Re:Google Maps Lawsuit: Woman Follows Directions, Gets Run Over
by mburney on Sunday May 30, 2010 @11:14PM
(#1391693)
I don't think she should win this lawsuit but it does make me think google could add a new feature describing the safety level of a route.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Google Maps Lawsuit: Woman Follows Directions, Gets Run Over
by epochwolf on Sunday May 30, 2010 @11:28PM
(#1391713)
There is no safety issue here, it's a stupidity issue. She could have used the walkway I commented about instead she decided to walk on what is obviously a highway.
Re:Google Maps Lawsuit: Woman Follows Directions, Gets Run Over
by 27182818284 on Sunday May 30, 2010 @11:55PM
(#1391741)
At first I thought and typed,
"Yeah, exactly. They could add a safety warning about the health effects of eating the phone or laptop you look at Google Maps on too, but we don't because there is an assumed level of intelligence. I hope that she doesn't just lose, but is also penalized for creating a frivolous suit."
But then I reread the parent's post and now I think what they meant is that a nice feature would be one that displayed a route's level of safety. For example, if the route makes you cross a busy highway it might get a red label while a route that crosses no roads would get a green label.
Re:Google Maps Lawsuit: Woman Follows Directions, Gets Run Over
by epochwolf on Monday May 31, 2010 @12:38AM
(#1391786)
I'm torn. I don't know if you saw the stop sign article but the more signage you put on something, the dumber people act. On the surface it's not a bad idea but then what happens if it's not accurate? Some of the streets in my city (Green Bay, WI) are safe most hours of the day and then you need to avoid them between 4pm and 5pm if you value your life.
It would be a nice feature but it might open them to actual liability for reporting inaccurate safety information.
Re:Google Maps Lawsuit: Woman Follows Directions, Gets Run Over
by dkokelley on Monday May 31, 2010 @02:44AM
(#1391984)
I was thinking that too. The more Google attempts to provide safety, the more they become vulnerable to civil actions.
Who was it that said there would be no car accidents if we replaced airbags with spikes?
Re:Google Maps Lawsuit: Woman Follows Directions, Gets Run Over
by mburney on Monday May 31, 2010 @12:05AM
(#1391751)
Exactly, that is the kind of feature I am suggesting. After all, good software often compensates for errors made by the user.
Re:Google Maps Lawsuit: Woman Follows Directions, Gets Run Over
by Groxx on Monday May 31, 2010 @02:00AM
(#1391913)
Except that by creating such a metric, they'd be more likely to be sued for its incorrectness.
Imagine what would happen if someone walking a "safe" route gets mugged.
Re:Google Maps Lawsuit: Woman Follows Directions, Gets Run Over
by wooster on Monday May 31, 2010 @01:26AM
(#1391868)
A further refinement would be to take into account unsafe neighborhoods, the time of day, lighting, and crime rates along the path.
Re:Google Maps Lawsuit: Woman Follows Directions, Gets Run Over
by melling on Sunday May 30, 2010 @11:49PM
(#1391737)
What's the most fair and effective way to stop these types of law suits? Perhaps these can be filtered through some other group of judges to determine if they have merit?
Even lawyers realize the system is broken.
Re:Google Maps Lawsuit: Woman Follows Directions, Gets Run Over
by smokinn on Monday May 31, 2010 @12:02AM
(#1391747)
In Canada there's a preliminary hearing of some sort (not sure about the specifics) to see if the case is even justified in being tried. The vast majority of stories like these are all thrown out.