JWT, like SAML, is made to support separate identity providers and the service providers. In the spirit of generality, this means the identity provider(s) could be from a different vendor, operated by a different organization. E.g., you could let users access their account on your service based a token issued from Google. But that means Google chooses the algorithm, not you!
And it's a standard, so you don't have to write any code of your own. Just import the right middleware for your framework and you're set!
So the temptation is there for library authors to support all the defined algorithms, and just enable everything by default to be as compatible as possible - after all, you can just look at the header to see which algorithm to use!
If these things are suggested in the standard and promptly followed by major implementations, then the standard isn't very good.
https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc7518.txt
Still, my point about it missing from RFC7115 stands.
---- Original comment ---------
The standard says you should support NONE as the algorithm and that you should use the algorithm the client sends you, all the while completely failing to mention the issues with that, both in its Security Considerations section (which mentions even more "obvious" things like "use keys with high entropy") and in the description of the algorithm to decode a token (which initial implementers probably relied upon to get to a "correct" implementation). Sorry, that is a failure of the spec as well in my book.
If you spec something with risks, at least mark the critical parts clearly with "point away from foot".
A better standard IMHO would have suggested the API for the decode functions, making it clear that the algorithm used should be whiteli
If you issue tokens with none, then you will have to accept them when clients send them back. This is obviously a very bad idea, but that's all th spec says. If the issuer chooses to be insecure, that is a valid choice.
If you issue tokens with a specific algo, and clients send them back with a different or none header, you know they have been forged.
The spec allows issuers to decide whether to use none, it doesn't say you must trust none tokens if you know you didn't issue them.
A standard promoted as "the standard for secure tokens" should not aim for "You can use the pieces to build a correctly behaving system" or "the spec allows secure implementations", it should aim for "if you use this and follow some spelled-out basic rules you get fool-proof secure tokens" and make wrong usage as hard has possible.
Right, so, why is this in the spec?
Example: The fact that my service has an http stack which must parse a cookie header doesn't mean my app must accept its contents as valid. There's a lot of confusion on this thread about which components should/must do what things.
Why would an issuer ever let a client decide what algo to use?
"Send a header that specifies the "HS256" algorithm when the application normally signs messages with an RSA public key."
Again, under what circumstances would a header be used by the client to ask for a specific implementation?
What about encrypted client side cookies - would you let the client "send a header" to specify which key to use???
The only problems you highlighted are serious input validation issues and a naive, broken trust model.