News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by TheSpiceIsLife on Sunday March 12, 2017 @04:24PM (#13852868)
hauling the most lethal cargo there is

I can think of about 50 more dangerous things I'd rather not pass on the highway.

The truck carrying a nuclear warhead is about a squillion times more dangerous than the warhead itself.

Trucks have killed more people than nuclear weapons ever will.

Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by Taniwha on Sunday March 12, 2017 @06:59PM (#13853744)
I got stuck next to one of these in a 2 hour jam (something big was on fire 100 miles south of us) on CA I-5 the night before Thanksgiving 20 or so years back ... it was so obvious - large white unmarked truck, combat-style jeep-things front and back bristling with big antennas, full of scary dudes in fatigues and dark glasses - it was like something out of central casting - throw a McDonalds logo or something on the truck for heaven's sake

While sitting next to a nuke and not really knowing how safe it was was a bit scary the actions of the security dudes when people started getting out of their cars to stretch their legs was far more scary - they were actively menacing while trying not to give away why they were there or that the unmarked truck between their vehicles was in any way special (despite being stupidly obvious)

Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by sandworm101 on Monday March 13, 2017 @08:07AM (#13857021)
Sounds more like an aircraft/spacecraft part in transit. Or aircraft weapons. Regardless of the OP, nukes are small. They dont need big trucks. My money would be on a shipmemt of missles parts (rocket motors) or similar weaponry that you donr want shipped by air.
Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by LeifCarrotson on Sunday March 12, 2017 @04:35PM (#13852936)
There are a lot more trucks than there are nuclear warheads. If there were as many warheads, and they went as many miles as trucks, I expect that accidental detonations would be a lot more common.
Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by TheSpiceIsLife on Sunday March 12, 2017 @04:50PM (#13853019)
Firstly, has there ever been an accidental detonation of a live nuclear warhead? A lot more common than zero is still fairly infrequent.

Secondly, is that a fair comparison? There are approximately as many trucks, and as many nuclear warheads, as the market demands.

Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by jonknee on Sunday March 12, 2017 @05:06PM (#13853122)
> Firstly, has there ever been an accidental detonation of a live nuclear warhead? A lot more common than zero is still fairly infrequent.

No, but there have been plenty of accidents with live nuclear warheads (including losing them in the ocean!). The fact one hasn't gone off is more a matter of there not being a ton of them in the first place.

Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by XorNot on Sunday March 12, 2017 @05:18PM (#13853182)
No. This is not true at all.

Nuclear weapons can't detonate from being physically damaged. They might explode and scatter their contents about from the explosives in the core, but they won't reach criticality in anything other then an intentional, triggered detonation.

Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by saboot on Sunday March 12, 2017 @05:32PM (#13853243)
A weapon can be triggered without it being intentional, see the goldsboro incident. The bomb went through three of four arming sequences as the plane carrying it broke apart, it's considered luck the fourth and a subsequent detonation did not occur.

> “Until my death I will never forget hearing my sergeant say, 'Lieutenant, we found the arm/safe switch.' And I said, 'Great.' He said, 'Not great. It’s on arm.'” https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1961_Goldsboro_B-52_crash#Bomb...

Also what you are describing is "One Point Safety" in which an external explosion or fire can cause a nuclear detonation. This is mostly true for the current US arsenal, but wasn't in the past. It's one of the main reasons why the Little Boy design was so poor for safety, it only required one (preferably intentional) explosion

Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by jacquesm on Sunday March 12, 2017 @06:51PM (#13853689)
Makes you wonder what would have happened with respect to nuclear weapons if that bomb had indeed detonated. Very close call.
Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by pavel_lishin on Sunday March 12, 2017 @08:55PM (#13854386)
I love that there's just a nuclear warhead hanging out in a field in North Carolina.
Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by 67726e on Sunday March 12, 2017 @10:33PM (#13854823)
There's also a lost nuke right off the coast off Tybee Island, Georgia near Savannah.
Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by MichaelGG on Sunday March 12, 2017 @05:51PM (#13853345)
That hasn't been historically true. It might be true for newer ones but older designs could have gone off. There's also incidents where the bomb was armed accidentally, say, by it slipping while in a plane. Some of the "intentional" detonators were very simple and could be triggered by a surge.

Source: https://www.amazon.com/Command-Control-Damascus-Accident-Ill...

Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by marvin on Sunday March 12, 2017 @06:08PM (#13853436)
Not only that, but designs thought to be "one-point safe" (a detonation starting at one point in the explosive lens will not cause a significant nuclear chain reaction) actually turned out to cause significant nuclear yield if detonated from one point. Same source.
Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by Animats on Monday March 13, 2017 @01:26AM (#13855426)
Everything in the current US inventory has that property. The US didn't achieve that until 1960 or so, after extensive nuclear testing. It's not clear about the weapons of other nations.

The Hiroshima enriched uranium bomb was about as safe as an IED. It would have gone off if it hit the ground hard or was in a fire. The bomber crew had orders to dump the bomb in deep water if they had to abort the mission and return to base. Landing on Tinian with the bomb was considered far too risky.

Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by M_Grey on Sunday March 12, 2017 @06:30PM (#13853541)
Accidental detonation can include, "Sir, we have indications of multiple Russian launches!"... followed by ~15-45 minutes to decide it it's a glitch, or the end of the fucking world.

It has happened before, but fortunately without the detonation.

Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by eon1 on Sunday March 12, 2017 @08:24PM (#13854223)
Sounds like a loss of essence, IMO.
Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by M_Grey on Sunday March 12, 2017 @09:37PM (#13854574)
It has not recurred. I do deny them my essence.
Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by TheSpiceIsLife on Sunday March 12, 2017 @05:14PM (#13853169)
The fact one hasn't gone off is more a matter of there not being a ton of them in the first place.

There doesn't appear to be a consistent theory as to why we aren't all dead from nukes.

Your claiming there aren't enough of them to be dangerous, while elsewhere in the thread someone is trying to scare us with a very large number.

I'm willing to bet $1000 neither of us dies from a injuries sustained due to proximity to an accidental nuclear detonation of the warhead variety.

Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by charles-salvia on Sunday March 12, 2017 @05:42PM (#13853299)
> There doesn't appear to be a consistent theory as to why we aren't all dead from nukes.

Probably because launching a nuclear attack doesn't benefit nation states, if other nation states also have nuclear weapons. Also, all large high GDP nation states currently have intertwined economic dependencies, which also makes it less likely they would be inclined to launch nukes at each other.

Obviously, at the moment, North Korea stands out as a potential exception here, but they have nowhere near the number of warheads or industrial capacity to even play on the MAD doctrine level - they're certainly far from becoming anything like the next USSR.

So the only really remaining scenarios that could lead to a nuclear attack (barring massive changes in the current geopolitical order) would be that some non-nation-state actor, perhaps with fanatical motivations, gains access to a nuclear weapon. Although, in this case, without the state infrastructure to actually launch multiple warheads at the same time, it's unlikely that such an attack would be in any sense civilization-ending (even though it would certainly be very devastating, of course).

Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by jacquesm on Sunday March 12, 2017 @06:52PM (#13853695)
> but they have nowhere near the number of warheads or industrial capacity to even play on the MAD doctrine level

That's exactly the level they're playing at.

Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by jonknee on Sunday March 12, 2017 @05:19PM (#13853188)
> There doesn't appear to be a consistent theory as to why we aren't all dead from nukes.

We haven't had a nuclear war...

> Your claiming there aren't enough of them to be dangerous, while elsewhere in the thread someone is trying to scare us with a very large number.

I'm not claiming that at all, I'm just saying that just because one hasn't been accidentally detonated doesn't mean a whole lot. The biggest danger is surely an intentional detonation, but accidents do happen.

Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by TheSpiceIsLife on Sunday March 12, 2017 @10:32PM (#13854814)
What it does tell us is this: at the height of the nuclear arms race the USA and USSR collectively had in excess of 70,000 nuclear warheads.[1]

71 years have passed since the first nuclear bombs were used. That's 71 years without an accidental detonation nor a nuclear weapon used in an act of aggression on enemy soil.

Nuclear weapons exist and we aren't doing too bad of a job coping with that.

But, I suppose, as Steven Pinker is fond of saying: no one has ever recruited activists to a cause by announcing that things are getting better, and bearers of good news are often advised to keep their mouths shut lest they lull people into complacency. Also, a large swath of our intellectual culture is loath to admit that there could be anything good about civilization, modernity, and Western society.[2]

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_arms_race

2. http://www.nytimes.com/2011/10/06/books/review/the-better-an...

Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by vkou on Monday March 13, 2017 @12:56AM (#13855332)
A man falls off the roof of a ten-story building. As he's passing a third-story window, the occupants within can hear him shout: "So far, so good!"

Given the many. many known nuclear close calls (And I'm just counting the ones that were likely to cause a nuclear war - not domestic mishandling of materials), this is an insane position to take, with our current nuclear arsenals.

Four times in our nuclear history, the decision of one man saved us from armageddon. We are only having this conversation because people like Stanislav Petrov made the right decision - after the entire command-and-control system surrounding them failed.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nuclear_close_calls

Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by mikeash on Monday March 13, 2017 @09:56AM (#13857839)
What do you suppose is the risk per year of nuclear war? One in a hundred? One in a thousand? One in a million?

Going 71 years without it is compatible with all of those numbers, yet they mean very different things for our ability to prevent nukes from being used, and for our likely future.

I personally don't find it particularly comforting that we've made it this far. Just because we've made it 71 years doesn't mean we'll make it another 71.

Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by mikeash on Sunday March 12, 2017 @06:37PM (#13853580)
I'd take your bet, but only because I believe an intentional detonation is far more likely.

My vaguely informed guess is that the probability of nuclear war is around 1% per year. This is roughly consistent with what we saw during the Cold War (both the lack of a nuclear war and the numerous instances in which it almost happened) and seems to be consistent with the way things are set up today.

Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by M_Grey on Sunday March 12, 2017 @05:01PM (#13853082)
Detonation? No. Compromise of the physics package so that the whole mess is radioactive?
Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by TheSpiceIsLife on Sunday March 12, 2017 @11:12PM (#13854968)
This would only present a minor annoyance as far as chemical cleanup operations go.
Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by RugnirViking on Monday March 13, 2017 @01:14PM (#13859900)
I suggest you read about the cleanup of polonium around london after the alexander litvinenko incident. That is only for enough radioactive material to poision one person. Scale this up to a nuclear weapon and I imagine it would be a nightmare
Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by M_Grey on Monday March 13, 2017 @12:00AM (#13855136)
I'd love some citations for that claim.
Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by hbosch on Sunday March 12, 2017 @06:29PM (#13853536)
I challenge you to a game of International Warfare.

You get the truck, and I get the nuclear warhead. Sound fair?

Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by chinathrow on Sunday March 12, 2017 @04:46PM (#13853000)
> Trucks have killed more people than nuclear weapons ever will.

Well, we don't know that exactly as long as we keep stockpiling them throughout the world.

Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by TheSpiceIsLife on Sunday March 12, 2017 @04:51PM (#13853032)
Aren't there fewer nuclear warheads now than there were 5 years ago? And 5 years before that.

Or maybe you meant trucks, there does seem to be an ever increasing amount of those.

Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by chillacy on Sunday March 12, 2017 @09:06PM (#13854440)
You can't predict Black Swan events by looking at the past... by that logic 2008 shouldn't have happened because the markets were going up for so long. Actually I would stay out of predicting the future in absolutes myself... things are at best probabilistic.
Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by M_Grey on Sunday March 12, 2017 @05:02PM (#13853098)
There are over 2,500,000 Kilotons of nuclear warheads out there. Nagasaki and Hiroshima combined received about 38 Kilotons. Extrapolate from the realization that all of that death and destruction represents, in absolute terms, .000152% of the current arsenal.
Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by TheSpiceIsLife on Sunday March 12, 2017 @05:10PM (#13853143)
I'm still not scared.

There must be several orders of magnitude more steel rolling around the streets and highways, crashing in to people's living rooms, moving down cyclists, being used as weapons by drunks and crazies.

Threat of nuclear destruction doesn't factor in to my threat analysis at all. I'm more worried about data corruption in my photos backups, or my dog getting hit by a car, or dropping a 5000kg load of steel on myself, or someone else, at work.

Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by M_Grey on Sunday March 12, 2017 @05:12PM (#13853156)
That's why global problems like nuclear stockpiles and global climate change will kill us, while people are busy sorting their albums of pet photos. You're not wrong to focus on what you can control or at least change, but you're wrong to utterly shut out the rest, and contribute to your own demise as a result.
Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by bluedino on Sunday March 12, 2017 @05:56PM (#13853368)
>> Trucks have killed more people than nuclear weapons ever will.

one nuclear weapon in the wrong hands could change that.

Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by nickpsecurity on Sunday March 12, 2017 @04:31PM (#13852911)
Plus all the safety features mean they won't go off. I was told safety is even overdone to point that many are expected to be duds during atmospheric reentry due to fail-safe tripping by mistake.
Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by 467568985476 on Sunday March 12, 2017 @04:52PM (#13853041)
I would really recommend reading Eric Schlosser's phenomenal book Command and Control. I don't know who told you that about safety, but the book paints a very different picture. There have been numerous very close calls that could have resulted in accidental detonations and it's luck, not safety checks, that they didn't.
Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by bdowling on Sunday March 12, 2017 @06:10PM (#13853446)
The documentary film version is excellent as well.

http://www.commandandcontrolfilm.com

Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by nickpsecurity on Sunday March 12, 2017 @05:47PM (#13853323)
Im aware of some close calls from a long, long time ago. Sandia revamped a lot of the tech not long ago. The source might have been talking about one or the other. Ill do some more research since I only have hearsay from people at this point.
Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by tgragnato on Sunday March 12, 2017 @05:27PM (#13853224)
Not to mention the threat posed by the number of suitcase nuclear device russians allegedly lost control of.
Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by laughfactory on Sunday March 12, 2017 @05:34PM (#13853256)
Except that there are no suitcase size nuclear weapons. This is nothing but a scary myth.
Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by fotbr on Sunday March 12, 2017 @06:25PM (#13853511)
We (the US) managed to pack one into an 6" artillery shell that weighed 118 lbs (or 128lbs for the second version) - the W48 [1].

That's much smaller than a suitcase. Heavy, sure, but quite a bit smaller than the carry-on suitcase I was lugging around last week, and I've got a small one compared to the monstrosities that are considered to be carry-on sized now.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/W48

Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by wolf550e on Sunday March 12, 2017 @06:10PM (#13853448)
155mm artillery nukes like W48 were deployed. They fit in suitcases.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/W48

Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by tgragnato on Sunday March 12, 2017 @05:54PM (#13853359)
I read this paper some time ago, is fas.org a reliable source ? https://fas.org/sgp/crs/nuke/RL32572.pdf

> During the Cold War, the United States and Soviet Union both deployed nonstrategic nuclear weapons for use in the field during a conflict. While there are several ways to distinguish between strategic and nonstrategic nuclear weapons, most analysts consider nonstrategic weapons to be shorter-range delivery systems with lower yield warheads that might be used to attack troops or facilities on the battlefield. They have included nuclear mines; artillery; short-, medium-, and long-range ballistic missiles; cruise missiles; and gravity bombs. In contrast with the longer-range “strategic” nuclear weapons, these weapons had a lower profile in policy debates and arms control negotiations, possibly because they did not pose a direct threat to the continental United States. At the end of the 1980s, each nation still had thousands of these weapons deployed with their troops in the field, aboard naval vessels, and on aircraft.

> In 1991, the United States and Soviet Union both withdrew from deployment most and eliminated from their arsenals many of their nonstrategic nuclear weapons. The United States now has approximately 760 nonstrategic nuclear weapons, with around 200 deployed with aircraft in Europe and the remaining stored in the United States. Estimates vary, but experts believe Russia still has between 1,000 and 6,000 warheads for nonstrategic nuclear weapons in its arsenal. The Bush Administration quietly redeployed and removed some of the nuclear weapons deployed in Europe. Russia, however seems to have increased its reliance on nuclear weapons in its national security concept. Some analysts argue that Russia has backed away from its commitments from 1991 and may develop and deploy new types of nonstrategic nuclear weapons.

> The Soviet Union produced and deployed a wide range of delivery vehicles for nonstrategic nuclear weapons. At different times during the period, it deployed devices that were small enough to fit into a suitcase-sized container, nuclear mines, shells for artillery, short-, medium-, and intermediate-range ballistic missiles, short-range air-delivered missiles, and gravity bombs. The Soviet Union deployed these weapons at nearly 600 bases, with some located in Warsaw Pact nations in Eastern Europe, some in the non-Russian republics on the western and southern perimeter of the nation and throughout Russia. Estimates vary, but many analysts believe that, in 1991, the Soviet Union had more than 20,000 of these weapons. The numbers may have been higher, in the range of 25,000 weapons in earlier years, before the collapse of the Warsaw Pact.

Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by dfox on Sunday March 12, 2017 @06:24PM (#13853506)
laughfactory's point is that there are no nukes that actually fit into enclosure that one could call "suitcase".
Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by jacquesm on Sunday March 12, 2017 @06:54PM (#13853719)
And is wrong about that.
Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by dfox on Sunday March 12, 2017 @07:48PM (#13854031)
"Suit-case sized container" does not imply that it will actually fit into anything that looks like suitcase or otherwise be inconspicuously transportable, which is what all the scenarios of danger of suitcase nukes presume.

Even not taking the physical dimensions into account, the physics packages tend to be very heavy (which is mostly dictated by physics involved and trying to make the enclosure smaller seems to make it heavier, which makes sense given the physics).

In all I don't see how such weapon would be relevant for terrorist tactics, because using similar amount of effort one could just place large enough chemical explosive charge to cause significant (although several orders of magnitude smaller than from small nuclear warhead) damage.

Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by TheOtherHobbes on Sunday March 12, 2017 @09:13PM (#13854472)
Solving this problem doesn't require a huge amount of imagination. In fact the solution is rather obvious.

Let's just say that portable nukes are a very, very bad thing. A single 1kT nuke in the centre of a city would be very bad news on its own, and would make 9-11 look like a footnote. (1kT is a realistic yield for the ultra-portable Mk-54 warhead.)

Strategically, tiny nukes in small numbers are far more worrying than ICBMs, because unlike ICBMs they don't come with a built-in warning time or a sender's address.

Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by jacquesm on Sunday March 12, 2017 @09:16PM (#13854480)
> or a sender's address.

That maybe not, but the radioactive signature may give away the origin of the material.

That doesn't mean that's the party that planted it but it is at least going to provide a hint as to who initially put the warhead together.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_attribution

Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by jacquesm on Sunday March 12, 2017 @08:06PM (#13854107)
I could walk around Amsterdam all day with a 6" cross section piece of tubular metal and nobody would bat so much as an eye. And I have multiple suitcases large enough to put a 1 meter segment of that pipe in (inches, meters...).

Even the larger:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Davy_Crockett_(nuclear_device)

would easily fit, and those suitcases even have wheels so it would not look all that heavy to someone not lugging it.

Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by mikeash on Monday March 13, 2017 @10:00AM (#13857860)
Carting around a 120lb cylinder 6" in diameter and 33" long seems eminently doable in a rolling suitcase. You'll want to get a sturdy one and make sure your suicide bomber is well built, but I don't see what's so disbelievable about it.

Does this skepticism come from thinking "briefcase" rather than "suitcase," or...?

Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by tgragnato on Sunday March 12, 2017 @08:20PM (#13854201)
A chemical weapon is as effective as a portable nuclear device from a terroristic point of view (they tend to exploit vulnerabilities in the defence system to instill fear in the population), the main difference is probably the damage caused by the radiation.
Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by gaadd33 on Sunday March 12, 2017 @06:21PM (#13853496)
What about the M54? It looks like it would fit into a suitcase here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Davy_Crockett_(nuclear_device)...
Re:Troubled covert agency responsible for trucking nuclear b... by TheSpiceIsLife on Sunday March 12, 2017 @04:59PM (#13853075)
Somewhere a truck just killed someone right now.

I rest my case.