News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber is forcing drivers in Seattle to listen to anti-unio... by mseebach on Monday March 13, 2017 @09:26AM (#13857575)
Conjecture. You have literally no evidence in support of that belief. Not forced, full stop, the headline of the article is flat out wrong. If you defend this shit just because you agree with the sentiment, you have no right to an opinion about fake news.

EDIT: For the record, the parent has ghost-edited their post.

Re:Uber is forcing drivers in Seattle to listen to anti-unio... by wmsiler on Monday March 13, 2017 @09:48AM (#13857756)
I would dial this back a bit. Worst case scenario, the commenter you are responding to is committing confirmation bias by making negative assumptions to match their existing negatives beliefs. Confirmation bias is easy to slip into even if you know it exists, and this angry response isn't useful.

Best case scenario (which I think is more likely), they are simply interpreting this story in context. Uber has several ethics scandals under their belt including ones involving them gathering and analyzing data for unethical purposes (guessing which of their customers have had one night stands).

Re:Uber is forcing drivers in Seattle to listen to anti-unio... by mseebach on Monday March 13, 2017 @10:52AM (#13858251)
How is this different from how fake news perpetuates? My foe has done bad things A, B and C, therefore it's OK to not just assume they are doing D as well, but OK to present D as fact.

For the record, what I am reacting to is not the possibility of a belief that Uber might do such a thing[1], but the defence of a naked lie.

1: I think such a belief is an extremely shallow reading of Uber as wanting to do evil in and of itself, rather than willing to bend a lot of rules very very far to serve their customers (and sometimes cross the line in creative data-driven marketing), and have created a toxic corporate culture in the process -- it's easy to see how 'break all the rules as long as you're winning' can do that. I also don't think they will survive long, companies with less toxic cultures (but no less friendly to the taxi-interest-captured regulatory bodies or unions) will prevail because they can attract the better talent. Firing a driver with good performance because he doesn't listen to the company podcast is not even remotely consistent with that willingness. But that's not the discussion we're having.

Re:Uber is forcing drivers in Seattle to listen to anti-unio... by ceejayoz on Monday March 13, 2017 @10:56AM (#13858294)
This is a company who wrote software to detect and hide from law enforcement, and you think it's not feasible they'd try and come up with a score for how friendly a driver is to unionization? C'mon.

The headline is incorrect - they're not being forced - but it's hardly "fake news" conspiracy theory to speculate that some drivers may feel pressured over this.

Re:Uber is forcing drivers in Seattle to listen to anti-unio... by mseebach on Monday March 13, 2017 @10:57AM (#13858304)
The word was 'forced'. You defended it. C'mon yourself.

Speculating what people might be doing, especially when it sounds plausible, then presenting it as fact, is exactly fake news.

Re:Uber is forcing drivers in Seattle to listen to anti-unio... by ceejayoz on Monday March 13, 2017 @11:03AM (#13858356)
My post literally stated (now edited to add "the headline is misleading / clickbaity" to be even more crystal-clear on that point) that they're not technically forced.
Re:Uber is forcing drivers in Seattle to listen to anti-unio... by mseebach on Monday March 13, 2017 @11:14AM (#13858458)
I understand, and I understood before. You're defending the lie by saying that it's only technically incorrect. You do understand that the phrase means that you think it's still substantially correct -- not that it conceivably could be true?
Re:Uber is forcing drivers in Seattle to listen to anti-unio... by ceejayoz on Monday March 13, 2017 @11:22AM (#13858533)
I believe it is substantially correct that Uber and companies like it engage in ethically dubious and legally murky anti-union actions.

I believe it implausible that Uber didn't consider the pressure/intimidation aspect that a daily prompt to listen to their propaganda entails when adding it to the system.

Re:Uber is forcing drivers in Seattle to listen to anti-unio... by icebraining on Monday March 13, 2017 @09:41AM (#13857710)
I agree that the headline is over the top. That said, Uber now even tracks users when outside the car. Since they can't know for sure if it's being tracked, it's inevitable that the drivers will feel pressured, and Uber knows that.
Re:Uber is forcing drivers in Seattle to listen to anti-unio... by mseebach on Monday March 13, 2017 @10:56AM (#13858300)
It's not over the top, it's a lie. A creepy feature in the customer app has no bearing on that.
Re:Uber is forcing drivers in Seattle to listen to anti-unio... by xg15 on Monday March 13, 2017 @09:41AM (#13857714)
After the recent reveals about the Greyball tool, such conjectures seem reasonable.
Re:Uber is forcing drivers in Seattle to listen to anti-unio... by mseebach on Monday March 13, 2017 @11:03AM (#13858365)
Do you think people who share fake news on social media think what it says seems unreasonable? Do you think that's a valid excuse to share fake news, or to defend it when it's called out for being fake?
Re:Uber is forcing drivers in Seattle to listen to anti-unio... by xg15 on Monday March 13, 2017 @01:03PM (#13859784)
Reasonable != true.

The difference is between presenting your ideas as "facts" - or making it clear that they are theories, ideally with reasons given why you think they are worth considering.

This exchange belonged to the latter category.

More generally, the term "fake news" is thrown around far too often for my tastes. If I remember correctly, the origin was a scandal about eastern european scammers writing deliberately doctored news to create controversy and cash-in on ad revenue.

Nowadays, this term seems to be used by anyone to describe any kind of rumors or guesswork (or occasionally well-researched journalism) that doesn't fit their particular view.

Re:Uber is forcing drivers in Seattle to listen to anti-unio... by hueving on Monday March 13, 2017 @01:45PM (#13860287)
>Reasonable != true.

Right, but in some peoples' opinions, the moon landing being a conspiracy is reasonable. That doesn't mean we should discuss it like it's true on this website.

Re:Uber is forcing drivers in Seattle to listen to anti-unio... by xg15 on Monday March 13, 2017 @04:35PM (#13862088)
Yup, hence why I specified why I find it worth to think about. (Greyball etc)
Re:Uber is forcing drivers in Seattle to listen to anti-unio... by ceejayoz on Monday March 13, 2017 @09:37AM (#13857678)
Sure. No evidence except centuries of union busting, Uber's flouting of regulations, metrics on everything, digging into ride records without permission to prove points to journalists, etc.
Re:Uber is forcing drivers in Seattle to listen to anti-unio... by Spooky23 on Monday March 13, 2017 @03:01PM (#13861135)
The company was just caught shadow-banning users who work for municipal government to avoid potential regulatory issues. Uber deserves zero benefit of the doubt, as they have proven themselves as an organization to be unworthy of trust.