Re:Patent Troll: Bloomberg calls it what it is
by starkfist on Tuesday June 01, 2010 @07:25PM
(#1396465)
The true entrepreneurial lesson to be learned from this is that the opportunity is ripe for someone package up the side effects of these patents into complicated IP instruments nobody understands and become the market leader in patent trolling derivative trading.
Re:Patent Troll: Bloomberg calls it what it is
by megablast on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @12:26AM
(#1397094)
Hopefully he can start up a patent market, where moms and pops can invest in patents they like the look off, in the hope that one day they will make them some money back.
That way, say when a new company like Apple gets into making phones, there can be a rush on mobile oriented patents.
Re:Patent Troll: Bloomberg calls it what it is
by aaronblohowiak on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @01:20AM
(#1397186)
that's pretty much what patent consortiums like MPEG are.
Re:Patent Troll: Bloomberg calls it what it is
by bartl on Tuesday June 01, 2010 @08:49PM
(#1396642)
This does indeed sound a lot like the Broken Window Fallacy (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window): despite the money changing hands, having to pay to have a broken window fixed, is not good for the economy, because now people are forced to pay for costs that serve no benefit.
Re:Patent Troll: Bloomberg calls it what it is
by EugeneG on Tuesday June 01, 2010 @08:43PM
(#1396623)
Liquidity is a decent point.
R&D is very risky. A company invests a lot of money into R&D. A large part of this money produces no return. Some of this money may yield patents. A liquid market means that a company can take some of these patents (which may be worth nothing in an illiquid market) and convert them into cash. Liquidity increases return on a firm's investment into R&D and so may have the consequence of incentivizing corporate research spending.
Re:Patent Troll: Bloomberg calls it what it is
by pyre on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @03:46AM
(#1397383)
But what happens with these patents once they are sold is just as important. It's short-sighted to only be concerned with the initial sale of the patent. [i.e. Loosening restrictions on the sale of weapons would increase liquidity for weapons-makers, but it's not necessarily a 'good' thing because you have to consider what will happen with these weapons after they are sold.]
Re:Patent Troll: Bloomberg calls it what it is
by meric on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @09:47AM
(#1397892)
If the patent system works, i.e, it is beneficial to society for technology companies to sue people who infringe their patents, then I think allowing "non-practicing" entities will be beneficial also. By allowing companies to sell their patents and then licensing it back royalty-free, they are able to "out-source" their responsibility to shareholders (and the law?) to sue anyone who infringe on the patents. This means they can concentrate on R&D and making things people want, which is what they are best at, rather than spending time worrying about and looking for patent infringements. This latter task is better reserved for people good at lawsuits and doing them at lower opportunity costs, like the founder of Round Rock Research LLC.
That is, if the patent system works.
Good fucking god. Have we become so beholden to capitalist buzzwords even after the financial wizards stole reams of cash from the taxpayers and made it impossible for the middle class to afford a home, that we unequivocably deem "liquidity" to be a good thing?
Before making such statements there has to be some analysis of whether the sale of said "asset" is beneficial to society in any way—doubly so in the case of government-granted monopolies. Otherwise we may as well just jump right to urging serial killers to become hitmen so we can add liquidity to the murder market and boost the GDP.