News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by DeusExMachina on Monday March 27, 2017 @12:31PM (#13969128)
Am I wrong or all the issues seem to be not gender related but about management and they apply to both sexes?
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by jetsnoc on Monday March 27, 2017 @12:50PM (#13969349)
I would hazard a guess that a weak manager, manages all employees poorly. However, I would bet a lot of money that, like so many things in life, when you are bad in all quadrants on one thing, you'll likely be bad at other things like managing women. Realistically, they are the nearly the same to manage, but you can do some dumb things to make them feel excluded or make them feel like there is a boys club (probably because there is.)

Susan Fowler's team, for example, a bad manager thought it was a good idea to save costs by not purchasing leather jackets for women on the Uber DevOps team. Spare the few hundred or thousand dollars (even if it were in the thousands) and make your employees feel equal and like they are a part of the same tribe. It's common sense. Pocket change to Uber and it makes people feel comfortable around their coworkers, and they will enjoy being part of a team and being passionate about their work-unit, co-workers and take pride in their company.

Here's some anecdotal evidence. I had a product manager last week tell me she thought it was great that our company bought women's jackets for the team instead of making them wear bulky men's sizes like so many companies she has worked for in the past. That cost me less than $150 for them to set up the plates/screens/whatever with the printer but it bought me thousands to tens of thousands of dollars in good-will. Great investment. For me, this was a small gesture on my part and the companies behalf. But, it went a long way. The ladies on my teams are strong contributors, and it's table stakes for me to make sure they feel included and part of the team. Even if I have to tailor to them. Pun intended.

My direct management of every employee is a little bit different based on who they are, their communication style, how they receive feedback and their work-style. I assume that gender goes a little bit into how I interact with each person on my team and I am willing to admit I probably have some biases but overall if you're already managing your team with a high eq, you'll fare well and create an inclusive team.

Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by mratzloff on Monday March 27, 2017 @12:48PM (#13969324)
It's not like women are aliens with concerns that are completely divorced from male employees. They just have a superset of concerns that also includes the potential for gender discrimination from coworkers and managers.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by mrtron on Monday March 27, 2017 @01:23PM (#13969744)
There are likely a similar set of male specific issues as well, so it seems presumptuous to call it a superset.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by rexpop on Monday March 27, 2017 @01:44PM (#13969963)
This is important. There's a fine line between calling women's needs "special needs" and implying the primacy of maleness.

Indeed, both men and women have a superset of human concerns.

The union is never instantiated.

Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by mratzloff on Monday March 27, 2017 @02:02PM (#13970134)
Supersets are not exclusive.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by Chris2048 on Monday March 27, 2017 @02:17PM (#13970250)
What do you mean?
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by fwefwwfe on Monday March 27, 2017 @02:32PM (#13970393)
Maybe each gender could have a set that's the superset of their common needs. Or maybe it was meant that the superset can equal the original set.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by mratzloff on Monday March 27, 2017 @04:52PM (#13971672)
Correct on the former.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by emodendroket on Monday March 27, 2017 @01:14PM (#13969631)
> Especially as a woman, I worry about being labeled hyper-sensitive, or that my gender will influence a person’s reaction to my feedback (e.g. the perception that women are hysterical).

[...]

> The final straw has typically been something like my manager making an off-hand remark that is thoughtless and rude, or perhaps a project I care about deeply is axed, or I’m denied a raise, or someone I care about at work is sexually harassed or gets fired.

To me these sound like issues that women are more likely to encounter.

Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by Terr_ on Monday March 27, 2017 @08:18PM (#13972939)
I am reminded of this quote from a fantasy book about the gender-dynamics of displaying emotion:

> "If she wept, wasn't it too extravagant; if she laughed, how odd that she should do so at her brother's funeral; if she spoke, he whispered that she was frenetic; if she fell silent, wasn't she grown strangely gloomy? And you could just watch men begin to see what he told them they were seeing, whether it was there or not. Toward the end of his visit there, he even said such things in her hearing, to see if he could frighten and enrage her, and then accuse her of becoming an unbalanced virago."

(The Curse of Chalion, by Lois McMaster Bujold.)

Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by ck425 on Monday March 27, 2017 @01:20PM (#13969710)
I'd say they're issues that are harder for woman to navigate. Not because they're less capable I should add, but because what's considered acceptable behaviour is different.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by emodendroket on Monday March 27, 2017 @01:22PM (#13969731)
Yeah, sure. Either way it is a difficult position.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by briandear on Monday March 27, 2017 @03:57PM (#13971133)
"perhaps a project I care about deeply is axed, or I’m denied a raise... or gets fired"

Women more likely to encounter this? This stuff happens all the time to everyone. I'm not sure how this is something a woman is more likely to encounter.

Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by vkou on Monday March 27, 2017 @06:51PM (#13972541)
They probably aren't, but if they express displeasure about it, the same way that their male colleagues do, some people would interpret that as them being overly emotional.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by emodendroket on Monday March 27, 2017 @04:11PM (#13971262)
I assumed everyone could use their wits and understand what part of that very short except was salient. In fact, I think you have, since you've gone ahead and elided it.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by ruleabidinguser on Monday March 27, 2017 @01:22PM (#13969732)
To me the ones that sound more likely to be encountered by a woman are sexual harrassment, being labeled hyper-sensitive, or worrying that gender would have an effect on communication.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by emodendroket on Monday March 27, 2017 @01:22PM (#13969737)
Yes. I agree, which is why I cited those excerpts.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by ruleabidinguser on Monday March 27, 2017 @01:23PM (#13969743)
I just thought you included some things there that aren't really gendered.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by emodendroket on Monday March 27, 2017 @01:28PM (#13969811)
I just didn't want to go nuts with ellipses.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by hn_throwaway_99 on Monday March 27, 2017 @12:36PM (#13969201)
I had the exact same reaction. Common themes were along the lines of not having confidence in your direct manager, especially in cases where technical folks have been promoted into management positions. I hear this all the time.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by danielneri on Monday March 27, 2017 @12:38PM (#13969233)
Agreed - all of the comments or reasons given are not specific to a particular sex, and I've heard the same laments from men as well.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by fwefwwfe on Monday March 27, 2017 @02:45PM (#13970516)
That was my impression as well. Managers get shifted around to cover up problems and are protected by their superiors. And look at how a lot of low level managers come to be - there's no real training or requirements that are specific to management, they just want to go from dev the management. And there's also next to no oversight for the managers, just, "Did your team hit its goals?" They are the modern equivalent of medieval royalty. I think they person who talked about women leaving the company for better opportunities is probably right.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by lostapathy on Monday March 27, 2017 @12:56PM (#13969421)
Agreed - I am not female, and these are the same reasons I'd be unhappy with a job or leave.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by Zikes on Monday March 27, 2017 @12:36PM (#13969195)
I think there's a case to be made that, in general, women may be more sensitive to some universal tech industry issues which men tend to shrug off or otherwise deal with differently.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by kfrzcode on Monday March 27, 2017 @12:43PM (#13969277)
Do you have any supporting evidence to help build this case? I don't buy it.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by mtreis86 on Monday March 27, 2017 @12:56PM (#13969416)
According to Dr. Elaine Aron, http://hsperson.com there is a similar percentage sensitivity in both genders, 15-20%.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by zer00eyz on Monday March 27, 2017 @01:01PM (#13969478)
Your being down voted because no one wants to hear it, but there is some truth to it.

It isn't so much a biological difference (there may be some of that) but one that is likely a byproduct of how we socialize children [1].

Fixing this issue in adults is a hell of a lot harder to fix than it is in kids.

It doesn't help that software engineering as a whole, is to varying degrees, broken. From how we interview to how we manage projects [2]. We simply have no idea how to build something effective and repeatable within the constraints of the current system.

[1] I could put a million different links here, lets just use this one and you can do your own research after that: http://www.latimes.com/science/sciencenow/la-sci-sn-girls-bo...

[2] Again illustrative example, pick your own poison here as well: https://hbr.org/2008/02/the-experience-trap

Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by Arizhel on Monday March 27, 2017 @03:32PM (#13970905)
Funny how you're being downvoted too. You're probably being downvoted for pointing out the naked truth about software engineering and its utter brokenness.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by kfrzcode on Friday March 31, 2017 @05:23PM (#14008420)
I think this is a more likely scenario -- nurture rather than nature.

Nobody's born with bias or opinions.

[dead]
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by BadassFractal on Monday March 27, 2017 @12:49PM (#13969346)
Old school feminists have been cringing at this trend for a couple of decades at this point. It's unfortunate the newer generations haven't been exposed to where we came from and how we're now regressing back, undoing much of the work they did.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by Zikes on Monday March 27, 2017 @12:48PM (#13969325)
Generalizing, actually. But I don't think that it's necessarily a bad thing.

Taken individually, you'll find folks all over any given spectrum, but if we're going to address "Women in Tech" vs the implicit "Men in Tech" then we can't just say "well the two are exactly the same and therefore there's no discussion to be had."

Of course there's differences between men and women. Different values, different priorities, different sensitivities. Maybe there are issues in nursing and education which men are more sensitive towards, and that's why there's such a larger opposing gender disparity in those fields? That doesn't mean that either gender is necessarily "weaker", just "different".

If we want to help technical managers retain women, then it would be helpful to determine which issues women are generally more sensitive to, even if they're the same issues men have faced for however long but which have not driven them away from the industry.

Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by StargazyPi on Monday March 27, 2017 @12:53PM (#13969389)
Can you pick out any problems in particular pointed out in this article, that are more frequently picked up on by women?

Most of the common ones seem to be a company or manager's words not matching their actions. The sample sizes I've experienced may be fairly small so far (very few female colleagues, as ever), but I've seen men and women leave in equal measure for that type of transgression.

Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by Zikes on Monday March 27, 2017 @01:01PM (#13969480)
I don't know of any studies, anecdotes aren't data, and I don't know of any particular issues listed in the article that might affect women more than men.

The only point I'm trying to make is the obvious one: men and women are different. It's a stupid point, taken at face value, but it's one that seems to get lost every time someone says "but men face those same issues" or "that doesn't seem like a gendered issue to me".

Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by StargazyPi on Monday March 27, 2017 @01:51PM (#13970033)
Yeah, I agree that on aggregate, men and women have subtly different tendencies.

The reason I bring it up though, is that I don't see or experience any particular​ bias around most of the the issues in the article. Most of the points raised really don't seem like gendered issues.

Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by Zikes on Monday March 27, 2017 @02:17PM (#13970254)
We need to find a way to figure out which of those differences are important, then. YC seems to be trying via this Ask a Female Engineer series, but if we ask those female engineers which issues are most important to them in regards to what would drive them away and the answers they give aren't satisfactory, then what conclusions can be drawn?

If the issues listed are largely the same issues faced by men, and if the issues have an equivalent impact on male engineer retention, then the answers are incomplete or we're asking the wrong women. Maybe we should ask female former engineers why they left the industry?

Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by sgustard on Monday March 27, 2017 @12:43PM (#13969270)
I think there are valid examples, e.g.: 90% of my coworkers are male. Men: don't notice. Women: might notice.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by scandox on Monday March 27, 2017 @12:53PM (#13969391)
Um hope I'm not being humourless but obviously if the percentage was reversed then the Men would notice and a majority would be somewhat bothered by it. Especially if they perceived a difference in how they were treated as part of that smaller group...

Isn't this kind of the point? Am I missing summat?

Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by emodendroket on Monday March 27, 2017 @01:15PM (#13969645)
It's probably true that, for the most part, men are less likely to mind, say, crude sexual remarks about women, but I don't think it follows that we should just tell women to suck it up.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by jrubinovitz on Monday March 27, 2017 @12:51PM (#13969364)
If these are your issues as well, you can join in and help fix them. No one is trying to invalidate your problems; this is a call to action for better engineering management practices.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by readams on Monday March 27, 2017 @01:18PM (#13969684)
Except when you interview only women about reasons they leave companies, what you hope to discover is why more women than men might be leaving. This article offers no insight on that question.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by jrubinovitz on Monday March 27, 2017 @02:46PM (#13970519)
I guess we disagree there.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by Yizahi on Monday March 27, 2017 @01:47PM (#13969982)
You are correct. And hiring is also management responsibility (not a job maybe but they are responsible in the end). So bad hires are also management fault.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by logicallee on Monday March 27, 2017 @12:58PM (#13969433)
Well, due to the outrageous skew in gender, I think you have to read these things more deeply. There are offices with 18 or 20 men and 0 women or 1 woman. That doesn't happen statistically - certainly not with the incentives of exceedingly high salaries and a field that is open to all (by means of a computer science undergraduate program.) Look at something that is much harder than becoming a software engineer: becoming an MD in the United States. It has far higher mental and educational requirements; it's simply harder. An MD can learn C++ (to code their medical application) much faster than a C++ engineer can learn even a tiny part of the MD's domain expertise.

Here is the gender breakdown of MD's:

http://kff.org/other/state-indicator/physicians-by-gender/

Women comprise 34% of MD's to 66% men. That is a statistical skew, but nowhere near the 93% male that programmers face. In essence when you reply to a comment here on HN you could carelessly say "he" referring to an OP without referring to their first name, whereas if this were a forum for physicians you would not make that assumption because it's not skewed enough for you to do so. (Here on HN there are lots of female engineers but they don't usually announce themselves explicitly.)

So software engineering has a gender problem. Now we're getting an interview about what some people cite for leaving an industry in which they can make six figures within their first five years, with nothing more than an undergraduate education or the equivalent self-learning of 25% of one.

So it is important to read the interviews extremely carefully and with a very open mind.

For example, what are some of the worst things about being a software engineer: insane hours; intense mental focus (it is impossible not to take your work home with you and I am sure many programmers routinely dream of the tasks they are working on); coupled with bull-pen open space offices:

However, open office plans[1] were not cited by the women in this interview. Zero mentions as far as I can see (I re-skimmed and also searched inline for "open').

The word hour or hours does not occur a single time.

So even though it appears that the issues cited are independent of gender, it is imperative to read these interviews very deeply. There could be more to them than meets the eye.

I don't know what it is, but it has to be in these interviews, lurking beneath the surface. Read more deeply.

[1] such as the monstrosity pictured here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_plan

Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by gurkendoktor on Monday March 27, 2017 @01:53PM (#13970050)
> There are offices with 18 or 20 men and 0 women or 1 woman. That doesn't happen statistically - certainly not with the incentives of exceedingly high salaries [...]

It's entirely possible that I am extrapolating from my own naivety, but do young men really get into software development for the money? I don't think any of my friends were thinking about our future salaries when we started programming after school. It's just this hobby that people will inexplicably pay us money for. I know this sounds like a cliché, but I've never seen data to the contrary.

Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by lazyasciiart on Monday March 27, 2017 @02:37PM (#13970440)
Yes, it is an uncontroversial fact that the number of computer science degrees achieved correlates to the social perception of CS as a path to wealth, and the implication is that some people enrol in CS because they think there is money in it - http://www.geekwire.com/2014/analysis-examining-computer-sci...
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by rarec on Monday March 27, 2017 @01:59PM (#13970117)
There are quite a few who do it for just the money. And there's nothing wrong with that, either.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by angry-hacker on Monday March 27, 2017 @05:32PM (#13971982)
The majority of people I know do it for the passion. Nice salary is a bonus, but I'm 100% the men I know would do the same work even for pennies.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by AnimalMuppet on Monday March 27, 2017 @05:55PM (#13972163)
I used to think, every so often, "Don't they realize that I'd do this even if they didn't pay me?"

But then I got married, had children, the kids grew up and needed braces and cars and college. I really need work that pays well right now, whether or not I like the work.

Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by angry-hacker on Monday March 27, 2017 @07:44PM (#13972809)
I know very well how tough it is... but for a lot of guys, things like that are not a priority. For different reasons... I personally believe this is what makes the difference between women and men. Women tend to appreciate real things like family, kids, healthy lifestyle more than the geeks who are fine with staring a screen all day long.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by emodendroket on Monday March 27, 2017 @09:09PM (#13973157)
It sounds more like the difference between 20-year-olds and older people with responsibilities other than themselves and work.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by angry-hacker on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @06:21AM (#13975403)
Not really, men tend to care more about work than family. That's just the way it is.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by emodendroket on Monday March 27, 2017 @09:09PM (#13973152)
I think a fair number of people major in computer science and get programming jobs because it's a stable job, yes.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by yourapostasy on Monday March 27, 2017 @01:38PM (#13969908)
Does software engineering have a gender problem, or a social validation problem?

It is no secret that women in nations where software engineering is likely to be a significant source of employment are far more socially attuned than men are; whether this is by nurture or nature is grist for another mill at another time. It is also no secret that software engineers rank lower on social validation than doctors. Empirically, look at a sampling of org charts, and statistically, pure software engineers (not counting Fellow-type positions, for example) rarely call the shots. Not that they should as a rule: I'm pointing out the reality.

Regardless of the US reality for doctors, with the constraints imposed upon them by the dysfunctionally-broken US healthcare policies, the social perception of doctors is "doctors call the shots". The phrase "doctor's orders" carries enormous cultural weight behind it.

To empirically test a weak form of this hypothesis, compare the number of women managers who were originally trained as programmers to women software engineers. If there is a statistically significant deviation, then some Maxwell's Demon-like mechanism at work performs a sorting function that emerges this deviation, gradually exerting an inexorable pull upon women programmers into management. A stronger experimental confirmation of this hypothesis would require someone with far more training in such psycho-social factors discrimination to devise an experiment to empirically test.

I'm not discounting the very real challenges women software engineers face. Personally, I have not witnessed first-hand any of the workplace vibe-killers described, and I've been in a lot of different workplaces by dint of my wandering consulting career, but I can believe it happens because I've also seen some really bad behavior in the species, and generally I tend to attract clients with pretty solid corporate cultures. But women tend as a statistical aggregate to pay attention to the nuances of social rankings far more than most men realize, and especially men in software engineering realize.

Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by Chris2048 on Monday March 27, 2017 @02:25PM (#13970337)
Putting "It is no secret" before a claim doesn't validate it, please provide some support/context for "[female devs] are far more socially attuned than men are".

Also, a phrase like "doctor's orders" is common, because most members of the public will have occasion to see a doctor, the profession having existing for a long time. There's no saying "CTO's orders", yet this is obviously a position of power.

Also, your observances wrt men and social ranking could easily be confounded if you don't have a complete knowledge of the filters on the men & women you see in IT.

Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by yourapostasy on Monday March 27, 2017 @04:42PM (#13971579)
Start here, and expand outwards in related searches:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sex_differences_in_emotional_i...

Saying "C-level's orders" doesn't carry anywhere the same weight as "software engineer's orders". Given a technical decision, what weighting is the CFO's decision given over the software engineer tasked with understanding the problem domain? I deliberately chose CFO because it is a common refrain on HN and elsewhere that software engineers are summarily overridden by non-technical management on technical decisions. How frequently are doctors overridden on medical decisions by non-medicine-trained hospital administrators? I don't know the precise answer to that, but doctor/nursing friends don't complain about it.

I'm pointing out a possible line of inquiry that doesn't seem to come up in these discussions. Given the relatively low status of IT in most non-tech companies I work with, compared to Sales and Finance for example (where women are better represented than in coding and technical IT, yet sales and finance cultures can be notoriously misogynist in many orgs), it isn't an unreasonable question to pose whether or not that relative low status of programming turns off women in the general non-tech business world, which vastly outweighs our small echo chamber of strongly-tech-focused companies.

An observation I've been chewing upon. The US pharmaceutical /medical sales environment is heavily represented with women, with a blatantly cynical unspoken industry practice of hiring easy on the eyes women. This is an openly misogynist atmosphere, with getting hit on just a part of their daily sales calls, but women are not driven away by it to the point where beautiful medical sales women no longer is a cliche. Incentives matter. Might there also be the possibility the programming world's negatives outweigh the compensation, and at some point, the compensation can outweigh the negatives?

A related question is why, with so much money on the line, and as direct revenue generators, are so many women programmers in tech-focused companies relating consistently depressing stories of exclusion? In other words, are there no financial consequences for managers mishandling such valuable revenue generators in general, or is it only when the revenue generator are women?

Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by Chris2048 on Monday March 27, 2017 @06:04PM (#13972242)
> Start here, and expand outwards in related searches

No thank you, I'd sooner someone qualified do that.

> it is a common refrain on HN

> I don't know the precise answer ... doctor/nursing friends don't complain about it.

My point is, that this is weak subjective evidence. I do not see the same trends you do.

> it isn't an unreasonable question to pose whether or not that relative low status of programming turns off women

Isn't it? Lets establish that it is true first.

> are there no financial consequences for managers mishandling such valuable revenue generators in general

Does "so many women programmers in tech-focused companies relating consistently depressing stories of exclusion" mean that most women in tech are excluded, or that these stories bubble to the top?

Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by neurotech1 on Monday March 27, 2017 @03:45PM (#13971037)
Quite a few hospitals have women in executive roles, some who are trained nurses, and basically "call the shots" in that role.

At San Francisco General Hospital, At least 50% of the Administrator(s)-On-Duty are women. It's a mixture of MDs, and nurses. In fact, I've only personally met one AOD who is male (nurse). The AOD calls the shots on a daily basis.

BTW one recent CEO, Susan Currin is a nurse & the current CEO Susan Ehrlich, MD are both women.

IMO It's not a validation issue. Companies (Tech or otherwise) have the culture they reinforce, dysfunctional or not.

Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by nickstefan12 on Monday March 27, 2017 @04:13PM (#13971284)
Respectfully, I think you missed the point of the parent comment.

Parent comment says: if `(former programmer) turned manager` is more equal in gender than `programmer`, that might mean there is a sorting function that is pulling women out of engineering and into management.

His/her hypothesis is that being a "regular dev" is not very socially respected, and thus, pushes women to want out at a higher rate than other professions, like say, Doctor.

The fact that Doctor gender ratio is similar to Manager Doctor gender ratio, actually fits his hypothesis.

Not saying I disagree with either of you, just re stating.

Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by emodendroket on Monday March 27, 2017 @09:11PM (#13973163)
It's my observation that there are a lot more women in roles like project manager or scrum master or business analyst than software engineer.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by dragonwriter on Monday March 27, 2017 @03:51PM (#13971083)
> Does software engineering have a gender problem, or a social validation problem?

The two are not mutually exclusive (and, indeed, can be mutually reinforcing.)

Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by spcelzrd on Monday March 27, 2017 @01:19PM (#13969696)
You're wrong. Every industry has management problems. Women leave tech at a rate much higher than they leave other industries. The only conclusion is that tech is a hostile environment for women, or that women are intrinsically unable to perform in tech.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by xienze on Monday March 27, 2017 @01:50PM (#13970019)
> Women leave tech at a rate much higher than they leave other industries. The only conclusion is that tech is a hostile environment for women, or that women are intrinsically unable to perform in tech.

"Men fail to enter [teaching|nursing|child care] at a rate much higher than other industries. The only conclusion is that [teaching|nursing|child care] is a hostile environment for men, or that men are intrinsically unable to perform in [teaching|nursing|child care]."

Which is it, in the areas I listed?

Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by dcole2929 on Monday March 27, 2017 @03:05PM (#13970689)
Seems like the most logical explanation is that [teaching|nursing|child care] are inherently hostile industries for men. Gender norms in America make it so that men aren't generally trusted around children, and face difficulties in navigating woman dominated fields like nursing.

Are you arguing that tech hasn't developed into a somewhat hostile environment for woman because men face difficulties in some industries as well? Because if so that's a poor argument. It's completely possible for both to be true for the same reason while have different underlying causes

Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by lliamander on Monday March 27, 2017 @02:38PM (#13970451)
Interestingly, I've heard women working in those fields lament the lack of male representation. In teaching and child care, some kids just respond better to men. In nursing, it's because men are generally going to have an easier time providing care for patients who are overweight.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by mpweiher on Monday March 27, 2017 @02:42PM (#13970490)
Interestingly, I've heard men working in tech lament the lack of female representation...
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by neivin on Monday March 27, 2017 @03:58PM (#13971151)
I remember reading a study about female teachers grading female students more leniently, while male teachers did not show a bias.

Source: http://cee.lse.ac.uk/ceedps/ceedp133.pdf

Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by Arizhel on Monday March 27, 2017 @03:22PM (#13970816)
You're changing the argument. The OP said that women leave tech at a much higher rate than other industries. You claim that men enter certain professions at a much lower rate. This is apples and oranges.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by xienze on Monday March 27, 2017 @03:28PM (#13970873)
Don't women also enter tech at a much lower rate than men? Because of said hostility issues.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by Arizhel on Monday March 27, 2017 @04:17PM (#13971329)
You have a point there, it can be argued that there's a link. However I do think it's important to compare apples to apples, and not to apple trees. So we should be looking at why men and women leave the industry, and also why they enter.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by DanBC on Monday March 27, 2017 @03:02PM (#13970659)
Each of those professions have considerable effort to increase the numbers of men working in them.

This is a tedious point, and it gets made every single fucking time there's a thread like this.

Use a search engine. You'd find, within a few moments, programmes across all of these industries to correct the gender imbalance.

Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by xienze on Monday March 27, 2017 @03:30PM (#13970888)
> Each of those professions have considerable effort to increase the numbers of men working in them.

And yet the number never budges, and we don't hear the president and the media blasting said industries over their shameful employment ratios day after day.

Instead it's just "hmm yes, that's curious. Well we're working on the problem. Carry on..."

Whereas in tech if the ratio isn't 50/50 there's hell to pay. In comparison there isn't a damn thing being done to address the imbalance in the industries I've listed. Yet women in tech, that's a national crisis.

Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by briandear on Monday March 27, 2017 @04:08PM (#13971243)
The American Counseling Association membership is 80% women. Only 10% of all social workers under the age of 34 are men. 70% of all psychology PhDs go to women. Minority representation is also very tiny. The vast, vast majority of mental health practitioners are white women.

Yet those are professions where sex-diversity has a real impact on society. It's far more serious than the sex of the person writing the code for a fucking social network.

There has been about 1 story in the NY Times about this issue in the past 10 years.

And tech sex-disparity? A near constant stream of articles.

By the way, 1% of carpenters are women and 98% of dental hygienists are women.[1] Is that catastrophic? Does it warrant NY Times articles or endless pontification?

[1] https://www.dol.gov/wb/stats/occ_gender_share_em_1020_txt.ht...

Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by mpweiher on Monday March 27, 2017 @01:54PM (#13970060)
> The only conclusion...

Yeah...no. That's such a distance that "leaping" to conclusions doesn't quite cover it. How about: women are (statistically) less interested in tech? So there is less intrinsic motivation, so extrinsic factors become much more important.

Not entirely coincidentally, that is exactly what surveys starting at high-school age right through professionals leaving the profession show. And "leaving" tech is often "getting promoted to management".

UPDATE: Note that even if this explanation were not the correct one (though I think it is the one that's most correct), it would still invalidate your assertion about other explanations being the only conclusions.

Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by ruleabidinguser on Monday March 27, 2017 @01:25PM (#13969772)
>or that women are intrinsically unable to perform in tech.

The more accurate version of this is "women find less value in tech." It deserves more consideration than it gets. There are differences that aren't just cultural between genders, and its something that should be taken into account when forming a judgement on these issues.

Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by spcelzrd on Monday March 27, 2017 @01:43PM (#13969952)
Or it could be that "tech finds less value in women".

Historically, your argument has been used to suppress women and minorities. It's weird that every time a group doesn't fit into an industry or a culture, that group is not white men.

Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by xienze on Monday March 27, 2017 @01:52PM (#13970041)
> It's weird that every time a group doesn't fit into an industry or a culture, that group is not white men.

Teaching, nursing, child care. Care to take a guess which group doesn't fit into those industries?

Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by ruleabidinguser on Monday March 27, 2017 @02:54PM (#13970580)
I wonder how they can genuinely maintain their position in light of this?
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by mpweiher on Monday March 27, 2017 @01:56PM (#13970080)
Note that women now exceed men as college graduates. Meaning for every profession where men dominate, you must have other professions where women dominate more. Otherwise the numbers don't add up.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by ruleabidinguser on Monday March 27, 2017 @02:58PM (#13970616)
Are you suggesting I have an interest in suppressing women and minorities? The only reason I'd want to do that is to decrease competition, and I can guarentee you that I share the same interest regardless of gender or ethnicity

My comment was out of an interest in not being lied to more than anything else.

Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by kristineberth on Monday March 27, 2017 @04:18PM (#13971336)
I didn't interpret that comment as a suggestion that you have an interest in suppressing women and minorities. But you might have a subconscious interest in maintaining your own worldview, wherein you're part of a group of people that 'gets' or 'finds value in' tech, and others aren't.

The subconscious forces that shape the way people think about these issues are the most pernicious.

Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by ruleabidinguser on Monday March 27, 2017 @05:28PM (#13971931)
I don't usually find subconscious arguments very convincing. They're kind of like appealing to magic, if that were a real fallacy.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by jetsnoc on Monday March 27, 2017 @01:22PM (#13969736)
IMHO, tech is a hostile environment with a lot of poor managers. I think the Peter principle applies to a lot of managers in tech. Promoted past their skill set. Just because someone is a good engineer does not mean they will be a good engineering manager. Managing humans with needs, concerns, ideals and life goals is so very different than managing a code-base. Executive leadership needs to consider this when building teams and figure out how to make and/or recruit good managers.
Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by cookiecaper on Monday March 27, 2017 @02:22PM (#13970308)
I wouldn't scope this down to tech. Incompetence and professional disinterest is by far the norm across all industries.

Career meritocracy is, more or less, a myth. In technical fields, there is a merit baseline that has to be cleared, but after that, any further relationship between merit and position evaporates. That is inescapable. People sometimes think they've escaped it and found the promised land of meritocracy, but they haven't. That usually just means they have a politically-skilled manager who is good at keeping their belief in the fairy tale alive.

I agree that a good engineer is not necessarily a good engineering manager, but I don't believe there are good engineering managers who are not also good engineers.

Re:Ask a Female Engineer: How Can Managers Help Retain Techn... by jetsnoc on Monday March 27, 2017 @11:00PM (#13973698)
I agree, this ain't just tech's problem.