News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by dkonofalski on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @05:15PM (#13935038)
I don't know if I'm just looking too far into your comment, but I don't see why you're blaming Netflix (or it seems you are) or how you got to them being the bad guys for this? They're not the ones that make the content. If it was up to Netflix, they would just release their shows DRM-free on Netflix for any platform. Unfortunately, that's not how things work and they have to bow to the demands of the content distributors (not creators, like some people have stated in other comments).
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by criley2 on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @05:23PM (#13935118)
"I don't know if I'm just looking too far into your comment, but I don't see why you're blaming Netflix (or it seems you are) or how you got to them being the bad guys for this? They're not the ones that make the content. If it was up to Netflix, they would just release their shows DRM-free on Netflix for any platform. Unfortunately, that's not how things work and they have to bow to the demands of the content distributors (not creators, like some people have stated in other comments)."

We did a book study on a book called Clean Code where I work, and I reminded of a similar situation that the book explains when describing why we all write dirty and bad code.

Why do we write bad code? Because our stakeholders and our product owners require it. Well, they push deadlines and expectations on us that mean we have to cut corners to make their promises become reality within the unrealistic time provided.

But if you ask the stakeholder why they pust that on you, the stakeholder will say "well, it's the client". Or they'll say "marketing made a promise to the client".

It's always upstream. There's always an upstream concern.

In the book they talk about making a stand, as a developer. That you have a responsibility to explain to your stakeholders and the people above you that doing something the RIGHT way is worth it. That you are the subject matter expert, that it is your responsibility to raise these concerns and thus your responsibility to write good code.

Netflix can pass the buck. "We do what we have to".

But they have a responsibility as one of the premiere web companies to do more than pass the buck.

A Good Internet doesn't happen accidentally, and it doesn't happen when stakeholders pass the buck. It happens when people make a stand for what's right and operate according to their values.

So yes, it is Netflix's responsibility not to bend Mozilla into accepting a Studio's IP demands, but to bend the Studio into accepting humanity's internet demands.

Why do we assume that Netflix can persuade Mozilla, but not a rightsholder?

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by mentat on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @06:03PM (#13935418)
The balance of the power is with the rightsholder. They own the content that Netflix wants to sell and that people want to watch.
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by criley2 on Thursday March 23, 2017 @09:19AM (#13939453)
And the balance of power when coding is with the client and management, we are but poor pawns, doomed to dirty code.
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by gech on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @11:02PM (#13937125)
Elvis is dead. His music should be free.
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by dkonofalski on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @07:58PM (#13936282)
While I agree that there's always an upstream to hot potato too, Netflix really isn't in a position to make those kinds of demands. That's part of the reason why they're starting to produce their own content. The majority of the revenue in their business model comes from the content they show and the majority of that content is owned by someone else. If there wasn't historical precedent of companies giving Netflix the finger and pulling all of their content from their service, I would say that Netflix could push the boundaries and take a stand to try and make a change in the right direction. Unfortunately, until losing Netflix as a platform hurts the movie studios and publishers, that's not going to happen.
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by EpicEng on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @08:48PM (#13936561)
Netflix absolutely does not have a responsibility to go out of business for the sake of pushing an issue few people care about. They have no real leverage here.
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by komali2 on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @06:27PM (#13935600)
Is it Netflix's sole responsibility though? Their only real legal responsibility (other than, well, to not break the law) is to add value for their shareholders. "Taking a stand against DRM" doesn't sound like that.

It sounds more like the job of the citizens to elect representatives that support a Good Internet, and if the politicians they elect turn around and screw their supporters (which isn't illegal), to elect new politicians. A pretty disgusting and slow system, sure, but the only other solution I can think of (I am not a smart man) is outright revolution, and hoping the revolutionary government is all about a Good Internet.

EDIT: I'm fine with being downvoted if I'm wrong or stupid, but I'd appreciate if someone could tell me why they believe I'm wrong or stupid.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by ndesaulniers on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @05:18PM (#13935071)
> If it was up to Netflix, they would just release their shows DRM-free on Netflix for any platform.

That is SO UNTRUE. Netflix would never want their content to be distributed by anyone other than them, which is the point of DRM; absolute control over distribution, not copy protection.

If Netflix was against DRM, then why release their first party content DRM ensnared?

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by dkonofalski on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @08:00PM (#13936294)
That's not necessarily true. It may just be a matter of efficiency. Because all the other content requires DRM, they may have a processing workflow or other technology that just DRMs any and all content in a single, unified manner. Changing that workflow to bypass DRM may actually make it more complicated. You also have to consider that their first party content is rather new so this could absolutely be something that they're working on doing but never implemented because it wasn't an option when they weren't producing their own content.
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by ndesaulniers on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @08:08PM (#13936347)
That's a pretty big "what if" I'm not willing to grant. Given how complicated the MSE+EME stacks are, I have no doubt they would test just MSE without EME, since they can't guarantee EME compliance on any given browser. You're reaching.
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by dkonofalski on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @08:22PM (#13936420)
Ok, fine... then replace it with any other one of the innumerable reasons they could have. Maybe it's not a technical issue. Maybe it's a political issue. The fact is that no one here knows why they haven't taken a position, especially based on their historic behavior related to it, and the issue is likely more complicated than anyone is giving it credit for.
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by bubblethink on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @05:27PM (#13935157)
> If it was up to Netflix, they would just release their shows DRM-free on Netflix for any platform.

What evidence do you have to back this ? It's not like Netflix's own content is available DRM free. Corollary: If you are a content owner and want your content to be available DRM-free on Netflix, will Netflix make a provision for you ? I hate these generalizations that people make. Just because a company (like Netflix) is more tech-savvy than the average media house and makes a few blogs and OSS projects that run on BSD or Linux, it doesn't make them any better for the end user.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by paulddraper on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @05:22PM (#13935112)
Wait, who is forcing Netflix to use DRM for Netflix-produced content?
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by AsyncAwait on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @06:31PM (#13935636)
I actually agree with you and am against DRM, but I think I've read that Netflix doesn't actually own all the rights to their content, which doesn't mean that they don't have a great amount of influence if they wanted to do it - obviously, they don't.
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by paulddraper on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @09:36PM (#13936778)
Who else is competing with Netflix for Netflix-produced content?
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by pathsjs on Thursday March 23, 2017 @08:26AM (#13939147)
Depends on the country. In Italy, Netflix cannot distribute house of cards because it sold the rights to do so to sky
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by dkonofalski on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @08:06PM (#13936329)
I can't say for sure but rights are really complicated. I mean... if you look at a show like House of Cards, Netflix doesn't even own all the rights for that. It's not just a decision that they can make unilaterally.
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by teej on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @05:16PM (#13935057)
I get your argument but a larger portion than ever of Netflix's catalog is first party content.
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by dkonofalski on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @08:05PM (#13936324)
That doesn't mean that the majority of their catalog is. Everything they do will be optimized for what they have the most of.
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by gcb0 on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @05:34PM (#13935216)
1. they make content too. but regardless...

2. they are the middle man for content. they are exactly the group that benefit most from drm.