One of the most talked about examples is Piraha[0], a language which doesn't really represent numbers. This is interesting because a study done by Everett and Frank[1] shows that this can actually have effects on cognition, providing some evidence for the Sapir-Wharf hypothesis[3]
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pirah%C3%A3_language
[1] http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0010027708...
Given that there is so much of physics that we have yet to understand (assuming what we think to be true is actually true), and given the infinite possibilities of what forms alien life could take, you can't make any assumptions about what sort of language they'd have. This was a point they briefly tried to make in the movie.
But I'd bet on the OPs hypothesis as well. At a guess, most space travelling species will have had to climb a similar developmental curve to our own - including agriculture (or whatever passes for it in their biosphere, unless they photosynthesize themselves), tool making, metal smelting, nuclear power, etc. etc.
If I had to boil it down to a sentence, Everett's claim ultimately was not that the Pirahã can't think recursively, it's that their language reflects a cultural aversion to referring to things that aren't concretely present, and this impacted their grammar for subordinating clauses.
OTOH, and quite separate from the recursion issue, there has been some really interesting research on Pirahã perception of number. The ScienceDirect link/paper in the parent is well worth your time; it's also here https://www.researchgate.net/publication/5308732_Number_as_a... and background at LanguageLog http://languagelog.ldc.upenn.edu/nll/?p=341
The short of it is that Chomskyan hypothesis has a giant edifice built upon a single central idea. A fraca in popular science (i.e., outside academic journals) arises between Chomsky and Pinker over these ideas. Some unknown researcher announces that his obscure language brings the whole edifice crashing down. Add in a touch of Sapir-Whorf to make accusations of racism credible, and Chomsky's well-known fondness for dismissing critics rather than engaging them in scholarly debate.
Basically, there were two debates (did Pirahã have recursion in the sense that Everett meant? and what constitutes proof or disproof of universal grammar?) that went on simultaneously, while someone apparently took the opportunity to smear Everett with the Pirahã study ban.
I don't believe in the existence of a set containing all natural numbers at the same time, except as an idea to talk about.
Numbers are probably not a good starting point, because they're surprisingly abstract. For example, there's no such thing as 1. You can have one of something, but you can't just have one. Number is a quality rather than a thing. In order to establish communication, you need to start with something where it is completely unambiguous what you're both referring to. You can do this with concrete things, not so much with qualities.
Numbers above one are even harder. There's no such thing as 2. You have a thing, and you have another thing. In order to get to two, you first have to establish the idea of the one thing and the other thing being similar. Then you have to find a way of making it clear you wish to refer to the collection of things, which is an abstract thing. Then, you need to somehow figure out how to make it clear you wish to refer to this abstract quality of quantity about this abstract thing, rather than some other abstract quality about it such as its permanence or utility or orientation.
Compared to this, talking about objects and actions seems a lot easier.d
Neither dogs (Dogs don't(?) think(!) in that as "walking"). You still walk with your dog, and I think most people see a dog walking, and think: "Is walking!"
Even if the way aliens "walk" were more like "swing" them see us moving from A to B. Maybe them translate them as "Moving from A to B".
The we show them "running", and them translate it as "Moving from A to B faster".
Eventually, them see a dolphin, and is moving more like them. Maybe them translate it as "Moonwalking".
Still, different words and concepts from them eventually must equal to our own, and even if are not a perfect 1:1 translation is enough to convey things.
For example, some ancients languages have different words for "Love" but ours use adjectives for them.
"This is eight milk". Cups of milk? Glasses of milk? Cartons of milk? Liters of milk?
One of the things that strikes me, is how we just started with integers and then tried to fit everything into them. I mean they're fine for counting, but kind of a hackjob for measuring. Like sure, integers may exist in reality insofar as there may be one tree, two trees... but what about weight, speed, gravitational acceleration?
An alien species may use entirely different systems for Counting vs. Measuring.
We even found out that numbers may be "complex", have multiple dimensions. Beings exitsting in 4+ spatial dimensions may "write" in 3D; using Platonic solids to represent integers and fractions, and spheres for measurements?
And just as how humans took a while to come up with the concept of zero, could such a hypothetical 4D being have a hard time thinking about the idea of 1?
Symplectic geometry is, similarly, a geometry on differentiable manifolds equipped with a "symplectic form" that generalizes the oriented area spanned by two vectors known in flat structures as the determinant.
Now here's the fun part: Riemannian geometry may exist in 1, 2, 3... dimensions; but symplectic geometry exists in even dimensions only. For example: if you tried to think of a 3D sphere of radius 1, you couldn't pass a 4D sphere through its largest section (a bit like if you couldn't pass a 3D sphere through a circle-shaped hole of same radius.
I forget what was my point initially.
So a funny thing happened. When my eyes first skimmed over that part, I spotted the word "donut". When I read it a second later, it wasn't there.
Something in my brain literally substituted "donut" for "circle-shaped hole" to the extent that it appeared in my vision, for a single processing cycle.
The idea still needs a bit of fleshing out to count for cases when you're working with hundreds of practically identical things, e.g. cells and atoms.
A (hollow) circle lives in 2D space, but is actually one-dimensional. How so? I can continuously map it to two 1D structures, one straight line for the top part and one straight line for the bottom part.
Now, there are moments (such as a cursive "e", for example) where our line crosses itself (so there's a point in two different "regions" of the line), so we can't say that all cursive writing is 1D. But it's darn close to being so.
What's more: even though our characters are darn-close-to-being-1D, the text we write with them is 1-dimensional. Some concrete poetry has tried to be two-dimensional, to little effect, but we mostly have sequential thoughts and a sequential language -- and only 1D structures can be sequential.
I assume you meant 2D there. I kind of get what you're saying.
What about Chinese/Japanese characters, surely they're not 1-dimensional? Our vision is still 2D though, with the sensation of depth being provided in the processing layer. What might actual 2-dimensional or 3-dimensional "text" be like? Say written by 4D beings with 3D eyes. [0]
(the primary topic on this page being systems that we may not relate to, comprehend, or even imagine, after all.)
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four-dimensional_space#Visual_...
If you were to remove the exact point of overlap in our cursive "e", we would have a 1D structure, even if a discontinuous one. And it would still be legible as an "e". This is what I mean by "darn close": infinitesimally so.
I haven't thought this through, but probabily every character in a legible sans serif point can be subject to this removal-of-overlaps process and still remain legible.
As for Japanese: katakana seems reducible to 1D by the same criteria; hiragana is certainly not, let alone ideograms (kanji/hanzi in chinese).
Even humans have languages that don't have numbers above of "one, two, three, many"; so long for generalized numbers being a universal concept.
Sure we use letters and numbers to represent them, and words for many musical concepts, but people have been making music without knowing these and since long before they were codified..
The number line is a continuous stream, right? Carrying on from my earlier comment [0], an alien species could use a smooth gradient of colors to represent numbers; their senses may be such that they interpret a distinct shade, or a "step" or "tick", after a small difference in wavelength/frequency, and they use those steps to represent integers, and a transition between two shades to represent fractions..
So if I want to tell you I want 1 of something, I just show you a deep violet. If I want 2, I "say" a ever-so-slightly less saturated violet. Green may mean a million, and reds would be used for astronomical scales. :)
But they may not "think" in terms of "numbers" as we do; they would just see and imagine colors and associate them with a sense of quantity, or comparison..
I'm sure their spaceships will work just fine.
We tend to deal numbers by turning them into symbol sequences and then applying grammatical rules to them --- we're good at grammar, we have hardware acceleration for it. Digital computers work the same way: the quantity is measured, turned into a number, turned into a symbol sequence, then we manipulate those symbols before turning them back into a number.
But analogue computers work by taking a measurement, representing it directly as a potential, and then performing various analogue operations on that potential to yield another potential. At no point during the operation is the potential converted to a number. (Disclaimer: our analogue computers do use numbers for I/O, because they measure the result potential and express it in ways we can understand, but that's just a UI issue.)
So I can totally imagine an alien technology that manipulated quantities using mathematical operations without having any way to express those quantities themselves other than in relation to other quantities. They could use symbol streams to represent the relationships --- if so, they'd probably get on quite well with algebra --- but the idea of representing the potentials themselves as a power series would be completely alien to them.
And before that, the way we write language, numbers, and music is digital, not analog- despite the fact that we seem to think more in an analog way than a digital one. Come to think of it, even our language is digital, despite the fact that our experiences are not and we often struggle to find the combination of words that will better reproduce the meaning we have in our minds.
Come on, this is HN, how can you not see the advantage of calculating with numbers, and writing down numbers, in place of approximate quantities? And why we converted an entire century's worth of audio and photographic recordings to a digital format?
Machines built by people who think differently will work differently.
As for the fact we're "symbolic creatures", perhaps we are, but again- is it because our brains are natively digital or because we really put a lot of effort in trying to be symbolic? (I don't know whether our brains can be called digital- neural networks seem more analog than digital, but there might be quantization going on at some levels to manage the complexity and the noise of handling analog information.) Maybe symbolic reasoning emerges despite being really hard to master, because it actually manages to grasp some fundamental aspect of reality?
You can have logic -binary or not- to define rules of inference, without defining a particular rule of inference for numbers (measuring quantities).
As someone else sort of implied elsewhere [1], if aliens use mathematics at all, it would probably be easier to reason with them in terms of topology rather than number theory.
However, a major plot point in the movie is that time does not exist and that there is no such thing as causality. In the world of Arrival, there is not a lot of reason to believe that mathematics, logic, and science are capable of bringing us to a true understanding of the universe. It wouldn't work to teach human mathematics to the aliens because human mathematics is weird and wrong.
True, but there is a bound on how much complexity of a concept can differ across axiom systems. Complexity (up to an additive constant) is an objective fact independent of any particular axiom system.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kolmogorov_complexity#Invarian...
Was math so universal that any intelligent species discovered the same math as what humans had discovered? Could there be a universe where irrational numbers were the primitives upon which all mathematics was based, in the same way that humans based all of their mathematics on the prime numbers? Was there a “beautiful” universe in which irrational numbers did not exist, and all patterns were simple? Perhaps there was a universe which lacked electromagnetism, and, even as our universe had atoms whose changing bonds explained all physical phenomena, perhaps that other universe had manifields whose changing coordinate systems, mapping one dimension to another, explained all physical phenomena? Our own universe was composed of 3 solid dimensions and then a fractional 4th, but what would life be like in a universe that consisted only of fractional dimensions? How could aliens imagine something whole, if nothing in their universe was whole? How could such aliens imagine a “one”, an integer, something complete? Perhaps in such a universe the integers were the most difficult concept in math, only discovered after thousands of years of careful research. Perhaps there was an alien far smarter than any of his peers, admired even as we admire Einstein, whose greatest accomplishment was the discovery of the formula “1 + 1 = 2”, a formula which, in that universe, was so utterly counter-intuitive that most adults went through their life without ever understanding it.
No book, sad to say. The movie is based on a Ted Chiang short story named "The story of your life."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Story_of_Your_Life
There are a number of books out there named "The Arrival" or a variation thereof, but they have no connection with the movie.
I only post this to keep people from ordering books with that name, hoping to acquire more depth than the movie provides. Not to disparage the movie, which I regard as first-rate.
Numbers are more abstract. They couldn't just draw a number "2" for example. Or show 2 apples because it might seem they are just talking about apples and not numbers.
> by using names and human concepts...should start with concepts that are universal: mainly numbers
The way the movie do this make perfect sense.
Some examples:
- Your tribe in a island make first contact with a advanced civilization. You started with 1 coconut. Then you show 2 coconut.
Your advanced emissary think the coconut must the base food of your tribe, and yours is very poor.
Numbers rarely are used in abstract ways. Similar in how (big mistake) people try to push programming as math (because "obviously is math").
- You have a baby. To communicate with him, you start with some universal laws that hold across the universe:
"A monad is just a monoid in the category of endofunctors"
What you consider universal laws, the most important and more universal, maybe are not the first kind of laws others are thinking. And this guys do everything in perl, his civilization have discovered functional programming and discard them 20 centuries ago as annoying.
- Your atlantian civilization, the most advanced that ever existed in earth, make first contact with the atlantian civilization on Andromeda. Both talk in perfect english, obviously. Correctly, you understand this guys must be smart, so you start conversation like this:
"So, do you guy know that the Spirit is the same than the Everything times the light instant and the light instant?, and the light instant is perfect and stay always as before or after?, and you spaceship obviously feed on spirits?"
Both civilization know than E=mc2, but his notations, names and ways to transcribe them not align at all. And probably sound incorrect nonsense.
- You start teaching them your numbering system. Them get confused why 2 + 2 is equal 4.
Your numbering system is decimal, them is not.
Then you try to showcase that exist several systems.
Them start get more confusing. Why your result contradict each time?
----
Not matter how I look at this, walking, eating, you, me, my name, your name look like far more universal and more sensible things to know than anything related to science or tech.
So start with "one" and "two" or maybe even the concept of nothing vs something. Work your way to vocab words related to space and time (again, I would think these universal concepts considering the aliens traveled with the goal of getting to earth), then get into specific human concepts like me vs you vs third person.
They essentially worked through language in the same way you would work through language with a human baby, which I think would get you no where when talking to an alien race (who are "adults" at this point you would assume, and have their own fully developed world views).
Just my 2 cents though.