I'd wager BDFL prefers the CPython implementation because it's probably simpler. Also, it supports tons of targets and is super simple to build.
It's healthy for a language to have more than one implementation. A big win would be a linux distro selecting pypy for use as the default Python. But IMO many python scripts that folks use just don't run long enough to see a benefit from PyPy.
You're doing good wagering, Guido mentioned just this at several keynotes (source: skim through his PyCon/EuroPython keynotes, there's a good chance he addresses the point or answers a question about it). I'd paraphrase him with: although now a big project with optimizations here and there obscuring the purpose of many parts, CPython remains a boring well-understood "no rocket science" C project. As an example of this, I remember him mentioning how the opcode dispatcher remains a giant `switch` statement rather than something more intricate.
That doesn't mean he dislikes or wants to hinder PyPy (or IronPython or Jython or Pyston or ...), just that he's fine with CPython reach and trade-offs as the "default python", and if you prefer another Python with different performance/compatibility/featureset/xyz characteristics, you're welcome to grab it :)
* Is most up-to-date and has all the latest features * Everyone is most familiar with * Already is packaged in all operating systems * Is the most stable * Is compatible with all C extensions
At a EuroPython Keynote, the BDFL mentioned that he hasn't had a closer look at PyPy (he mentioned downloading it and playing with it for a few minutes). I.e. there is a certain disinterest. Also, remember that the "Zen of Python" (https://www.python.org/dev/peps/pep-0020/#id3) was written about the design principles of the Python interpreter, and PyPy is not exactly the Zen of python.
Personally, I'd love to see Python 4 to be based entirely on PyPy.
One reason is that CPython is kept relatively simple on purpose, so it abstains from implementing things like a jit or other very complex optimizations. The biggest obstacle for pypy adoption is that it can't serve as a drop in replacement in the majority of cases, be it because its behind (until now far behind) in supporting new versions of the language or because a lot of popular packages rely on C extensions. The CPython way of binding to C on which these packages rely on does not fit the architecture of pypy very well so they did not really support it at all until recently.
The people who really care about Python performance (sci. comp & HPC) are the ones driving the (non-)adoption of PyPy. One, the existing solution (CPython + Cython) is pretty mature. Two, they require the holy trinity: Numpy, Scipy and Matplotlib. None of these are supported on PyPy, and only Numpy is even close.
That said, the cpython+cython solution is not going away any time soon.
Care to elaborate? I agree that numpypy is pretty much complete, though I have not found it to be faster in my limited testing. I was under the impression that a great deal of work would be required to get the other two running, even using CPyExt (which would not be faster, which was the whole point to begin with). I'd love to be proved wrong though.
Do you mean to refer to the Global Interpreter Lock as the factor which prevents it from becoming the official path for the language? CPython, the reference implementation, has the GIL as well.
Or the PIL library (though everyone seems to use Pillow now?)
Does anyone know why it still hasn't managed to get enough traction to become the official path for the language, and why it still needs mozilla support to get funds ? My intuition is that it's just too complex. But haskell,scala,swift and rust also have a lot of complexity so that can't be the only reason.