News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Russian police arrest anti-corruption leader, hundreds in... by snitko on Sunday March 26, 2017 @06:38PM (#13963766)
What really pains me is that people participating in such protests don't understand neither the dynamics, nor history and are thus unnecessarily hurt. Any leader stays in power so long as he knows where the money is (controls money flows), pays his key supporters and the army/police.

Money in Russia is primarily oil money and this source is not drying up any time soon. More importantly, the people fighting for changes are rarely the ones who can later be in power, but are rather used by others to get in power. Even if they get in power, it's very unlikely they are good at managing economy and the country as a whole, since they didn't understand the dynamics of political power in the first place.

For those interested I highly recommend reading "The Dictator's Handbook: Why Bad Behavior is Almost Always Good Politics". It's eye opening for anyone who thinks protesting or voting can change anything.

Re:Russian police arrest anti-corruption leader, hundreds in... by Const-me on Sunday March 26, 2017 @07:08PM (#13963890)
In Ukraine, the corrupt leader controlled a lot of economy, paid his supporters, and supported the police just fine (Army decided to stay neutral).

People overthrew him regardless.

I have close friends and relatives in both countries, and I think in Russia that’s nearly impossible. Not because of oil and gas revenues, because people. They aren’t dramatically different, the cultures are close, but there’s some statistically significant difference.

Russians are more inclined to believe they cannot change anything, just like the opinion you expressed in your comment.

Ukrainians are more inclined to stand against violence. When riot police brutally attacked peacefully assembled teenagers in Ukraine in 2013-nov-30, it sparked the main phase of the country-wide protests. Today riot police brutally attacked peacefully assembled teenagers in Moscow, and the only reaction I see so far is on Facebook.

Re:Russian police arrest anti-corruption leader, hundreds in... by snitko on Sunday March 26, 2017 @10:34PM (#13964717)
This is absolutely completely untrue. I've heard this so many times from my Ukrainian friends. If Russia and Ukraine swapped populations somehow, but leaders would remain the same I guarantee you would do absolutely nothing in the circumstances in Russia.

In Ukraine, the leader was weak, the opposition well financed, the quality of life was less satisfying than in Russia and there was a clear window of opportunity. And even then it all ended up with a different group of corrupt oligarchs taking control. In essence, nothing changed in Ukraine, at least for the better. You can't blame war for everything.

> Russians are more inclined to believe they cannot change anything, just like the opinion you expressed in your comment.

First of all, this would clearly be considered racist by some, but luckily I don't care. I'm sure there are people in Ukraine who are also level-headed and realistic enough to consider how real politics works. Again, I highly recommend the book to get a realistic perspective.

Finally, just to make it clear, I do not support any kind of war and have nothing against Ukraine wanting to break ties with Russia.

Re:Russian police arrest anti-corruption leader, hundreds in... by sillysaurus3 on Sunday March 26, 2017 @06:39PM (#13963769)
Any leader stays in power so long as he knows where the money is (controls money flows), pays his key supporters and the army/police.

Related: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rStL7niR7gs

Re:Russian police arrest anti-corruption leader, hundreds in... by snitko on Sunday March 26, 2017 @06:40PM (#13963780)
This video is actually based on the book.
Re:Russian police arrest anti-corruption leader, hundreds in... by snitko on Sunday March 26, 2017 @06:44PM (#13963797)
I should also add I watched Mr. Navalny speak and he is:

1. Not a good speaker. 2. Very populist. 3. Doesn't understand economics. 4. His whole campaign is based on criticism of the incumbents and he has very little to show for how he would actually manage the country or solve problems. 5. He is against returning Crimea to Ukraine (which is understandable, given the general sentiment in Russia, he'd lose a lot of votes)

Re:Russian police arrest anti-corruption leader, hundreds in... by Grue3 on Monday March 27, 2017 @06:01AM (#13966334)
I think the more HN appropriate angle on this story is that none of Russian top news networks have reported on the protests, even though thousands of people had attended them. Imagine US networks not covering Ferguson protests, or Occupy Wall Street. Most people wouldn't even know it happened.
Re:Russian police arrest anti-corruption leader, hundreds in... by joyofdata on Monday March 27, 2017 @06:28AM (#13966457)
HN is not just tech stuff - it is anything discussed by techies. This absolutely belongs here.
Re:Russian police arrest anti-corruption leader, hundreds in... by shmerl on Sunday March 26, 2017 @06:28PM (#13963712)
Re:Russian police arrest anti-corruption leader, hundreds in... by hjrnunes on Monday March 27, 2017 @04:12AM (#13965946)
European media reported opposition rallies happen all the time.

Rallies need permission from city authorities to happen. Permission was applied for the Kremlin square and denied. Alternative venues suggested by authorities and refused by organisers, which maintained original plan thus engaging in illegal activity and defying authorities.

Organiser and several protesters arrested.

Is there a country where protest marches and rallies do not need permission from, at least, city authorities to happen?

Re:Russian police arrest anti-corruption leader, hundreds in... by notatoad on Sunday March 26, 2017 @06:32PM (#13963734)
Is this relevant to HN? I normally kind of like the off-topic stuff that ends up here on a sunday afternoon, but this seems especially reddit-worthy.
Re:Russian police arrest anti-corruption leader, hundreds in... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday March 26, 2017 @06:40PM (#13963777)
> Is this relevant to HN?

I thought it was relevant, given the changing culture of protest across the world and their tie-ins to encryption.

This, and HN's attempts to "de-politicize" this forum, remind me of a conversation a Russian-born Valley-based venture capitalist. I asked why Silicon Valley seems less politically organized, and thus influential, at the grassroots level than New York City.

"New York is closer to D.C.," she observed. But that doesn't explain why the average person from Silicon Valley has less influence than, say, from Los Angeles.

We're Alan Turings, she said. Turing wanted to be left alone to make things. Unfortunately, his government didn't see similarly. First, with World War II and later by prosecuting him for his sexual orientation. Being able to be left alone to make things is a luxury, a delicate balance almost unprecedented across human history. We will lose the privilege if we refuse to even discuss it.

Re:Russian police arrest anti-corruption leader, hundreds in... by toomuchtodo on Sunday March 26, 2017 @06:39PM (#13963770)
Geopolitical issues aren't off topic. Some of the best hacking takes places outside of silicon.