News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by hackuser on Thursday March 23, 2017 @06:28PM (#13944926)
> The team had a quota of 420 dashboard frames per shift but seldom made more than 350

For me, one of the most thought-provoking expressions of the perspective of the factory worker came from the Studs Terkel book, Working, where he interviewed a factory worker and UAW local president named Gary Bryner in the early 1970s or late 1960s. Bryner:

"In that little book of quotes I have: 'The workingman has but one thing to sell, his labor. Once he loses control of that, he loses everything.'" ...

"They use time, stopwatches. They say ... We know it takes so many seconds to shoot a screw. We know the gun turns so fast, the screw's so long, the hole's so deep. Our argument has always been: That's mechanical; that's not human."

"The workers said, We perspire, we sweat, we have hangovers, we have upset stomachs, we have feelings and emotions, and we're not about to be placed in a category of a machine. When you talk about that watch, you talk about it for a minute. We talk about a lifetime. We're gonna do what's normal and we're gonna tell you what's normal. We'll negotiate from there. ..."

"If the guys didn't stand up and fight, they'd become robots too. They're interested in being able to smoke a cigarette, bullshit a little bit with the guy next to 'em, open a book, look at something, just daydream if nothing else. You can't do that if you become a machine. / Thirty-five, thirty-six seconds to do your job - that includes the walking, the picking up of the parts, the assembly. Go to the next job, with never a letup, never a second to stand and think. The guys at our plant fought like hell to keep that right."

...

I'm not sure how much factory work is still like that, but imagine if that was your job today ... or for 8 hours per day, for the rest of your life.

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by hkmurakami on Thursday March 23, 2017 @08:12PM (#13945519)
I spent 3 months in a automobile parts factory in Japan as part of my new employee training. This was my job for 8 hours a day, less two 15 minute breaks and an hour lunch break.

I started to develop this mind-body separation where I could do the manual labor while completely disengaging the mind towards some daydreaming, because the routine was so ingrained into my body that I no longer needed conscious brain power to move my hands and examine the visual elements of my tools and parts.

Yes we were basically robots. At least the company genuinely cared about improving processes to prevent workplace injuries, even of the repeated stress category.

While their jobs were not the most important part of these people's lives, it did enable them to provide well for their families and pay for their hobbies and pursuits (I think a blue collar job at a tier 1 Toyota group supplier pays better than a below average whitecollar job in Japan). And they seemed to have a sense of pride in their work.

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by lazulicurio on Thursday March 23, 2017 @07:17PM (#13945225)
I work at a manufacturing company in the Midwest and, to me, the confusing part is where the modern push to treat workers like machines is coming from. In school, we were taught how Taylor was the "father" of scientific management, but that his ideas had mostly been superseded by those of Deming, who was a huge contributor to the post-war manufacturing miracle in Japan. And yet, the management at my current company---and from what I gather, many others---is decidedly Taylorist. It's like a race to the bottom where the prize is... something? I'm honestly not sure.
Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by a3n on Thursday March 23, 2017 @08:00PM (#13945468)
It's short term quarterly thinking. Get my review and bonuses and get out. If any manager thinks the company will be around, he doesn't really care. He's not in it to build a company or a legacy or pride, he's there to get his money and get out.

Driving your workers as fast as possible maximizes your bonus. Who cares what happens in ten years?

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by jz87 on Friday March 24, 2017 @01:54AM (#13946978)
Yeah if you read the article what you see is companies saving $7000 to avoid installing safety devices that ended up causing injuries that costed them multi-million dollar payouts in lawsuits.

The thing is, the incentives to the executives making these decisions is skewed. If they avoid investing in safety equipment, they make their bonuses, which can add up as long as nothing too bad happens. Yet if there is a serious injury costing the company millions, the worst thing that can happen is they lose their jobs. For senior executives, the bonuses can be larger than their base salaries, so the upside is larger than the downside.

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by maxxxxx on Friday March 24, 2017 @09:53AM (#13948892)
I think it's just easier to think that way and measure results. Empowering workers is more fuzzy and hard to measure.
Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by thatfrenchguy on Friday March 24, 2017 @03:22AM (#13947248)
The prize is more money for the shareholders.
Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by brudgers on Thursday March 23, 2017 @06:41PM (#13945008)
In modern manufacturing, a person would be lucky to hold the same job for ten years without being laid off or replaced. Many of these people work for staffing contractors who contract with tier 1, 2, or 3 suppliers and everything is just in time. Even when things are just in time, suppliers often start an assembly line, run it until their warehouse is full and then shut the line down to reduce expenses.

In many parts of Alabama there is are millions of square feet of potential storage space in the form of obsolescent manufacturing facilities.

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by dilemma on Thursday March 23, 2017 @07:18PM (#13945230)
>Even when things are just in time, suppliers often start an assembly line, run it until their warehouse is full and then shut the line down to reduce expenses.

JIT is part of lean. What you describe is short term mass production, not lean and also not JIT because it implies continuity.

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by brudgers on Thursday March 23, 2017 @07:47PM (#13945401)
An auto-plant is probably just in time. As one steps down the tiers, 1,2,3 the more likely batch processing is because lower tier suppliers tend to supply multiple companies at higher tiers and it often makes more economic sense to set up and tear down production lines than to try to run them in parallel.

Having an inventory also means that a hitch in production will incur contractual penalties under a JIT supply contract. The customer doesn't care when the shipping container was loaded with parts at the supplier's facility, just when it arrives at their loading dock.

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by jacquesm on Thursday March 23, 2017 @06:46PM (#13945042)
> I'm not sure how much factory work is still like that, but imagine if that was your job today ... or for 8 hours per day, for the rest of your life.

Sweat shops in Asia time their employees to 100ths of seconds for their tasks. I wished I was kidding, the timesheets for garment manufacture look like top sports results.

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by ringshall on Thursday March 23, 2017 @07:13PM (#13945204)
Do you know of any publicly-available reference for this? It's the kind of stark fact that effectively illustrates working conditions in those factories.
Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by jacquesm on Thursday March 23, 2017 @07:17PM (#13945229)
The movie 'the corporation' actually has shots of the sheets they got from the garbage of a factory (Nike or H&M iirc).
Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by gech on Thursday March 23, 2017 @07:27PM (#13945297)
Is there a fundamental soullessness to certain cultures? Or is it endemic to all?
Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by hackuser on Friday March 24, 2017 @12:20AM (#13946576)
If you look at the labor history in any country, I would guess that the "soullessness", if I understand your meaning, is inversely proportional to how advanced the economy is and how much political power the workers have. The advanced western nations used to have brutal 6-day workweeks and children working in coal mines.
Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by aanm1988 on Friday March 24, 2017 @05:17PM (#13952283)
Which we fought against.

Then the powers started fighting back against unions to the point where it's a horrifying idea.

So people lose their arms and die because of poor training and safety regs. A union means that the guy never touches that machine, that the girl and her team just sit and wait for the maintenance guy.

These fines also seem pretty low.

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by sqeaky on Thursday March 23, 2017 @07:12PM (#13945196)
If it can be done in a productive and enjoyable way, that might not be bad. I am sure that's not how it is.

If I had to work in sweatshop for whatever reason, it would make it suck just a little less if it were done in "events". For example get three people to have a race to build ten pairs of shoes. Take a breather, cheer on another group of employees, maybe a small prize for someone winning such a race. Have timed trials to build the fastest pair of shoes.

Don't take away your employees freedom, encourage them to do what you want, presumably make shoes in this contrived example. If people come up with their own ways to do it fast and they want to do more of it, then just maybe it will actually happen faster.

I think it works better with code. I like competing with my coworkers on optimizing things that pass our unit tests. We each try to optimize a given snippet of code in a unit test. Whichever is fastest and passes all the tests wins and gets committed.

EDIT - I know its shitty in these sweat shops, clearly what I described wasn't happening. I figured phrasing like:

> I am sure that's not how it is.

and

> it would make it suck just a little less

No need to downvote a silly idea so aggressively.

If someone needs to work in a sweat and if the person running it is decent they will try to make it not suck. That is why most sweatshops suck they aren't run by decent and this wouldn't work. Which is why I even contrasted it with software.

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by aeontech on Thursday March 23, 2017 @07:21PM (#13945256)
You really don't think the workers would see the "competition" as a transparent ploy?

FWIW, this was a well established practice in Soviet Union - top factory performers got prizes, medals and other rewards for beating expectations. [1][2][3]

Of course, this also tends to tempt the management to raise the required quotas over time.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socialist_emulation [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shock_worker_of_Communist_Labo... [3]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stakhanovite_movement

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by luca_ing on Friday March 24, 2017 @07:10AM (#13948094)
> You really don't think the workers would see the "competition" as a transparent ploy?

Even well-trained engineers miss this "transparent ploy".

Otherwise there wouldn't be such a culture of glorifying long working hours and almost no holidays in the US, or at least there would be much more push-back.

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by meddlepal on Thursday March 23, 2017 @07:29PM (#13945306)
Nobody really cares about whether work can be done in a "productive and enjoyable way". If your company or engineering manager thought they could get away with turning you into human machine because that's your only option then they most likely would or someone else would eventually.

Be very thankful software developers are in such high demand because there will be a time when that little competition will not be viewed as some sort of team morale boosting exercise but just another bit of frivolous spending to be eliminated. It may not happen in mine or your working career, but it will happen eventually.

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by jacquesm on Thursday March 23, 2017 @07:36PM (#13945348)
Funny, it's the software developers that are instrumental in implementing 'gamification' for all kinds of work related activities.
Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by goldenkey on Thursday March 23, 2017 @07:57PM (#13945456)
You mean the ones' who like programming too much and aren't even in academia. And don't realize it's a means to an end (it's a tool to build things.) Yeah those people suck.
Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by FullMtlAlcoholc on Friday March 24, 2017 @06:33AM (#13947942)
I think you're being downvoted because you are somewhat making light of a horrible and brutish reality a great deal of the world's population has to endure so that developed nations can have widgets and experience growth.

The reason that you can have such activities at work is because you are providing a service, software engineering, that has a high demand but is in short supply. Also, this usually isn't done with the goal of increasing productivity... it is done to maintain morale and make the company fun to work at so you dont leave. Not many experienced workers particularly enjoy these races, like employee of the month because it eventually becomes a way to abuse workers.

In a former life, I was a claims rep for an auto insurance company. We had a competition to do the most claims per day at rhe lowest cost. It was terrible. We were mobile, so one component was driving through Los Angeles traffic to someone's car or body shop. It encouraged people to drive like maniacs, skip all their breaks, and to stiff the customer on auto claims, which was shortsighted because they lost customers from us stiffing them and evetually were sued because this competition essentially limited our breaks. These things almost always end in a race to the bottom once labor supply increases or demand for labor decreases.

History is replete with horrific examples of competitions and quotas amongst low skilled. workers/slaves. In the oxymoronic(al) Congo Free State, colonial Belgium enacted a labor policy demanding a quota of rubber. If not met, workers, their wives, and their children would have their hands amputated. Article if you are interested :http://www.hartford-hwp.com/archives/35/181.html

> That is why most sweatshops suck they aren't run by decent and this wouldn't work.

It has little to do with the moral character of people running the sweatshops, although that does not absolve them from being pieces of shit. It has more to do with the economic system, its incentives, and consumers turning a blind eye to the origin of their products. The Stanford Prison experiment showed how normal people could turn into monsters given the right conditions.

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by sqeaky on Friday March 24, 2017 @07:52PM (#13953202)
> I think you're being downvoted because you are somewhat making light of a horrible and brutish reality

That is actually a good reason to be downvoted.

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by jacquesm on Thursday March 23, 2017 @07:18PM (#13945232)
This is not some kind of silly contest. Too slow by a little bit and you're out, also yesterdays 'peak' is tomorrows cut-off.
Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by scythe on Thursday March 23, 2017 @07:23PM (#13945264)
>yesterdays 'peak' is tomorrows cut-off

Obviously such a rule could not be applied for more than a few days. Humans have physiological limits no matter how hard you twist the psychological ones!

I am guessing it is somewhere in between. What may have started as a clever manager's way to motivate employees became another bureaucratic hoop for people to jump through.

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by krapp on Thursday March 23, 2017 @08:29PM (#13945596)
> Humans have physiological limits no matter how hard you twist the psychological ones!

People will push themselves to the brink of death (and beyond, sometimes) when given a choice between meeting a quota and not having a job. The quota can be unreasonable, as long as the company is constantly firing poor performers and training new people.

The gamification is serious business. Any button the company can push, any knob they can twist, any game they can get you to play to get you to work faster, and shave another second off your time, they will push and twist and play.

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by scythe on Friday March 24, 2017 @01:33AM (#13946875)
I was questioning the seriousness of his comment. It is literally impossible to implement the system he described. You will never find talented enough people after, say, six days, regardless of who you hire. I am not claiming that working people to the bone does not happen at all.
Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by FullMtlAlcoholc on Friday March 24, 2017 @06:37AM (#13947966)
Even if the contrived example above is impossible that hasnt stopped people from doing it.... As I stated above, punishing workers/slaves who didnt meet the quota meant less rations, cutting off hands, etc..which of course made it harder to reach the quota. The Congo Free State is an example of thia
Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by jacquesm on Thursday March 23, 2017 @07:39PM (#13945360)
It's not that much different from 'up or out'. There are always new entrants waiting to take over your job.
Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by sqeaky on Thursday March 23, 2017 @08:59PM (#13945702)
I wasn't stating how it is, I was stating a silly hypothetical of how it could be and decent for everyone. Clearly it doesn't work if the owners don't respect human rights as seems so common.
Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by martalist on Thursday March 23, 2017 @06:32PM (#13944952)
The article makes it sound very much like that, except 12 hours per day.
Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by cjslep on Thursday March 23, 2017 @07:59PM (#13945467)
This is exactly why I correct people from treating other people as "cogs in a machine" to treating them as "cells in a much larger organism".
Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by walshemj on Thursday March 23, 2017 @06:58PM (#13945107)
True but anyone who's done any "traditional" production engineering courses knows that for piece work you slow down when the time and motion guy comes round.

Let alone the Spanish practices my ex colleague who was from Red Clydside (makes Malcom Tucker look like a mummys boy) told me about "and the tea boy got a grand in a brown envelope"

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by gozur88 on Friday March 24, 2017 @01:53AM (#13946969)
I suspect most of that kind of stuff is automated now.

Is that better? Those guys made good money for the type of work they were doing. Now they're working at Starbucks or faking a back injury for disability.

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by mercer on Friday March 24, 2017 @02:14AM (#13947043)
Lots of work that could be automated still isn't. Furthermore, there are many jobs that are not technically factory work, but are essentially the same: dehumanizing, boring, conveyor-belt style work where you're treated like a robot.

I did tons of those types of jobs growing up, my little sister does so currently, and I've met quite a few highly educated adults who are miserable being stuck in this kind of job.

One good example would be the Amazon fulfillment center work, of which there are many articles online that paint a picture that I find horrifying.

Another example that might not come to mind right away when you think 'factory work' is call centers.

A friend of mine has a law degree but because she couldn't find work she ended up at a call center. While the work is less physically taxing, it's in some ways worse than a lot of factory work. She can't go on auto-pilot because she's talking to people, but at the same time she's forced to approach it as dumb factory work. Just complicated enough that you can't tune out, but boring enough that it gives no satisfaction.

Aside from high quotas, they track bathroom breaks and if she crosses some (equally unreasonable) threshold a manager will have a 'friendly chat' about it.

Aside from the fact that I've never met anyone who makes 'good money' doing this type of work, I personally don't blame anyone who does this long enough to eventually fake a disability or something. In fact, I'll happily keep paying high taxes if it supports that kind of 'disability'. No human should be forced to do that kind of stuff in this day and age, least of all in a developed nation.

That said, I think the 'faking disability to avoid factory work' type of person is mostly conjured up in support of particular political views. I'm just saying I'd not even be mad if it were the case.

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by aanm1988 on Friday March 24, 2017 @05:38PM (#13952436)
I worked in a call center for a couple of years when I was still in school.

I hated it so very much. We had to do credit checks and stuff, so they wouldn't let us have anything to do when it was slow. Towards the end of my time there they changed something and we started getting more call volume, that sucked. It became just hours and hours of talking about the same thing again and again.

> Aside from the fact that I've never met anyone who makes 'good money' doing this type of work, I personally don't blame anyone who does this long enough to eventually fake a disability or something. In fact, I'll happily keep paying high taxes if it supports that kind of 'disability'. No human should be forced to do that kind of stuff in this day and age, least of all in a developed nation.

So apparently the call center in the bigger city a few hundred miles away had a union. Doubt it made the work better but they were getting several dollars an hour more than us. We got 10+bonus, they were getting 15 or something.

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by TheAdamAndChe on Friday March 24, 2017 @12:19PM (#13949966)
These jobs are really important for an equal, balanced economy, too. Not everyone has the mental capacity or discipline to get a highly technical career, but plenty can do this kind of work. This leads to a higher demand for lower class work, which raises lower class wages and lowers poverty. A major problem in the US is that most of these kinds of jobs have either been shipped overseas or concentrated to a few urban areas in the country. This combined with a few other things have gutted demand for lower class work, which lowers lower class wages and adds to the inequality in the country.
Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by gozur88 on Friday March 24, 2017 @12:57PM (#13950326)
I did that kind of work in my teens and twenties as well, and my impression at the time was every job is a shitty job right up until it isn't there any more. There's been a lot of discussion about heroin and suicide and the soda economy on HN - that sort of stuff makes the affected communities long for the days of soul-crushing factory work.

>That said, I think the 'faking disability to avoid factory work' type of person is mostly conjured up in support of particular political views. I'm just saying I'd not even be mad if it were the case.

I'm not sure what you're trying to say here, but let me explain why I included that: In a lot of small towns that used to have coal mines or were factory towns for one company there simply are no jobs, so it's not that they're faking disability to get out of factory work. They're faking disability because they need money and they don't want to move away from everything and everyone they've ever known.