News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lockheed Martin completes new battle laser for U.S. military by throwanem on Friday March 17, 2017 @12:36PM (#13895364)
No, because the beam concentrates enough kinetic energy to go straight through whatever reflective material you have in mind.
Re:Lockheed Martin completes new battle laser for U.S. military by metalliqaz on Friday March 17, 2017 @12:53PM (#13895574)
Lasers are EM energy, not kinetic energy.
Re:Lockheed Martin completes new battle laser for U.S. military by throwanem on Friday March 17, 2017 @01:06PM (#13895716)
What happens when a photon interacts with something that has mass?
Re:Lockheed Martin completes new battle laser for U.S. military by AnimalMuppet on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:01PM (#13896318)
If the mirroring is perfect, the photon transfers a bit of momentum as it reflects. If the mirroring isn't perfect, it has some probability of being absorbed, transferring half the momentum that it would if reflected, but transferring all its energy...
Re:Lockheed Martin completes new battle laser for U.S. military by throwanem on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:18PM (#13896507)
And since the mirror isn't perfect, and becomes less so for every photon it absorbs...
Re:Lockheed Martin completes new battle laser for U.S. military by RugnirViking on Friday March 17, 2017 @01:22PM (#13895898)
Mostly, thermal energy
Re:Lockheed Martin completes new battle laser for U.S. military by throwanem on Friday March 17, 2017 @01:30PM (#13895982)
What happens when you dump thermal energy into bulk matter at a rate exceeding that at which that matter can dissipate heat?
Re:Lockheed Martin completes new battle laser for U.S. military by marcosdumay on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:40PM (#13896695)
The matter's temperature increases.
Re:Lockheed Martin completes new battle laser for U.S. military by throwanem on Friday March 17, 2017 @03:05PM (#13896961)
What happens when its temperature increases past the melting point?
Re:Lockheed Martin completes new battle laser for U.S. military by marcosdumay on Friday March 17, 2017 @05:44PM (#13898253)
It melts.

I'm really not getting your point on the context here. The actual effects of this on a real target will depend on a huge number of variables (I bet it's great against stealth things, but cheap drones will start using aluminum paint).

Re:Lockheed Martin completes new battle laser for U.S. military by lkbm on Sunday March 19, 2017 @02:20AM (#13905603)
Let me abbreviate this discussion:

> > > So, is now when everyone starts to put mirrors on their missiles, tanks, and aircraft?

> > ...

> It melts.

That's their point: mirrors don't magic away lasers. Dismissing this weapon with a simple "but mirrors!" is foolish.

Re:Lockheed Martin completes new battle laser for U.S. military by marcosdumay on Monday March 20, 2017 @12:38PM (#13915544)
> mirrors don't magic away lasers

They do. That's exactly the point. Or, more specifically, if your laser is so strong that mirrors can't handle it, you can't also generate it because you need mirrors for that too.

It's just that you can't use them everywhere. It may be useful to ask where mirrors can viably go, and where they can't, but discussing the effects on mirrors won't lead anywhere.

Re:Lockheed Martin completes new battle laser for U.S. military by strictnein on Friday March 17, 2017 @01:31PM (#13895994)
And thermal energy is mostly kinetic energy.
Re:Lockheed Martin completes new battle laser for U.S. military by arethuza on Friday March 17, 2017 @12:45PM (#13895474)
I wonder what a 60kW laser would do to a tank? Not very much I'd have thought.
Re:Lockheed Martin completes new battle laser for U.S. military by throwanem on Friday March 17, 2017 @01:28PM (#13895949)
You'd be right. It would need to dwell for considerable time on the same part of the tank's armor to have any meaningful effect, and even that would rely on slow, inefficient heating as a mechanism. (Assuming a rather improbable 100% kinetic energy transfer from a 60kW beam, that equates to about three .50 BMG rounds per second from contact range. That's a big round, but not big enough to have a significant effect on tank armor.)

To address another commenter's point, it would not set off explosive reactive armor (ERA). While I don't have detailed information on the ERA compositions in common use, the constraints at hand effectively necessitate the use of relatively insensitive plastic explosives, broadly similar in characteristics to the well-understood C4. Such explosives require a shock wave, provided by a special device or (in the case of ERA) by the impact of a shaped charge, to detonate; heat and fire will not set them off. (Vietnam-era American soldiers burned pieces of C4 from Claymore mine charges as cooking fuel. The smoke was toxic, but that was the only danger.)

You need a composition like this for ERA because it is not an actively controlled system. It's not as though there is a computer in the tank which detects an impact and detonates the corresponding ERA segments; the physical processes of such impacts play out far too quickly for such active control to work. ERA therefore has to work on a purely physical basis if it's going to work at all, and that means you need to use an explosive susceptible to detonation on impact. But you don't want an explosive that's very sensitive to impact, or to heat or fire, because you don't want to waste ERA or unnecessarily endanger infantry operating near the tank. (ERA's dangerous enough already that way without giving it a hair trigger!)

So it's already not all that plausible that a beam like this might transfer enough energy, even on direct impact with a mass of such explosive, to set it off. But the impact won't be direct, because ERA isn't constructed of bare explosive blocks; there's always going to be a layer of metal, not armor but still relatively thick, between the explosive and the outside environment. This structure would intervene between the explosive and the beam, and would dissipate the transfer energy as heat. That might eventually set the underlying explosive on fire, but, for the reasons we've already covered, it would not cause a detonation.

Re:Lockheed Martin completes new battle laser for U.S. military by Maken on Friday March 17, 2017 @01:04PM (#13895696)
Could it make the reactive armour explode?