Thinking of the maths involved in certain man made games (eg chess), those maths aren't necessarily truths about the physical universe.
Maths have been useful for clear thinking to help understand and predict behavior in the physical world but they remain distinct from the physical.
I think I understand the point you are making, but it's not such a clear distinction.
But the universe isnt just particle configurations. It's the rules of physics too.
Mathematical truths, the ones mathematicians care about, are founded on axioms that have truth values set by our relationship with the physical world, it informs our intuition. This is inescapable.
But maybe you are right, math isn't the epitome of human knowledge. It is the art of learning that knowledge. Still, in some way, individual knowledge constitutes the extent of anyone's own universe.
The old and tired tripe of mathematics being some ethereal detached mental masturbation is so sorely mistaken that I must ask you to respond in as much depth as I did. Because your viewpoint is not only wrong but also the reason so many children grow up to be adults that dislike mathematics. Its a sad disinformation to disconnect the properties of our universe from the science that studies the most abstract type cast of our universe: object.
> Imagine
Imagination is in principle intuitive.
> it recognises no individual things, not even itself,
self-awareness is part of the common definition of intelligence.
> Imagine [something that is patently made up]
> Yet it is true
utter nonsense
> it has no intuition of the natural numbers. If this being makes statement on arithmetic, like 1+1=2, ...
How?
You can't just say
> imagine Natural numbers need not be in scope of intuition
> then Natural numbers need not be in scope of intuition
I mean, sure you can, but that is circular reasoning and not at all convincing.
Take a look at this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematical_universe_hypothes...
The fact that it could mean the universe or the language pretty much lets your argument fall apart.
However, there is another question. Why do we want anyone to do mathematics? Asking, not what math gives the mathematician but instead what math gives society at large. (That is, beyond contented mathematicians).
As long as mathematicians are self-reliant, the second question doesn't matter. However, when mathematicians start making demands of society the second questions is natural.
Note that these questions are orthogonal. Any answer to the mathematics extrinsic value need not inform its intrinsic value. Just like the intrinsic value of mathematics is not related to its extrinsic value.
The point here is that math for math's sake has an awesome byproduct for society: phd's that go commercial. To be afraid that maths will then get squeezed for such phd's to the detriment of it's intrinsic value massively discounts the will of mathematicians and the long view of society. Sure, there will be some that try this squeeze. But their effect will be limited. Meanwhile, this is how mathematics can sustain itself at much higher levels.
Do you really think there is so much true extrinsic value in all the proofs of mathematics? I'd say the value of all those who graduated and went on to do other things easily outweighs all those proofs.
It was the creation and later understanding of those proofs that had extrinsic value. This means that any field of mathematics has value no matter how likely it is to ever be applied.
As such, extrinsically it matters little what field you study, all of it is useful.
Mathematics > Physics > Chemistry > Biology > Physiology > Medicine
Discoveries in mathematics are truths about the universe. They are deeper than particle physics in some respects. Some parts of mathematics might seem abstract but every mathematical system uses the naturals in its axioms or representation. The naturals are directly based on counting, based on the nature of macroscopic objects in our universe. The universe enforces rules, and the facts about naturals, and systems built upon them, are truths that directly point at the nature of information and complexity in our universe.
Why should mathematicians apologize? Hardy was wrong, mathematics can lead to nukes. But its the base level of truth, there is no other scientific discipline that discerns the patterns of the most abstract physicality - objects, and gleans truths, rules for how objects interact.
Solving the Riemann Hypothesis or other conjectures that aren't even known yet might lead to understandings/models that allow for time machines. It's impossible to know.
But why not seek to understand the universes' laws at its most generic level. Its enlightening. Spiritual. Awakening.