News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by madengr on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @07:27AM (#13866566)
Too bad Asimov does not call out religion as a culprit, as he alludes to that in his books. The US has a huge evangelical (or fundamentalist) population that places faith over reason.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by lr4444lr on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:44AM (#13867023)
He could have, but that still doesn't dig satisfying deeply into the analysis: why would Americans be prone to evangelical / fundamentalist religion, and a general disdain for knowledge? It isn't a direct line from the Puritans, whose descendants anyway hardly account for the result of successive waves of immigration seen today. There are deeper issues at play such as:

The country's birth from a remote colonial revolution with a deep distrust of monarchy, tradition, and authority.

Being a destination for various people disenfranchised in their home cultures, who need a new metric of success, coalesce around money as the arbiter of success and indirectly "correctness".

Geographic isolationism from other and significantly diverse first world nations.

A lingering sense of superiority for our heroic role in WWII.

I don't know how much each of these contributes, but I think the answer to the questions Asimov raises is sooner found in, say, de Tocqueville than in Susan Jacoby.

Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by DoofusOfDeath on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @07:58AM (#13866736)
FWIW, most evangelicals I know reject the notion that faith and reason ought to be in contradiction. I think you'll find that few well-respected Christian theologians or pastors would embrace such a contradiction either.

AFAIK, a more orthodox understanding of faith this: It's a willingness to take the risk that a proposition is true, or that a person can be trusted, even in the absence of iron-clad proof. As one guy phrased it, it's "putting all your eggs in one basket".

And FWIW, I've encountered numerous liberals, conservatives, athiests, and theists who hold self-inconsistent sets of beliefs.

Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by beaconstudios on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:46AM (#13867042)
I think pretty much all humans hold self-inconsistent internal beliefs. We're not rational agents.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by richmarr on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:57AM (#13867104)
> ...most evangelicals I know... few well-respected Christian theologians or pastors... I've encountered...

With respect this argument (as presented) is anecdotal and subjective. There's neither data nor analysis so it's not very pursuasive.

> ...a more orthodox understanding of faith this...

Careful there, you're conflating the two meanings of the word 'faith'. One is putting trust in something, the other is to follow the doctrines of a religion (or referring to a specific religion). They're related but distinct.

Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by aaron-lebo on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:05AM (#13866773)
You are arguing against an ideological worldview.

It should go without saying that religious belief (as varied as it is) has very little to do either way with sound reasoning. You can find monsters throughout history that are (edit) religious or non-religious.

Speaking of contradictory beliefs, how about Lenin? He was an atheist but also thought he was a man of destiny...and murdered a bunch of people through fanaticism. Of course nobody wants to claim him today - not a true believer. Everybody knows true believers wouldn't do that.

Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by DoofusOfDeath on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:47AM (#13867051)
> It should go without saying that religious belief (as varied as it is) has very little to do either way with sound reasoning. You can find monsters throughout history with faith or non-faith.

I'm not sure I follow what you're trying to say.

The first sentence seems to be an assertion about the relationship between reason and religious belief. But the second sentence seems to be about the non-relationship between holding a [non-]religious world-view and being a monster.

Are those two sentences were meant to work together to make a larger point? If so, would you mind restating it so I can understand?

Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by aaron-lebo on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @07:53AM (#13866706)
Religion is only incidental.

Human beings are illogical and take a lot of things on faith. People often don't have good reasons to believe things or have simplistic views of other (see religion or not-religion). They believe because that's all they know. You eliminate all religion and you'll end up with non-religious faiths and ignorance. Haven't you noticed most tech is religion?

Religion might play a factor, but only as much as class, nationality, race, culture, education, background, genetic factors, etc.

Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by davrosthedalek on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:04AM (#13866766)
There is a natural drive to faith: We can't know everything, so we think we have to take some things on faith. The point being that most religions try to foster faith. It's often a central mantra that faith is good. This unfortunately trains people to stop asking questions. On the other hand, the scientific approach tries to manage how we deal with things we don't know for certain. We believe in things more because we have more evidence for it. Without trusting them 100%.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by wbillingsley on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:48AM (#13867055)
Oddly, in practice it's the other way around.

The vast vast majority of the population, for example, is in no position to question the LHC result identifying the Higgs boson. Unless you have a cool billion dollars or so to build your own collider, you are essentially in the position that an expert has told you so, and some other experts said they agree with them (peer review). So therefore believe what you are told. And whenever people do question scientific results, without the expensive equipment and basing their entire career around becoming employed as a scientist, we tend to call them cranks.

With most religious positions (eg, what is the biblical view on X), you've probably got three copies of different translations lying around the house, and have every means and encouragement to do your own questioning, argument, and interpretation.

In terms of the actual practice of questioning, interpreting evidence, and weighing up a decision on an open question where there are differing views -- most people have vastly more experience and engagement of doing that with religion than with science.

Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by aaron-lebo on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:08AM (#13866793)
Of course, but many things try and foster faith - companies do it, nations do it, people do it.

Most people whether they are religious or not aren't applying the scientific method to their daily lives. You can't blame that - biases are easy and trying to be objective is a pain in the ass.

Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by TeMPOraL on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @09:06AM (#13867149)
I think most people are smarter than this discussion is saying they are - it's just they don't optimize for the things we implicitly assume here. They don't optimize for the truth value of their beliefs, but for their direct usefulness in life.

Most of the scientific facts don't have a direct impact on your life, so you don't get rewarded for getting things right, nor you get punished for getting them wrong. Different criteria thus become more relevant. How a belief fits your image of yourself? How does it help you strengthen your ties to the groups you're in? How it positions you against the groups you dislike?

Note that in situations when getting things right has direct impact on one's life - like, when it comes to money or job - people suddenly become very rational.

Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by aaron-lebo on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @12:39PM (#13869042)
This doesn't add much to what you are saying, but I very much agree.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by taurath on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @07:32AM (#13866590)
And yet people are more likely to change their religion to match their politics than vice versa.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by willvarfar on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @07:37AM (#13866618)
Interesting, can you elaborate on what you mean and is there any studies behind it?
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by punk_coder on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @07:44AM (#13866657)
My sister and her husband did this. He was Episcopalian, and she became pretty religious after marrying him. No one in my family was raised religiously. My parents always said we can figure that out for ourselves when we get older. Anyway, once the Episcopalian Church welcomed gay pastors, and her church got one, they fled and became Southern Baptists.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by ddebernardy on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:08AM (#13866789)
That's rather specific to the US and I'm not sure I'd rate that as changing religion TBH.

In Europe, your usual choices when you disagree with the dominant church are to get over it, become atheist, or - more rarely - change faith altogether (as in to Islam, Buddhism, etc.) because, more often than not, you exhaust Christian picks after going through Catholicism and the local Protestant flavor or two.

In contrast, the US offers a very wide variety of Christian flavors (and Christian-based sects). So when, like your sister and her husband, you disagree you can just pick another church flavor down the block that is mostly the same with a few twists. You're still nominally Christian though.

The difference between the two is sometimes put forward to explain the contrast between the high number of atheists in Europe and the high number of religious people in the US.

Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by throwanem on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:05AM (#13866771)
In entire fairness, the Protestant strains in general can be organized along a single dimension with Calvinism at one end and Unitarianism at the other. Episcopalianism is relatively close to the latter, and Southern Baptism to the former; I don't really know that I'd describe it as a change of faith entire when someone moves along that dimension toward a more satisfactory interpretation of the scripture which all these strains share.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by fsloth on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:23AM (#13866884)
I don't think that qualifies as changing religions.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by sabertoothed on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @07:37AM (#13866615)
Politics and religious beliefs are intertwined. Especially in the US (in the Western world).
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by DoofusOfDeath on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @07:47AM (#13866665)
This seems sensible to me.

If a person truly believes his religion, it has major implications for his/her notion of what it means for humans to thrive, what activities are moral/ethical, and the goals of human society.

It would be very strange indeed if those beliefs had no bearing on one's politics.

Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by tchock23 on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:19AM (#13866853)
Do you support removing non-profit status from churches to formalize this?
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by sigzero on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:38AM (#13866980)
No, because once you give the government the ability to tax something you give the government the ability to control whatever that something is. The Supreme Court has ruled on this in the "Walz vs. Tax Commission of the City of New York" ruling.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by DoofusOfDeath on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:43AM (#13867021)
> Do you support removing non-profit status from churches to formalize this?

I don't know. I see good arguments for and against.