News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tech’s ruling class casts a big shadow by friedman23 on Monday March 13, 2017 @12:50AM (#13855310)
I don't think you can consider 5 companies to be an oligopoly especially when you don't see monopolistic practices. These companies regularly undercut each other and innovate.
Re:Tech’s ruling class casts a big shadow by aaron-lebo on Monday March 13, 2017 @12:59AM (#13855341)
Re:Tech’s ruling class casts a big shadow by friedman23 on Monday March 13, 2017 @01:04AM (#13855356)
Yes, and it's illegal. Having a monopoly isn't illegal. Anyway, your statement is completely unrelated to the subject of whether these companies would be innovating more if the market was less consolidated and I don't believe so.
Re:Tech’s ruling class casts a big shadow by aaron-lebo on Monday March 13, 2017 @01:15AM (#13855397)
Some kinds of monopoly are illegal. That first case was an antitrust case which has some connection to anti-monopoly, yeah?

Those companies have had a decade at the top with all the money and talent in the world. Has tech gotten that much better since 2007? Has Apple's hardware gotten better relative to the competition? Has your web experience gotten remarkably better? Do we prefer Allo or Hangouts or x, y, or z to Google Talk?

With the clout they have you have to innovate some and they certainly have. The question is whether they have innovated substantially. It doesn't seem like it.

Re:Tech’s ruling class casts a big shadow by friedman23 on Monday March 13, 2017 @01:54AM (#13855539)
> Has tech gotten that much better since 2007?

Yes

> Apple's hardware gotten better relative to the competition?

"Relative", explain why you put that qualifier please beyond not having an argument. Also yes.

> Has your web experience gotten remarkably better?

Yes

> Do we prefer Allo or Hangouts or x, y, or z to Google Talk?

Hangouts, what's your point here?

You really don't remember what tech was like 10 years ago.

Re:Tech’s ruling class casts a big shadow by adrianratnapala on Monday March 13, 2017 @03:00AM (#13855772)
In 2006 the linux desktop was about the same as it is now, the Windows one was better. In 2006 I didn't have a smartphone yet. And in 2016, I don't have one any more.

(Actually I have one from work, but I only seem to use it as a wireless hotspot.)

Re:Tech’s ruling class casts a big shadow by trimbo on Monday March 13, 2017 @10:35AM (#13858099)
Vista was better than Windows 10?
Re:Tech’s ruling class casts a big shadow by adrianratnapala on Monday March 13, 2017 @02:40PM (#13860945)
Vista, I admit was terrible.

But XP was very good for its time -- it brought in the big menus and (quasi?) full-screen stuff which later metastasied in Win 10. Though those menus were also a throwback to the good old DOS text-mode menu systems.

Win7 was of course another good one, a few years later. But note: the difference between Win7 and Vista was not the UI design -- it was the performance and other aspects of technical execution.

Re:Tech’s ruling class casts a big shadow by Neliquat on Monday March 13, 2017 @10:55AM (#13858287)
Noone used vista, it was XP, 7, 10 for 90% of users.
Re:Tech’s ruling class casts a big shadow by macintux on Monday March 13, 2017 @11:23AM (#13858540)
Per the graphs at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usage_share_of_operating_syste... it looks like Vista peaked at 40%.
Re:Tech’s ruling class casts a big shadow by zlynx on Monday March 13, 2017 @02:59PM (#13861119)
Vista ran very well for me in 2 GB of RAM. It was absurdly slow in 1 GB machines, especially on laptops shipped with Vista plus bloatware.

I used Vista until 7 came out. I usually upgrade Windows versions rapidly. Linux too, I usually jump into the Fedora betas. I haven't been sorry yet.

Anyway, your own statement is contradictory. From what you said 10% is not "no one."

Re:Tech’s ruling class casts a big shadow by tabeth on Monday March 13, 2017 @01:16AM (#13855398)
I find this kind of learned helplessness to be fascinating. Do you think big companies need apologists? Do you think there would be more or less innovation with more smaller firms?
Re:Tech’s ruling class casts a big shadow by friedman23 on Monday March 13, 2017 @01:58AM (#13855554)
Helplessness? Apologist? I don't consider Google/Facebook/etc my enemy like you seem to. These companies are not exploiting me, I have no reason to be hostile to them (profit is not exploitation).

> Do you think there would be more or less innovation with more smaller firms?

Likely less, I do not think that private space exploration or self driving cars would be possible without the massive accumulation of capital enabled by tech giants.

Now let's look at the counterfactual, the US has massive tech giants and the majority innovation comes from or to the US. Other countries don't, other countries don't have nearly as much innovation bar a few exceptions.

And truthfully, I find people that are anti capitalism to be far more interesting. It's amazing that people can convince themselves that private ownership is wrong while living in the most prosperous time in history and also believing that stripping those better off of their wealth will somehow lead to a more prosperous society when every time it has been done it has lead to disaster.

Re:Tech’s ruling class casts a big shadow by sharemywin on Monday March 13, 2017 @09:29AM (#13857602)
It's funny you make it sound sound like Darpa had no part in self driving cars. or that the government space program didn't set the standard and the foundation for private space exploration.

Yes Capitalism and Liberal Democracy is the most powerful system man has ever created. Hopefully we don't screw it up by giving all the credit to the guy handing you the apple from the orchard we call the "western world"

Football is an awesome game but without the guys in the black and white uniforms it would be nothing but chaos.

Re:Tech’s ruling class casts a big shadow by sanderjd on Monday March 13, 2017 @11:20AM (#13858509)
I didn't read the parent's comment as anti-government. It is certainly pro-business, but the two aren't mutually exclusive. Your analogy with sports and referees seems apt: referees are important but it wouldn't be a very good game without having the players as well.
Re:Tech’s ruling class casts a big shadow by simonh on Monday March 13, 2017 @11:47AM (#13858810)
Liking grapes doesn't mean you therefore must hate oranges.
Re:Tech’s ruling class casts a big shadow by majewsky on Monday March 13, 2017 @06:20AM (#13856553)
> I do not think that [...] self driving cars would be possible without the massive accumulation of capital enabled by tech giants

Yet people are building self-driving cars as a hobby project. Sure, the whole topic would not progress that fast, but that statement is a bit overblown. (Same for private space exploration to a much more limited extent.)

Re:Tech’s ruling class casts a big shadow by taneq on Monday March 13, 2017 @07:30AM (#13856846)
People are building toy systems that work in limited scenarios, not putting in the hard engineering work to build robust, generally applicable systems. (Unless there's some significant hobbyist self-driving system I don't know about? The closest thing I can think of was comma.ai and that was barely at the "won't drive off a fairly straight highway, probably" stage.)
Re:Tech’s ruling class casts a big shadow by tomhoward on Monday March 13, 2017 @08:18AM (#13857089)
People are building toy systems that work in limited scenarios, not putting in the hard engineering work to build robust, generally applicable systems

Also, they're building these systems using tech that has been developed and open-sourced by the big players.

Re:Tech’s ruling class casts a big shadow by Method-X on Monday March 13, 2017 @03:12AM (#13855805)
Great post. You would really like Peter Thiel (read Zero To One).
Re:Tech’s ruling class casts a big shadow by cylinder on Monday March 13, 2017 @01:32AM (#13855459)
Reminds me of when people were fine with erosion of civil liberties, expansion of surveillance, etc, under Obama because they trusted him and thought he was decent, and that they could probably trust future Presidents with that power too. Here, they find the current crop of leaders at these companies decent enough, not realizing their control and leadership will change over time.