Re:Tech’s ruling class casts a big shadow
by kyleschiller on Monday March 13, 2017 @03:26PM
(#13861427)
To be clear, the "wage-fixing" was a no cold-call agreement that involved Apple and Google, not the rest of the companies mentioned. [0]
I'm all for criticizing giant companies but can we at least get our facts straight and not sound conspiratorial about it?
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-Tech_Employee_Antitrust_L...
Is there a distinction between "a no cold-call agreement" and "wage fixing" that I'm not aware of? This sounds a bit like "I didn't commit assault I only hit him".
Re:Tech’s ruling class casts a big shadow
by tynpeddler on Monday March 13, 2017 @06:47PM
(#13863245)
>Our (Google's) policy only impacted cold calling, and we continued to recruit from these companies through LinkedIn, job fairs, employee referrals, or when candidates approached Google directly. In fact, we hired hundreds of employees from the companies involved during this time period.
Not defending google here, but there is some nuance to the issue.
The scummiest part to me is that they made "agreements that, when offering a position to another company's employee, neither company would counteroffer above the initial offer."
From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-Tech_Employee_Antitrust_L...
Re:Tech’s ruling class casts a big shadow
by eli_gottlieb on Monday March 13, 2017 @07:50PM
(#13863694)
If we didn't get conspiratorial about it, we'd have to admit it's the natural interest and tendency of labor monopsonists to try to suppress wages.
Up to a point, but the wage fixing issue has already been settled and this article is current, not historical. Walt is pointing at what he sees happening now. Can you point out instances of criminal collusion you think are or might be currently happening?
Re:Tech’s ruling class casts a big shadow
by Bartweiss on Monday March 13, 2017 @11:55AM
(#13858905)
This is a reasonable criticism, but it also feels a bit like the circular argument used for the TPP: "You're talking about the old idea, you need to respond to the new one we won't let you see!" I don't have an example of ongoing collusion, but a week before the wage fixing news broke I couldn't have cited that, either. I could probably muster something about coopting web standards organizations or hypocritical stances on net neutrality, but it would be weak.
I didn't mean to attack Walt for saying "alleging", and I recognize he's talking about consumer-facing issues anyway, but I did think it was a relevant historical note that this was very recently more than an allegation.
Re:Tech’s ruling class casts a big shadow
by RestlessMind on Monday March 13, 2017 @01:07PM
(#13859833)
These big tech co's have already demonstrated that they are willing to break rules if its suits them (cf. wage fixing). What makes you trust them at this point? What have they done to redeem themselves?
I found this an odd comment, because we don't have to "allege collusion". It's been documented and settled in court. It was wage fixing, not price fixing, but it's still clear evidence that the "Gang" is willing to work together against the market.