News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AlphaGo Is Not AI by flashman on Sunday March 19, 2017 @06:18PM (#13909998)
Is AlphaGo really what we want to classify as 'intelligence'? It is a calculating engine – one which outperforms humans, to be sure, but no more intelligent than a properly-wielded pocket calculator.
Re:AlphaGo Is Not AI by matt4077 on Sunday March 19, 2017 @06:24PM (#13910038)
Yes – stuff like this is confusing 'intelligence' with 'sentience'.

Playing go or chess would have been classified as activities clearly requiring intelligence in the recent past. We're just moving the goalpost whenever AI advances. At some point, it'll probably divide mankind into fractions which either want or don't want to grant certain rights to AI (possibly obsoleted by the great AI uprising of 2025-20-11 6:45:23am to 2025-20-11 6:45:25am)

Re:AlphaGo Is Not AI by jacquesm on Sunday March 19, 2017 @07:58PM (#13910625)
I don't think it is quite that simple.

The 'real world' is not nearly as nicely ordered and specified as a turns based game is. So a computer will be ideally positioned to take advantage of its ability to:

- remember perfectly, forever

- execute algorithms at extreme speed

- in parallel

So you end up with a race that is comparable to a sparrow against a jet airplane. Technology can and does beat biology regularly in all sorts of domains.

Slowly but surely computers are making their way into the real world: their programmers - and by extension the systems - learn how to adapt to the messiness of interacting with life as we know it.

Just like you'd first get kids to play in a playground (the games) and then let them loose in the real world (self driving cars and other much harder tasks).

In the end, all of these amount to a slow but steady march towards human equivalence on a large range of tasks, and excelling humans on plenty of them.

The hard AI question is one where we ask ourselves whether or not there will one of these days be a system that is better than humans on essentially all tasks without exception, including learning, creativity and so on. Once you reach that level all bets are off, until then the slow-but-steady march continues.

The difference is evolution vs revolution, but we've already seen enough progress in limited AI domains that we could conclude we're already seeing a minimal revolution. Whether it will result in a major one is still an open question, it could easily be that progress will at some point plateau.

Re:AlphaGo Is Not AI by iopq on Sunday March 19, 2017 @06:50PM (#13910206)
It uses intuition to play, which is how humans play, but it does it by considering way more positions that humans.
Re:AlphaGo Is Not AI by kirrent on Sunday March 19, 2017 @07:25PM (#13910442)
Not only does it use a form of intuition, but it's an intuition that it's developed itself, rather than just copying others. Professional Go players are learning from the creative strategies of AlphaGo and if that doesn't imply some level of weak intelligence then I'm not sure why anyone talks about a weak/strong AI divide to begin with.

Like Scott Aaronson said, "You can look at any of these examples -- Deep Blue, the Robbins conjecture, Google -- and say, that's not really AI. That's just massive search, helped along by clever programming. Now, this kind of talk drives AI researchers up a wall. They say: if you told someone in the sixties that in 30 years we'd be able to beat the world grandmaster at chess, and asked if that would count as AI, they'd say, of course it's AI! But now that we know how to do it, now it's no longer AI. Now it's just search."

Re:AlphaGo Is Not AI by hueving on Sunday March 19, 2017 @07:21PM (#13910414)
>It uses intuition to play,

Not by the normal definition of intuition. It reasons about millions of moves.

Re:AlphaGo Is Not AI by kirrent on Sunday March 19, 2017 @07:38PM (#13910529)
Could you provide a citation for that figure? It's not one I've read but I don't necessarily disbelieve it. It is worth considering this perspective from one of the Deepmind Nature papers:

"During the match against Fan Hui, AlphaGo evaluated thousands of times fewer positions than Deep Blue did in its chess match against Kasparov; compensating by selecting those positions more intelligently, using the policy network, and evaluating them more precisely, using the value network—an approach that is perhaps closer to how humans play. Furthermore, while Deep Blue relied on a handcrafted evaluation function, the neural networks of AlphaGo are trained directly from gameplay purely through general-purpose supervised and reinforcement learning methods"

Re:AlphaGo Is Not AI by iopq on Monday March 20, 2017 @12:14AM (#13911643)
The policy network (intuition) is already high dan level, which is stronger than many strong amateurs. That's right, with zero reading it's already something like 5d level.

The other part that increases its strength is the positional evaluation through the value network. It's ALSO intuition based on which points are going to belong to which player.

Those two combined give it a high dan level, maybe around 8d.

Only the last component (Monte-Carlo tree search) is not quite as similar because it uses random game roll-outs to ALSO give an evaluation.

AFAIK, value network evaluation is an overestimate of territories, while the MCTS is an underestimate so using both it's stronger than professional level.

The levels I put is the version that played Lee Sedol. The version that went 50-0 on the Internet is clearly stronger and might already be professional level without MCTS.

Re:AlphaGo Is Not AI by mistercow on Sunday March 19, 2017 @07:54PM (#13910604)
Those are two independent sentences which are not mutually exclusive.
Re:AlphaGo Is Not AI by joesb on Sunday March 19, 2017 @10:23PM (#13911254)
Your intuition is probably based on millions of events happened to you and your ancestor (parts that are developed through evolution and social construct).
Re:AlphaGo Is Not AI by manquer on Sunday March 19, 2017 @11:22PM (#13911443)
Equivalent on the side would be million of games in the past either simulation or real human ones, both of which such systems use