Re:Unsealed Documents Raise Questions on Monsanto Weed Killer
by Alex3917 on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @08:19AM
(#13875555)
How is this article in any way not about GMOs? The whole point of roundup is that you can douse food crops with enormous quantities that would normally kill them, thanks to genetic modifications.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Unsealed Documents Raise Questions on Monsanto Weed Killer
by randomdata on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @09:32AM
(#13875927)
The whole point? We still spray roundup on many of our non-GMO crops. It's inconsequential, if not desirable, to kill the crop near harvest. Roundup had a couple of decades of use in food production before GMOs arrived on the scene.
Also, most of what you see coming out of the sprayer is water. The actual amount of glyphosate used in an application is minimal.
Re:Unsealed Documents Raise Questions on Monsanto Weed Killer
by jmnicolas on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @10:34AM
(#13876350)
Yeah but glyphosate is not an aliment. Why would you eat something that is not an aliment ?
Re:Unsealed Documents Raise Questions on Monsanto Weed Killer
by DanBC on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @11:10AM
(#13876620)
The whole point of roundup is that you can use it earlier in the growing cycle, when weeds and non-GMO crops are more vulnerable. This should mean that farmers can use less chemical so long as they're using GMO crop.
"Buy our product, you'll spend more on inputs" would be a fucking stupid USP for Monsanto.
Re:Unsealed Documents Raise Questions on Monsanto Weed Killer
by 09bjb on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @11:36AM
(#13876814)
It _should_...until the pests attaching the crops develop resistance to the chosen combination of agrichemical/genetically-induced resistance to said agrichemical.
Here's a 2010 article--it's gotten significantly worse since then. http://www.nytimes.com/2010/05/04/business/energy-environmen...
Re:Unsealed Documents Raise Questions on Monsanto Weed Killer
by the_af on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @08:50AM
(#13875704)
I would separate GMO, the technology and field of research, from Monsanto. I don't see why corporate corruption and dishonesty must go hand in hand with GMOs. Even glyphosate itself is not the whole story about GMOs.
Re:Unsealed Documents Raise Questions on Monsanto Weed Killer
by dragonwriter on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @01:34PM
(#13878025)
> How is this article in any way not about GMOs? The whole point of roundup is that you can douse food crops with enormous quantities that would normally kill them, thanks to genetic modifications.
No, it's not. RoundUp was around and commercially used as a weedkiller, including in agriculture, before transgenic RoundUp Ready traits were developed.
It's true that RoundUp Ready and similar traits increase the demand for and use of the herbicides they provide resistance to, but the safety of the herbicides is orthogonal to the safety of the herbicide resistant crops.
Re:Unsealed Documents Raise Questions on Monsanto Weed Killer
by cm2012 on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @08:34AM
(#13875630)
Roundup vastly reduces pesticide quantity.
Re:Unsealed Documents Raise Questions on Monsanto Weed Killer
by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @11:06AM
(#13876580)
It takes a lot more water than bleach, when imbibed, to kill someone .. bleach for everyone?
Re:Unsealed Documents Raise Questions on Monsanto Weed Killer
by maxerickson on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @12:44PM
(#13877449)
The addition of appropriate amounts of chlorine to drinking water may well be the single thing that has most impacted human health.