DEVELOPERS?"
Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by chc on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @07:03PM (#1399782)
You're saying Windows' appeal to developers is mainly due to Steve Ballmer embarrassing himself onstage and little or nothing to do with how many users the platform has? I find that quite incredible.
Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by Tamerlin on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @07:58PM (#1399899)
Microsoft has a long history of bending over backwards for developers, even going so far as to put one-off patches in its own libraries to fix bugs in 3rd party applications.
Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by steveklabnik on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @07:49PM (#1399879)
No, I'm saying that Microsoft believes that by bringing the best developers to their side, good apps will be made, and then users will follow. That's why he was screaming that.

Now, you may disagree with the way that they're going about doing that, but from what I understand, tools like Visual Studio really are best of breed. I don't use IDEs or Windows, so I wouldn't know, but that's just what I hear.

Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by chc on Thursday June 03, 2010 @03:53PM (#1402322)
Yes, they have really great development tools. They really do. But no sane person would look at Microsoft and say Visual Studio .NET is the reason they've dominated the PC market for almost two decades. People develop for Windows because everybody uses Windows. If nobody used Windows, VS would not be enough to keep people developing for the platform.
Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by stcredzero on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @11:57AM (#1398294)
Mindshare is The foundation. Apple squanders it. Google gets this part right.
Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by steveklabnik on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @12:09PM (#1398340)
There are lots of complaints about how Android version incompatibilities makes it a pain for developers. The iPhone is a joy to program for, but the app store policy sucks. Android is a bitch to program for, but the app story policy is great.

I'd say they're about neck and neck.

Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by acangiano on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @01:17PM (#1398619)
> Android is a bitch to program for, but the app story policy is great.

The Android Market policy is only great if you are from one of the few countries that can publish app on it. It amazes me that this aspect is always left out while discussing the topic.

Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by wwortiz on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @01:45PM (#1398725)
Well at least you have the option to publish an app outside of the market, like on it's own website.

Though I know it really doesn't solve the problem the fact that you aren't completely locked out of legitimate phones is nice.

Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by steveklabnik on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @01:20PM (#1398632)
Us Americans can be notoriously American-centric. But you're right. I'll have to remember that for future discussions, thanks.
Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by ableal on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @02:39PM (#1398913)
[searches a bit, finds this]

Supported locations for distributing applications: http://www.google.com/support/androidmarket/bin/answer.py?hl...

Supported locations for merchants: http://www.google.com/support/androidmarket/bin/answer.py?an...

Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by stcredzero on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @12:28PM (#1398430)
iPhone - Has greed on it's side, good environment, not too open, squanders mindshare

Android - Not the 1st choice of the greedy, too many compatibility issues, very open, makes the right moves for mindshare.

By this analysis, Android seems to be on a winning trajectory in the long run.

Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by ThomPete on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @02:28PM (#1398874)
That surely depends on how you define winning.

Apple actually makes money with their mobile products. Not sure do or will do.

Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by chmike on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @12:52PM (#1398523)
The most amazing is that developpers have to pay to develop for Apple. I won't.
Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by hboon on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @01:40PM (#1398705)
That's just a cost of business. Minute in the grand scheme of things.

Unless you are arguing about freedom to put apps on your own device. That's a different discussion

Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by pwhelan on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @06:06PM (#1399618)
However, for someone like me who is starting to develop for a possible startup idea -- I'm starting with Android. If this doesn't pan out, then other dev will be on Android. I'll do iPhone next then others if it pans out, but if it doesn't? Back to Android...
Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by hboon on Thursday June 03, 2010 @01:41AM (#1400506)
I'm not sure I understand. Do you mean you want to start with Android and if it doesn't work out, go with iPhone?

While I understand that currency power can vary quite a bit and have a huge effect here (and I don't know if that affects you), I would say it's generally not a big deal compared to other costs.

But another interesting point is there has been suggestions that the subscription fee be much higher, rather than remove it. I am supportive of this. The reasoning behind this is it helps to filter off a certain class of developers that tends to pollute the app store. Part of it is due to the poor discovery facilities of the app store, but making it more exclusive does have it's benefits, and drawbacks, naturally.

Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by pwhelan on Saturday June 05, 2010 @12:30PM (#1407045)
That was a poorly written post on my part.

I am starting out using Android (getting an HTC Incredible soon as well). If I can get things working well with Android and want to start selling apps and/or start a software company for mobile phones -- I will start out with Android. If things go well enough that I am capable of pursuing another platform as well, then I would do the iPhone next but only after Android success. If I were to fail here, I would stick with Android because of the flexibility and I believe there are more opportunities there. I don't see Apple's ecosystem allowing business software to truly thrive on iPhone/iPad in comparison to Android and others -- I also believe this is intentional.

Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by gte910h on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @12:41PM (#1398466)
Honestly, I'd love too see android be a viable competitor, but until it is, Apple is going to continue reigning.

Android is still ultrafragmented, and none of the tablets are out yet (nor will necessarily be that good when they come).

Half the iPad development I'm seeing looked for is for B2B apps, not consumer apps.

Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by Raphael on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @01:42PM (#1398708)
And how will business apps be viable if you aren't allowed to install your own software?
Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by KingOfB on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @02:32PM (#1398884)
http://developer.apple.com/programs/iphone/enterprise/

Basically this allows side loading of business apps to approved business of a large (500+) size. I'm not sure if the apps need to be approved by apple still, but I'm guessing they would.

Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by gte910h on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @04:53PM (#1399335)
That is not what that program is for. It is only for internally developed applications for use internally. Useless for a vast majority of things.
Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by pwhelan on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @06:01PM (#1399603)
And why Android will likely take over the medical market, because one doesn't have to deal with this nonsense.
Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by gte910h on Thursday June 03, 2010 @02:58PM (#1402151)
Yes, I think you're right there will be a large set of medical vendors who will do this.

Then again, there are a LARGE subset of technophobic doctors who love apple and will clamor for that instead.

Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by pwhelan on Saturday June 05, 2010 @12:39PM (#1407059)
That is true. I could be wrong, but I personally feel that Apple is being difficult on purpose. I do not think they want the iPad to become a business device (or be a company that produces primarily for businesses). I think they want to be recreational products company -- which works pretty well for them -- and not have to deal with similar problems that Microsoft with business issues.

I won't be at all surprised if the Android tablets have a similar look & feel to the iPad, but intended for specialized work as opposed to media consumption. I imagine the customization capability of an Android (or other OS) tablet would allow for simple, specialized devices that succeed.

I could be entirely wrong about Apple's paradigm and the resultant prospects. I disagree with many of Apple's decisions, but no one can deny their success over the past few years (though their stock is overvalued right now imho).

Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by gte910h on Monday June 07, 2010 @10:59AM (#1410724)
I believe they're trying to make 100% sure there is not a legal way to get around the Appstore ecosystem, that way they keep their 30% of all sales. If they have to sacrifice b2b apps, I think they're fine with that.
Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @04:25PM (#1399237)
And yet, Apple's opinion on whether an app is appropriate for your company is worthless.
Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by gte910h on Thursday June 03, 2010 @04:19PM (#1402404)
I concur. I hope the courts deem them a monopoly and force them to allow alternate app loading mechanisms to all.
Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by Timmy_C on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @12:07PM (#1398332)
I don't think these types of stories are scaring off anybody since we've been reading about App Store rejections for the last two years and it seems that companies and developers continue to want to make apps for iPad/iPod/iPhone.

It sounds to me like these developers didn't read the app store guidelines. Don't make apps that do what Apple devices can already do natively. They made an app that was too much like a desktop and got rejected. That seems entirely reasonable.

Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by alex_c on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @12:25PM (#1398416)
Trying hard not to downvote just because I disagree so strongly, I don't even know if it's possible to find some common ground for discussion.

It sounds to me like these developers didn't read the app store guidelines.

I'm getting really sick of that defense for Apple. How exactly do you logically go from "Don't make apps that do what Apple devices can already do natively" to "Thou shalt not make a cool picture frame app"?

Yes, it's entirely the app developers' fault, and Apple can never be mistaken. The allmighty App Store Guidelines CLEARLY spell out for developers what they can and cannot do. They are immutable, all-encompassing, never vague, and impossible to misinterpret. If only developers would READ, we would never see any of these stories.

Argh.

(Have I just been trolled? On HN?)

Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by Timmy_C on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @12:59PM (#1398549)
I'll concede that there may be a jump in logic. And it is upsetting that a developer that plays by the rules gets denied for some unforeseeable reason. But I am tired of reading the same Apple is screwing the developers story. Why so much negativity in this thread?
Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @04:26PM (#1399245)
Its all reflected from Apple, who is torpedoing folks' sales capriciously.
Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by dieterrams on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @01:04PM (#1398569)
> How exactly do you logically go from "Don't make apps that do what Apple devices can already do natively" to "Thou shalt not make a cool picture frame app"?

When you make your picture frame app look like a desktop.

I feel sorry for the guys, because it was certainly unintended. The path they took to adding value to their picture frame app unfortunately shifted the gestalt from picture frame to desktop, and when you're moving in that direction, you might fail to notice the shift. But it is entirely reasonable for Apple to disallow apps that can confuse the UI hierarchy for the user. Obviously, none of us on this site are going to be confused by it, but they have to take a much broader demographic of users into account.

Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by alex_c on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @01:27PM (#1398662)
>When you make your picture frame app look like a desktop.

Can you actually point me to anything in the existing developer agreements or interface guidelines that disallows this? I just looked, and I haven't been able to find anything - but it's not exactly hard to miss something.

Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by dieterrams on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @01:56PM (#1398763)
From the iPhone Human Interface Guidelines - Creating a Great User Interface:

"As you design your application, be aware of the metaphors that exist in iPhone OS and don't redefine them."

I wasn't aware of this specific guideline/rule until just now, having looked for it in response to your question. But I do think it's an easily intuited rule, given a basic understanding of usability. Still, I don't think these guys knowingly violated the rule. It's a weird case.

Even while I think it's reasonable for Apple to reject the app on these grounds, they could certainly do a better job clarifying how rules are applied and reduce developer risk. The most effective way would just be to maintain a listing of all rejections and the rationale behind them.

Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by alex_c on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @03:14PM (#1399028)
I just don't see it. If I sat down today to make an app like this, and read the sentence you quoted, it wouldn't even cross my mind that I might get in trouble. What is the existing metaphor for "picture frame that shows the time, weather, and some other useful info"?

For that matter, where does it say anything about desktops?

It's about as useful as a Rorschach test, or staring at the clouds to understand the shape of Apple's intentions.

Yes, again, Apple's platform means Apple's rules - developers have little to no bargaining power. I just don't want to pretend that the rules aren't completely unpredictable at times.

Edit: I've run afoul of HIG violations before - it's usually relatively minor stuff that can be fixed and should get approved once it's resubmitted. Even "redefining a metaphor" can usually be fixed by changing to more standard controls. It doesn't sound like there's any UI change these guys can make to their app to make it acceptable.

Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by dieterrams on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @07:59PM (#1399901)
> What is the existing metaphor for "picture frame that shows the time, weather, and some other useful info"?

A desktop with a customizable background and widgets. Seriously, if you take a screenshot of that app and go around showing it to your friends, do you think their first impression is going to be, oh, it's a picture frame with widgets?

> For that matter, where does it say anything about desktops?

The "desktop" is a metaphor. You don't have an actual, literal desktop on your computer.

Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by alex_c on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @09:10PM (#1400029)
>Seriously, if you take a screenshot of that app and go around showing it to your friends, do you think their first impression is going to be, oh, it's a picture frame with widgets?

Actually, yes, especially if they're less tech-savvy (part of the assumption underlying this whole discussion is that Apple is trying to protect users from getting confused). It doesn't look like you can interact with it much - you certainly can't put icons on it and use it to launch programs, or have it run in the background and become visible when you close everything else. But that's not even really my point.

>The "desktop" is a metaphor. You don't have an actual, literal desktop on your computer.

Thanks, I managed to get that far on my own. My point is that I still don't see anywhere in the agreements that you can't make an app that looks, if you squint hard enough, like a desktop.

This isn't really going anywhere, and I don't want to spam this thread more than I already have. If you want to continue this discussion, there's some contact info in my profile.

Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by dieterrams on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @10:46PM (#1400239)
I don't know that this discussion has anywhere left to go, but I thought I quoted the relevant part in the HIG already. The desktop is a metaphor. HIG says don't redefine iPhone OS metaphors. The picture frame app invokes the desktop metaphor. The iPhone OS already has a desktop metaphor, in the form of Springboard. Therefore, picture frame app is redefining an iPhone OS metaphor, and the app gets rejected. This is a reasonable application of the rules. You could certainly quibble with it. But reasonable does not imply optimal, or that the rules couldn't stand revision.

Also, this is the sort of issue we can obstinately disagree over without consulting data, but I really doubt that even non-tech savvy users are going to identify a screenshot of this app as a picture frame. I've never seen a picture frame with a bunch of widgets on it, at least until I saw this app. I'd consider it far more likely that non-tech savvy users have seen a computer desktop with widgets on it and a picture for a background.

Re:Apple: Make a desktop, your iPad app is toast by DougBTX on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @02:15PM (#1398839)
It sounds to me like these developers didn't read the app store guidelines.

The app was accepted, and for sale in the store, and only then did it get pulled - so says the article. Not even the unnamed app store reviewers spotted that this app went against the guidlines.