News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Most Expensive Weapon Ever Built by Animats on Saturday March 25, 2017 @12:44AM (#13954142)
The VTOL version of the F-35 is insanely complicated.[1] Here's a Harrier doing the same thing.[2] VTOL runs the cost way up, and VTOL with stealth is even more expensive. (Can't do both at the same time, not with all that stuff sticking out.)

The justification, though, is not unreasonable. If you want to project air power, and don't have VTOL, you need a full sized air base or carrier within range. With VTOL, you can operate from a smaller firebase or a small carrier.

The US's small carriers are the USMC's amphibious assault ships, the Wasp and America classes. The US currently has 9 of these, and is building more of the America class. Each is a self contained package of military power - about 1700 Marines and their gear, helicopters, VTOL fighters, Osprey VTOLs, landing craft, and missiles. Everything you need for a small war. That's where the F-35 was supposed to be useful.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zW28Mb1YvwY [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2pweY5y5eRI

Re:The Most Expensive Weapon Ever Built by lhopki01 on Saturday March 25, 2017 @10:08AM (#13955695)
Of course if the marines were allowed to build full sized carriers they would and wouldn't need VTOL.

And if the army was allowed to build close air support aircraft they would and wouldn't use Attack Helicopters.

This isn't a matter of efficiency it's a matter of services jealously guarding their turf.

Re:The Most Expensive Weapon Ever Built by BJBBB on Saturday March 25, 2017 @12:31PM (#13956353)
Marine aviation is very small, and they are naval aviators, so Marine squadrons do carrier duty. But they are small and mobile, and want to be able to operate from remove patches of dirt. Helicopters in general, and the F35B and V22 in particular are principle enablers of CAP. And Marines generally do not want Air Force over them as they tend to prefer Army and Naval aviator brand of CAP.

The Army is not allowed jets per the same post WWII regulations that separated the Army Air Corps to form the Air Force service branch.

Re:The Most Expensive Weapon Ever Built by lhopki01 on Saturday March 25, 2017 @06:49PM (#13957938)
The massively shorter range of VTOL aircraft completely negates any advantage of being stationed closer to the front that small patches of dirt give you.
Re:The Most Expensive Weapon Ever Built by sbierwagen on Sunday March 26, 2017 @12:02PM (#13961405)
Note that both the Harrier and the F-35B are generally STOVL, not VTOL. Dry weight of the B is 32,000lbs, and globalsecurity says the lift fan can only produce 39,700lbs of thrust. A single JDAM weighs 2,000lbs. Doesn't leave much room for fuel. V-22 is the same way.
Re:The Most Expensive Weapon Ever Built by leggomylibro on Saturday March 25, 2017 @02:57PM (#13957021)
Full-sized carriers have theirr own issues, though. Maybe you don't want to use a small city with its own protective navy and full-sized air force for every expeditionary mission. Smaller cruiser-sized platforms could fill a more flexible role while being abpe to be in many more places at once.

Like, if you play EVE, would you really rather have a more widely-available Thanatos if it meant giving up Ishtars?

Re:The Most Expensive Weapon Ever Built by lhopki01 on Saturday March 25, 2017 @06:46PM (#13957921)
VTOL aircraft have bigger issues than full sized carriers. The Harrier that the Marine's currently use has a terrible range and payload.

Also there are carriers that carry full sized aircraft that are smaller than US Marine carriers like the French Charles de Gaulle.

The US marines would like full sized aircraft carriers just like the army would like CAS jets.

Re:The Most Expensive Weapon Ever Built by sidegrid on Saturday March 25, 2017 @11:30AM (#13956096)
Why not combine the forces.
Re:The Most Expensive Weapon Ever Built by Animats on Saturday March 25, 2017 @02:02PM (#13956784)
The Marines do, which is one of their strengths. The USMC has ground-pounders, tanks, rotary and fixed wing air, and landing craft. Doctrine is to use them together under one commander. "All operations are combined operations." The package is intended to win small and medium sized battles without needing other resources for 2-4 weeks. That's enough to deal with many crises. For the big jobs, it gives the Big Army time to position its heavy resources. Right now, there are four US Navy amphibious assault ships at sea, loaded up with Marines, weapons, and aircraft, spread around the world just in case they're needed in a hurry.

The U.S. Army, when not in combat, is a resource pool. Deployment involves pulling together various units and equipment from different locations and sending them somewhere. The mix of units depends on the task. "Moving Mountains", by Gen. Gus Patronis, describes how this was done for the Gulf War.

Re:The Most Expensive Weapon Ever Built by lithos on Saturday March 25, 2017 @12:14PM (#13956276)
The social conflict would be the same as combining IBM, Dell, and Google.
Re:The Most Expensive Weapon Ever Built by BJBBB on Saturday March 25, 2017 @12:44PM (#13956421)
Agree. Each service branch is a different culture. The different branches' cultures are reflective per their mission and the resultant qualifications and standards for the 'type' of person that would be able to pass the training requirements respective of the mission. Air Force and USMC are the most profoundly dissimilar, where a more appropriate analogy might be a comparison of Google to IH.
Re:The Most Expensive Weapon Ever Built by Ericson2314 on Saturday March 25, 2017 @01:27PM (#13956633)
This is true. But as a civilian, I'm not sure why I'd give a shit.

Moral wil sink for 20 years, but any major conflict should snap 'em out of that.

Re:The Most Expensive Weapon Ever Built by unit91 on Saturday March 25, 2017 @04:06PM (#13957312)
Combat veteran here (Afghanistan, 2012). You have no idea what you're talking about. War is very hard on morale. You're away from your family killing people who are trying kill you, hoping to live through it, and most of all hoping that in the right moments you'll be able to summon all your strength and courage​ to fight bravely and honorably. In spite of all your hopes and fears you see death in the most inglorious circumstances. I had a friend of mine who was killed while taking a dump. Try that for a morale booster.

To answer your question directly, I hope you care because you vote, and because regardless of what you think we fight and die for you because we believe your life and liberty are precious. Mistakes and inefficient equipment and organizational structures cost lives (maybe mine, certainly others). And if a "better" organized military only results in us being a little happier day-to-day, is that really so much to ask?

Re:The Most Expensive Weapon Ever Built by Ericson2314 on Sunday March 26, 2017 @12:01AM (#13959072)
To be clear I was working under the (unjustified, hypothetical) assumption that while tradition gives us the separate branches, a different organization would be more effective in the long run.

Obviously moral is very important, I don't mean to dispute that. I was saying I don't care for the branches' cultural continuity prima faciae. A temporary drop in moral is bad, but if the new organization really is better the drop should only be temporary and moral should recover long term.

The second part of my argument is a mere whip that if we got ourselves into a "big moral/self-evidentally important war", that would bost moral more than the reorg would hurt it.

Re:The Most Expensive Weapon Ever Built by Ericson2314 on Sunday March 26, 2017 @12:11AM (#13959099)
A good concrete example of this principle is integrating women into all combat rolls. In the short-term I imagine this absolutely will distablize the culture and probably hurt moral in certain quarters. In the long term, I hope the culture(s) will change and moral will recover.
Re:The Most Expensive Weapon Ever Built by wtbob on Saturday March 25, 2017 @08:17PM (#13958225)
> But as a civilian, I'm not sure why I'd give a shit.

I hope you give a shit about the effectiveness of theprotection others are delivering you. The sort of person who works well in the Air Force is not the same sort of person who works well in the Army is not the same sort of person who works well in the Navy is not the same sort of person who works well in the Marine Corps. The jobs of the services are fundamentally different, as are the mindsets & aptitudes of those in them.

The Air Force is a mid-century corporation: it has metrics and deliverables (literal deliverables), and is oriented towards long-term sustainment of whatever it is asked to do. It's very, very good at building an organisation to do the same thing for years, with good morale for its people because they are never tasked too hard, and excellent safety results because that's important when operation a mid-century concern. On the downside, most of it is not really all that flexible, and its culture is not, in the main, oriented towards enduring long-term suffering (there are exceptions). If you have something you want done, you ask the Air Force. If you ask an Air Force officer to secure a building, he'll buy it.

The Army is big. Really big. You just won't believe how vastly, hugely, mindbogglingly big it is. It's all about mass, directed according to very strict orders. If you need to pave 1,000 miles of road, the Army Corps of Engineers will do it, according to its plans. If you need to garrison a town, the Army will do it, all nicely and neatly and according to plan. If you have a problem someone's faced before, you want the Army. There's a field manual for everything: a field manual for improvised munitions (because of course there's a manual for improvisation), a field manual for executions, a field manual for skiing. If you ask an Army officer to secure a building, he'll surround it and not let anyone in or out without authorisation.

The Navy is a floating, violent industrial plant. It never does the same thing twice; it's always going to one new port or another. It's not as laid-back as the Air Force, nor as regulation-bound as the Army. It speaks an entirely different dialect of the English language, for no particularly obvious reason. If you have a problem that no-one has ever seen before, you ask the Navy for a solution. If you ask a Naval officer to secure a building, he'll make sure a sailor sweeps & swabs the decks, and puts out the lights.

The Marines are a cult. They worship at the shrines of Chesty Puller, Dan Daly, Smedley Butler & John Basilone. They think that war is a racket, but they don't particularly care: they enjoy the racket. If you absolutely, positively need it dead or destroyed within 24 hours or less, you call the Marine Corps. If you ask a Marine to secure a building, he will take it by force, killing or capturing everyone inside. If he does a particularly good job of it, he'll be deified and join the pantheon along Puller &c.

If you put someone well-suited to the Marine Corps in the Air Force, he'll be fired for getting into a little trouble on the weekends. If you put someone well-suited to the Navy in the Army, he'll go out of his mind from boredom. If you put someone well-suited to the Air Force in the Army, he'll be miserable and quit. If you put someone well-suited to the Army in the Navy, he'll just be generally appalled.

The different services have different roles, different strengths and different weaknesses. Those differences are why they are well-prepared for a major conflict.

Re:The Most Expensive Weapon Ever Built by Ericson2314 on Sunday March 26, 2017 @12:14AM (#13959107)
See my comments on the first response. I don't mean to dispute that the branches have different cultures today or moral is affected by cultural continuity.
Re:The Most Expensive Weapon Ever Built by wtbob on Sunday March 26, 2017 @11:56PM (#13965079)
It's not so much morale (although that is important) as it is about effectiveness: someone effective at Marine combat won't be effective at Air Force combat, and vice versa, and similarly for the Navy and the Army. They're different jobs, and different people do well in them.
Re:The Most Expensive Weapon Ever Built by Ericson2314 on Monday March 27, 2017 @12:05AM (#13965113)
Certainly different jobs require different skills, but do the jobs inherently sort themselves into a few branches which ought to operate with some independence? I don't know the answer, but it doesn't strike me as an obvious yes.
Re:The Most Expensive Weapon Ever Built by lithos on Monday March 27, 2017 @07:09AM (#13966670)
I couldn't write this without insulting a branch purposefully or accidentally. Well done.
Re:The Most Expensive Weapon Ever Built by toomuchtodo on Sunday March 26, 2017 @01:26AM (#13959337)
Phenomenal comment! Thanks for taking the time to write it out.
Re:The Most Expensive Weapon Ever Built by pbhjpbhj on Saturday March 25, 2017 @07:44AM (#13955141)
>If you want to project air power, and don't have VTOL, you need a full sized air base or carrier within range. //

Or unmanned aircraft?

Re:The Most Expensive Weapon Ever Built by ufmace on Saturday March 25, 2017 @04:30PM (#13957425)
I don't think being unmanned will change much in terms of basing requirements. You still want to deliver the same weapons to the same targets with the same warheads, and that will take an aircraft of roughly the same size, weight, and fuel capacity to carry. You may not need pilots, at least in the aircraft, but you still need a big groundcrew to service engines, mechanical components, control computers, weapons and fueling, radar, etc. And you'll still need a big collection of spare parts, plus fuel and weapons.

What you get is the ability to stay aloft for longer, since no pilot needs a break, but you're still limited by fuel, albeit with ariel refueling, and weapons, if you're actually going to carry out attacks. You also get increased maneuverability from not having to keep a pilot alive and healthy, not sure how much that will help anything though. Maybe they'll be able to dodge missiles a little better? Probably the biggest change is that it's much less politically provocative to shoot down a drone, and much less politically risky to lose one, so they may be deployed more readily and in larger numbers.

Re:The Most Expensive Weapon Ever Built by astrodust on Saturday March 25, 2017 @05:07PM (#13957577)
Cheaper missiles, lighter planes, more minimal crewing requirements, it all adds up.

A large portion of the carrier space is dedicated to serving the enormous number of people that are needed to operate it. If you had only 20 people it could be a much smaller vessel.

Re:The Most Expensive Weapon Ever Built by Jdam on Saturday March 25, 2017 @11:06AM (#13956003)
Exactly. Except that establishing air superiority with unmanned aircrafts is decades away.
Re:The Most Expensive Weapon Ever Built by DrStalker on Saturday March 25, 2017 @07:55AM (#13955175)
They still need to take off from somewhere and land for refueling, though I expect they can have a much shorter take off and landing than a manned fighter even if they are not true VTOL.
Re:The Most Expensive Weapon Ever Built by ceejayoz on Saturday March 25, 2017 @09:33AM (#13955526)
That's where unmanned refueling aircraft come in.
Re:The Most Expensive Weapon Ever Built by throwaway7645 on Sunday March 26, 2017 @04:48PM (#13963193)
Which could be hacked. Would you like China driving an F35 w/ a nuke?
Re:The Most Expensive Weapon Ever Built by valuearb on Saturday March 25, 2017 @03:43PM (#13957212)
We have almost as many carriers (19) as the rest of the world combined (21). We have nine 100,000 ton carriers, the biggest carrier on the "rest of world fleet" is 55,000 tons. Our small carriers are bigger than the majority of carriers in the ROWF.

But if course we need more carriers because we aren't at war and no one risks attacking us for fear of nuclear annilation.

Re:The Most Expensive Weapon Ever Built by pacaro on Saturday March 25, 2017 @04:40PM (#13957466)
Doesn't look like the F-35 is going to be able to VIFF then!

Popular culture has it that this was a key capability of the Harrier in the Falklands War, where they were up against the much faster Mirage, but VIFFing allowed the harrier to unpredictably move out of a pursuing Mirage's flight envelope.

Re:The Most Expensive Weapon Ever Built by sceew on Saturday March 25, 2017 @12:01PM (#13956225)
F-35 is actually STOVL. Short-takeoff, vertical landing. Which allows it all of the flexiblity you mentioned above, but in combat the F-35 does not take off vertically.
Re:The Most Expensive Weapon Ever Built by deelowe on Saturday March 25, 2017 @12:22PM (#13956306)
What's the definition of short take off? In the video, it appears to lift off from a stand still.
Re:The Most Expensive Weapon Ever Built by ju-st on Saturday March 25, 2017 @12:50PM (#13956454)
It is capable of vertical lift off but the aircraft can lift more payload when rolling for a short amount (e.g. https://youtu.be/lu7ZUVXs6Ec?t=45s )
Re:The Most Expensive Weapon Ever Built by pacaro on Saturday March 25, 2017 @04:33PM (#13957439)
My understanding is that vertical liftoff is mostly for show. Operationally it tends to be more STOL, the V is only there for when the mission parameters demand it, at the expense of the heinous fuel cost of (particularly) take off
Re:The Most Expensive Weapon Ever Built by astrodust on Saturday March 25, 2017 @05:08PM (#13957585)
It's more like it can't lift off vertically with a full load of weapons and fuel, so you need to skimp on one of those two things to do the straight vertical takeoff.

The Harrier works on the same principle.