"DDT isn't terribly harmful and is useful" vs "DDT bio-accumulates much more than other pesticides"
As with most such debates, there are points on both sides, but that doesn't mean the arguments have equivalent weight. As someone with no real knowledge on the topic, I'm inclined to trust the latter case that I've heard all my life but keep an open mind that what I've been told could be wrong.
If you (that is, someone thinking that way and not you, above poster) are trying to sway me (as a proxy for a lot of people with similar thinking) to the "DDT should be brought back" side, you need to address the issue that is convincing me. Saying that people have eaten large doses of DDT or that DDT is super-useful for fighting malaria or parasites in, say, Africa, can be true without contradicting that it accumulates in environment and causes harm to some wide groups of animal life.
Even the linked article (which I'll admit to only skimming) doesn't say the charges against DDT were WRONG, just incomplete, particularly in what survives into the modern thoughts on the matter.
Personally I think those are overly broad claims and demand strong studies and proofs.
[1]: http://scienceheroes.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=309&Itemid=263I will say Carlson's claims were overdone. The book title, "Silent Spring", implies the extinction of all songbirds, and most songbirds were not affected by DDT.
But here's the facts: all birds which eat fish or other birds had a massive dieback which reversed in the 1970s. For example, consider Bald Eagles and Golden Eagles. The former eats fish and died off; the latter eats mammals and did much better. It wasn't just one species: every fish-eating bird died off: cormorants, pelicans, Bald Eagles, egrets. If DDT does not explain this die-off and recovery, what do you propose to explain this preferential near-extinction?
The "DDT is Innocent" train of thought is, in my view, wishful thinking on the part of some who want environmentalists to always be wrong. They were right on this one.
> Studies published in Poultry Science found chicken eggs almost completely unaffected by high dosages of DDT.
> In 1998, Royal Society for the Protection of Birds researcher Rhys Green published a study in the Proceedings of the Royal Society B which found that eggshell thinning of some bird species had begun 50 years before the introduction of DDT.
Despite some studies linking a byproduct (DDE) to moderate egg thinning in sensitive raptors, the ban was an overreaction.
There is a lot of FUD surrounding DDT, and it costs lives. Spraying DDT on the internal walls in my country would save hundreds of lives.
The study by Rhys Green is entirely misrepresented. He studied four species of thrush. Thrush don't eat fish, nor do they eat other birds. That literally supports what I said: DDT affected specific species of birds based on whether or not they consumed environmentally-concentrated sources of DDT.
Nor have you explained why DDT alone, rather than a less-stable alternative, must be used.
I'm sorry, but you have bought into FUD. We all do that sometimes. Today was your turn. I'm not looking forward to my next turn.
Of course, some interest groups like to present a different picture, as usual with environmental issues.
Now with the recent Zika virus outbreak many kids were born with microcephaly (crippled brains half the normal size), many people died or were crippled by Guillain–Barré syndrome.
I'm not saying DDT is a safe chemical, just arguing that its ban is exaggerated.
It seems plausible to me that we're talking about poisons of all sorts being cleaned from the environment, not just DDT.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethan...
http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/232
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1046/j.1474-919X.2003....
Many are behind a paywall but here are some with abstracts we can read:
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0742841397...
http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/23273747.2016.11...
Also, there may well be a valid debate about when or when not to use DDT, but the link you cite does not inspire confidence.
Are these enough citations to bury yours with?
https://www.google.com/search?q=damage+by+ddt&oq=damage+by+d...
You can easily track down a few dozen studies that will inform you about the damage.
There is a reason why nearly all the governments of the developed nations have moved to block or limit the use of DDT.
Try this, for that matter:
https://duckduckgo.com/?q=climate+change+due+to+ddt
or
Is that incorrect?
plenty of pesticides that aren't tainted
... as far as we know... now.Sometimes, adverse effects of pesticides aren't known (widely enough, anyway) until decades later. Dursban comes to mind and still pops up in new papers.
In addition, if the "taint" is incorrect then DDT could be a wonder.
(Actually I am not DDT fan, but I do know how to make an argument)
There are plenty of fine pesticides now which work well on mosquitoes. Since the newer pesticides decay, they don't build up in the food chain. Talk of bringing back DDT is silly.