News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Intent to Deprecate and Remove: Trust in Existing Symante... by tajen on Thursday March 23, 2017 @02:57PM (#13942975)
Am I the only one worried about LetsEncrypt becoming a monopoly? This move from Google is, indirectly, a huge service for them.
Re:Intent to Deprecate and Remove: Trust in Existing Symante... by gcp on Thursday March 23, 2017 @03:09PM (#13943104)
I don't see the link with LetsEncrypt here. Symantec doesn't give away free certs, and LetsEncrypt doesn't do EV.
Re:Intent to Deprecate and Remove: Trust in Existing Symante... by jsfitzsimmons on Thursday March 23, 2017 @03:57PM (#13943630)
The implementation is open source. You can launch your own ACME server (valuable for testing), and use that. CAs implementing this technology obviously need to go through the same hoop-jumping in order to become trusted, but that's true of any strategy of starting a CA.

The technology is available for any CA, existing or new, to copycat.

And if they don't want to use the open source reference implementation, they can cleanroom an ACME server that works with all the existing clients that work with letsencrypt.

Re:Intent to Deprecate and Remove: Trust in Existing Symante... by dangrossman on Thursday March 23, 2017 @03:12PM (#13943144)
If I'm reading the settings page right, Chrome trusts over 70 certificate issuers right now. Let's Encrypt is just one of those, and only issues a limited set of certificate types.
Re:Intent to Deprecate and Remove: Trust in Existing Symante... by aeijdenberg on Thursday March 23, 2017 @06:20PM (#13944869)
As I understand it, Chrome (unlike Firefox) does not ship its own root CA store - rather it defers to the root store of the operating system that it's running on. It does however apply some form of blacklist / additional restrictions over what the OS may allow.
Re:Intent to Deprecate and Remove: Trust in Existing Symante... by problems on Thursday March 23, 2017 @04:52PM (#13944143)
I'd be quite happy if LetsEncrypt becomes a significant monopoly - they're following much better practices than many other CAs, they run on open source software and are generally operated in a much more transparent way than other CAs. By using stuff like Certificate Transparency Let's Encrypt makes it so their issuances are publicly auditable - much more than many other CAs are doing these days.
Re:Intent to Deprecate and Remove: Trust in Existing Symante... by jldugger on Thursday March 23, 2017 @03:27PM (#13943286)
Arguably, they could just adopt LE technology wholesale. Shrinking cert lifetimes is compatible LE's already short cert lifetimes.