News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber CEO linked to escort bar visit that resulted in an H... by ThomPete on Saturday March 25, 2017 @07:17AM (#13955048)
Whats sexist about going to an excort bar?
Re:Uber CEO linked to escort bar visit that resulted in an H... by tptacek on Saturday March 25, 2017 @11:19AM (#13956053)
Stipulate (gingerly) that an individual or group of friends going to an escort bar isn't sexist. The problem is doing it as a company group function. If you reread the story, you'll see that we know about this because there was a woman executive from Uber in the group, and she was upset at being dragged along.

This has come up at a number of other companies (usual context: strip clubs). Stipulate that going to a strip club isn't sexist, but it's clear (to me at least, and, if I need to add this: to the lawyers) that it's sexist to generate social and professional pressure for women employees either to go to a strip club or to miss out on professional functions because attending a strip club is untenable.

[dead]
Re:Uber CEO linked to escort bar visit that resulted in an H... by tptacek on Saturday March 25, 2017 @12:13PM (#13956270)
First, I'd appreciate it if you could dial civility up just a little bit. Even among friends at a bar, I'd be taken aback by a retort like "I'm sure you think that's an argument".

Second, the issue here is much simpler than you're implying it is. You can't have a work function among executives at a strip club. It's not hard to see how doing that would exclude women. That's what this particular Uber executive is complaining about.

If you'd like to argue that this was in no way a work function, I think we'd be on solid ground to debate something where reasonable people might disagree. I'm less convinced that it's reasonable to disagree about whether companies should be allowed in practice to stage work events at strip clubs.

Re:Uber CEO linked to escort bar visit that resulted in an H... by ThomPete on Saturday March 25, 2017 @12:50PM (#13956461)
I am not sure what you mean with civility. It wasn't meant to be agressive. I literally meant I am sure you see it as an argument.

Not sure why going to a stripclub would exclude women. In what way does it do that? And even if it did it does not mean it's sexist. Furthermore the idea that important business talk happens at strip clubs is hard to see and that would be the primary reason for claiming stripclubs are excluding women. Otherwise mens clubs, golfing with your buddies and so many other things might as well be considered sexist.

Second of all if you really want to make that argument then you need to ban gender divided bathrooms at the executive level if there are too many men. Because a lot of talk happens in the bathroom too and there women are actually excluded to participate. This is a real issue and the chances of work being discussed here is many times higher.

So to claim that an occasional stripclub visit is excluding anyone and/or sexist is IMO a rather unsubstantiated claim.

I am well aware that it's the source of many tabloids and you can get in trouble for it but it has nothing to do with sexism.

Re:Uber CEO linked to escort bar visit that resulted in an H... by tptacek on Saturday March 25, 2017 @12:51PM (#13956471)
No, your rebuttal here doesn't make sense. It would obviously not be acceptable to hold business functions in a men's washroom, either.
Re:Uber CEO linked to escort bar visit that resulted in an H... by ThomPete on Saturday March 25, 2017 @01:24PM (#13956622)
Yet thats what happens and why women at some places have pushed for gender neutral bathrooms. So yes it makes perfect sense.
Re:Uber CEO linked to escort bar visit that resulted in an H... by tptacek on Saturday March 25, 2017 @01:38PM (#13956683)
What's your point? As I said upthread: businesses that have a pattern of making important business decisions in the men's bathrooms do in fact have a gender discrimination problem, and will in fact be shouldering legal liabilities for allowing it to persist.
Re:Uber CEO linked to escort bar visit that resulted in an H... by ThomPete on Saturday March 25, 2017 @01:48PM (#13956718)
My point is that you are confusing things. Neither a visit to a stripclub by a bunch of colleagues nor a gender divided bathroom means that there is any discrimination happening and that if we are to follow your logic a lot of things would be called discrimination which luckily they don't.
Re:Uber CEO linked to escort bar visit that resulted in an H... by tptacek on Saturday March 25, 2017 @02:05PM (#13956800)
So far you haven't provided an example of something similar that is "luckily not considered discrimination". The one example you have provided is in fact (and has in the real world been) grounds for a discrimination claim.
Re:Uber CEO linked to escort bar visit that resulted in an H... by ThomPete on Saturday March 25, 2017 @02:11PM (#13956824)
Which doesent make it that anymore than playing soccer or golf in a countryclub does.
Re:Uber CEO linked to escort bar visit that resulted in an H... by tptacek on Saturday March 25, 2017 @02:19PM (#13956872)
Conducting business within your company in the context of a men's only sporting league or athletic club is also clearly legally problematic.
Re:Uber CEO linked to escort bar visit that resulted in an H... by ThomPete on Saturday March 25, 2017 @03:02PM (#13957053)
And since a stripclub is not mens only and you have no indication what so ever that they were conducting business there, quite the opposite actually, your whole attempt to show that this could be sexism falls flat. You are basically just saying everything can potentially be considered sexist. Which is a quite trivial claim and has nothing to do with this discussion
Re:Uber CEO linked to escort bar visit that resulted in an H... by tptacek on Saturday March 25, 2017 @03:03PM (#13957059)
I can't find anything new to respond to in this comment so am content to let the discussion rest here.
Re:Uber CEO linked to escort bar visit that resulted in an H... by ThomPete on Saturday March 25, 2017 @05:05PM (#13957564)
And as long as the article doesn't even remotely support some of the reasons you gave for why going to the stripclub should be considered sexist I think that would be wise.
Re:Uber CEO linked to escort bar visit that resulted in an H... by Eridrus on Saturday March 25, 2017 @08:43AM (#13955350)
It reinforces the notion that women are objects to be paid for?

Sexist or not, this seems highly inappropriate for a work outing, and definitely adds more evidence to how Uber does not strive to have an inclusive culture.

Re:Uber CEO linked to escort bar visit that resulted in an H... by ThomPete on Saturday March 25, 2017 @09:50AM (#13955619)
How on earth do you get to that conclusion? I get that uber is a toxic environment but it's not because they go to an escort bar and they don't go to an escort bar because the environment is toxic.

Plenty of people do that and they work in great companies. They mostly do it because they are men and some men like to do that.

It sounds more like the a priori acceptance of some feminist branding of sex for money as turning women into objects to be paid for.

Everyone who takes money to do something for others are assets for them. That's why they pay the money. Whether thats working in an escort bar or working 100 hours a week in a startup, the only difference is that one job is paid much much better.

Re:Uber CEO linked to escort bar visit that resulted in an H... by tptacek on Saturday March 25, 2017 @11:21AM (#13956060)
Again: normal people do go to strip clubs (not so sure about "escort bars"). But normal companies don't have what are effectively company outings to strip clubs, and plenty of companies have gotten in trouble for doing that.
Re:Uber CEO linked to escort bar visit that resulted in an H... by ThomPete on Saturday March 25, 2017 @12:51PM (#13956468)
Sure they've gotten in trouble but the claim is that it's sexist. Thats not why they got in trouble though.
Re:Uber CEO linked to escort bar visit that resulted in an H... by tptacek on Saturday March 25, 2017 @12:53PM (#13956477)
It is sexist in exactly the same manner as the (I think you thought deliberately absurd) example you provided downthread, in which a company held business meetings in the men's bathroom.
Re:Uber CEO linked to escort bar visit that resulted in an H... by ThomPete on Saturday March 25, 2017 @01:30PM (#13956651)
I didn't say they held business meetings in the bathroom but nice strawman.

I said that men meet and talk in bathrooms which excludes women at places where there are very few of them.

So it wasn't deliberately absurd it was just deliberately different to make a point about the absurdity of the argument that excluding women from being in the company with men from their company is sexist per defition.

Furthermore where in the article does it say that they were conducting a business meeting at the strip club? Nowhere what so ever. So you are basing your argument on things that didn't happen.

Re:Uber CEO linked to escort bar visit that resulted in an H... by tptacek on Saturday March 25, 2017 @01:37PM (#13956678)
I didn't say that you did. Again: I know we disagree about a lot of this stuff, but I'm taking pains not to jab at you, and would appreciate if you'd reciprocate.

It is in fact the case that if a company has a systemic practice of making business decisions in the men's bathroom, women working at those companies will have a cause of action against that company.

Further: I made clear to you downthread that on the matter of whether the trip to the club was a business matter at all, reasonable people might disagree. I conceded up front that you might have an argument there --- I strongly disagree with that argument, but it's one you can reasonably make.

Re:Uber CEO linked to escort bar visit that resulted in an H... by ThomPete on Saturday March 25, 2017 @01:51PM (#13956732)
Yes you did

"(I think you thought deliberately absurd) example you provided downthread, in which a company held business meetings in the men's bathroom."

Furthermore you haven't pointed to a single example of any kind of business being conducted at the strip club.

It's not something I would drag other people to do, but it has nothing to do with gender discrimination to go to a scrip-club especially not when the purpose seemed to be picking up women not discussing the latest strategy.

Re:Uber CEO linked to escort bar visit that resulted in an H... by tptacek on Saturday March 25, 2017 @02:05PM (#13956796)
Once again: if your argument is that a group of company executives can decide on a whim to go to a escort club together and not have it be a business function, I can agree to disagree with you. I'm simply rebutting the notion that attending an escort club can't be on its own intrinsically sexist. Clearly, it can be.
Re:Uber CEO linked to escort bar visit that resulted in an H... by ThomPete on Saturday March 25, 2017 @02:13PM (#13956840)
who said it can't be? Another strawman.
Re:Uber CEO linked to escort bar visit that resulted in an H... by tptacek on Saturday March 25, 2017 @02:19PM (#13956868)
You literally asked the question:

"Whats sexist about going to an excort bar?"

I'm simply answering the question. Please stop being so rude.

Re:Uber CEO linked to escort bar visit that resulted in an H... by ThomPete on Saturday March 25, 2017 @03:05PM (#13957067)
You seem to be the rude person here. The context is pretty clear, i dont need a lecture in theoretical scenarios that have nothing to do with this case. Nowhere is feels pressured or businnes meeting at an escort bar mentioned.
Re:Uber CEO linked to escort bar visit that resulted in an H... by Eridrus on Sunday March 26, 2017 @06:41AM (#13960089)
You don't have to accept that these bars are sexist to see that they are exclusionary, which is really enough for them to be inappropriate.
Re:Uber CEO linked to escort bar visit that resulted in an H... by ThomPete on Sunday March 26, 2017 @12:22PM (#13961499)
Inappropriate for what?

For business? Sure but I don't see that mentioned anywhere and so we are back to opinions not clear cut definitions of what is inappropriate.

Re:Uber CEO linked to escort bar visit that resulted in an H... by dukeluke on Saturday March 25, 2017 @09:22AM (#13955488)
This post is actually an example of a conflict between multiculturalism and equality. In many cultures, this bar is acceptable, and in others it is seen as demeaning. When there is a conflict between the two, how do they choose what is right and wrong?
Re:Uber CEO linked to escort bar visit that resulted in an H... by Eridrus on Sunday March 26, 2017 @06:32AM (#13960062)
IMO equality trumps multiculturalism. It's the same argument about whether tolerant people should tolerate intolerance, and to me the answer is that they should not.

I expect that this is the side corporate America will come down on as well since discrimination is quite common in a lot of cultures including our own.

Re:Uber CEO linked to escort bar visit that resulted in an H... by ThomPete on Sunday March 26, 2017 @07:49AM (#13960315)
Equality in what though?

With regards to tolerant people tolerating intolerance well thats kind of self defeating isn't it? If you already have defined who you don't tolerate you are exactly the people you claim to be against.

But how would you make that work?

I am intollerant of lazy people, of islamic terrorism and entitled people. Am I on your list? Is it ok now for you to intollerant of me?

It's an unfortunate reality that tolerance is such a misunderstood concept because it gives us stances like yours who assume things are simpler than they actually are.