News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Creating bundles with guix pack by _ibu9 on Monday March 20, 2017 @01:38PM (#13916062)
Yeah Docker and friends exist basically because the industry is blissfully unaware of nice things like Nix.
Re:Creating bundles with guix pack by icebraining on Monday March 20, 2017 @02:54PM (#13916687)
I disagree, the advantage of Docker is that you can slap an image together by doing essentially what you were doing - running a couple of apt install commands, pip install -r requirements.txt, copy a few files and it's done. You don't need to learn a new configuration language, or package all your dependencies yourself, or try to understand a new filesystem layout when you enter a container.

I find Nix and Guix more interesting than Docker, but there's more to the latter's popularity than lack of marketing by the former.

Re:Creating bundles with guix pack by sedachv on Monday March 20, 2017 @06:04PM (#13918053)
> I disagree, the advantage of Docker is that you can slap an image together by doing essentially what you were doing - running a couple of apt install commands, pip install -r requirements.txt, copy a few files and it's done.

IMO that is the problem with Docker. People think that Docker somehow does anything for dependency management. It is an illusion because when you make or move a project into Docker you are essentially starting a new project, and new projects do not have dependency management problems. In a couple of years as people start upgrading components in their Docker-hosted apps dependency management and version conflict problems are going to appear, and will now be harder to resolve because image layering adds many possible failure points (not just at each layer, but also interactions between layers).

Docker is a convenient way to deploy Linux containers, but IMO it is a ticking time bomb when it comes to dependency management.

Re:Creating bundles with guix pack by _ibu9 on Monday March 20, 2017 @07:28PM (#13918526)
> the advantage of Docker is that you can slap an image together by doing essentially what you were doing - running a couple of apt install commands, pip install -r requirements.txt, copy a few files and it's done.

This is exactly what Nix expressions consist of, expect actually reproducible.

> You don't need to learn a new configuration language, or package all your dependencies yourself

Isn't this exactly what Docker and friends require...?

> or try to understand a new filesystem layout when you enter a container.

It wouldn't be new if it was standard as it should be.

Re:Creating bundles with guix pack by icebraining on Monday March 20, 2017 @07:57PM (#13918688)
This is exactly what Nix expressions consist of, expect actually reproducible.

Wait, really? You run "apt-get install X Y Z" in a Nix expression? Or are you saying they're equivalent? Because my point is that Docker runs the exact same commands.

Isn't this exactly what Docker and friends require...?

Sort of, but not really. Dockerfiles are extremely basic, and most of the work is done by shell commands, which developers are know and use. As for packaging all the dependencies, well, yes, but as a big ball of mud. Nix & Guix encourage you to use different packages and connect them. Dockerfiles are literally just dumb container in which you shove everything (using the same commands you already knew).

It wouldn't be new if it was standard as it should be.

And if my grandmother... well, you know the rest.

=================

Don't get me wrong, I'm not praising Docker, on the contrary. I'm just explaining why I think it's more popular than Nix/Guix.

Re:Creating bundles with guix pack by chriswarbo on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @11:18AM (#13922929)
> Wait, really? You run "apt-get install X Y Z" in a Nix expression?

It's probably possible, if you're running Nix on a Debian-based distro, assuming permissions and things are set up right. Of course, that probably counts as Nix abuse, the results wouldn't be any nicer than using apt-get as-is, and it may play badly with Nix's caching.

As a more realistic example, it's perfectly possible to fetch a bunch of repos and configure/build them using the normal processes for that language, e.g. something like this for a Haskell package:

    with import <nixpkgs> {};
    runCommand "some-haskell-app" { buildInputs = [ ghc cabal-install git ]; } ''
      echo "Fetching dependencies" 1>&2
      git clone "http://some-url"
      cd cloned-repo
      cabal update

      echo "Building" 1>&2
      cabal sandbox init
      cabal configure --prefix=$out
      cabal build
      
      echo "Installing" 1>&2
      cabal install
    '';
If you like opaque, monolithic blobs of bash, then the above seems pretty comparable to Docker. The reason few Nix users would do such a thing isn't that it's not possible, it's just that Nix's language makes it easy to decouple those pieces into composable modules; verify, cache and share intermediate results; selectively override parameters; inspect and debug at a REPL; etc.

In fact, it's probably quite straightforward to implement a docker-like system as a bunch of Nix functions, e.g. to get something like:

    with import <nixpkgs> {};
    fauxDocker {
      baseImage = http://some/huge/docker/blob;

      # Will be run in a chroot of the above image
      setup     = ''
        apt-get update
        apt-get install foo bar
        ...
      '';
    };
Re:Creating bundles with guix pack by chriswarbo on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @06:08PM (#13926734)
> In fact, it's probably quite straightforward to implement a docker-like system as a bunch of Nix functions

Oh, it turns out that already exists. Just came across some tests, which appear to chroot into another OS image and run commands. Complete coincidence :)

https://github.com/NixOS/nix/blob/master/release.nix#L202

Re:Creating bundles with guix pack by moosingin3space on Monday March 20, 2017 @02:50PM (#13916648)
Not exclusively. If I want to pay someone for support for running NixOS-based servers, who do I pay? Does NixOS have a support term anywhere near Red Hat (or even Ubuntu)? What about the awkward CLI UX? What about a turn-key solution to deploy my app? These questions are reasonably well answered with Docker, less so with Nix/NixOS.

I say this as someone who really likes the ideas of Nix. In fact, I see the benefits of Docker as being solved reasonably well by Nix:

* Isolation of multiple applications on the same server are handled by NixOS containers, which use the same configuration as a NixOS system and use things like cgroups and namespaces,

* Immutable/declarative deployments (through things like docker-compose) are elegantly handled through nix-expressions,

* Multiple versions of a dependency are handled through the nix store.

I think a good measure would be to provide good tooling for generating Docker images from Nix, and this is what `guix pack` can do today. Once Nix has gotten over these pains, it can become a good developer tool, and from there, ops may choose to adopt it.

Re:Creating bundles with guix pack by equalunique on Monday March 20, 2017 @06:15PM (#13918123)
This company uses Nix & recently funded certain features. If you really want some help with Nix, they might have expertiese for you: http://www.tweag.io
Re:Creating bundles with guix pack by moosingin3space on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @01:22PM (#13924264)
I was making a point, not actually looking for purchasing a service like this.
Re:Creating bundles with guix pack by timclassic on Monday March 20, 2017 @07:40PM (#13918597)
Nixpkgs includes support for generating Docker images: https://nixos.org/nixpkgs/manual/#sec-pkgs-dockerTools

I've used it lightly and so far it has worked well.

Re:Creating bundles with guix pack by kmicklas on Monday March 20, 2017 @07:27PM (#13918521)
> If I want to pay someone for support for running NixOS-based servers, who do I pay?

This is exactly my point; the industry is blissfully unaware of the concepts themselves behind Nix. I'm not saying Nix itself is the ultimate piece of engineering but it's clearly ahead of industry thinking.

> What about a turn-key solution to deploy my app?

That's the idea of NixOps.

Re:Creating bundles with guix pack by moosingin3space on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @01:47PM (#13924478)
NixOps looks great. I'm glad to see there's work in that direction -- turn-key deployment is something that Docker, at least in theory, can do well.
Re:Creating bundles with guix pack by cookiecaper on Monday March 20, 2017 @02:08PM (#13916317)
Gotta be careful with this type of heresy! You won't get hired at a trendy VC-backed company if you're harshing the buzzwords. ;)