Re:Programming: Attitude Trumps Intelligence
by klochner on Thursday May 27, 2010 @06:23PM
(#1385115)
He maybe overstepped a little, but the principle is sound:
For robust, maintainable software systems, convention and simplicity trump cleverness.
Re:Programming: Attitude Trumps Intelligence
by abstractbill on Thursday May 27, 2010 @07:07PM
(#1385182)
Not the way he's meaning it. This is a follow-up to his previous post, which claims that "There are no super programming languages, only super programmers."
Cleverness gets you things like Garbage Collection. Convention and simplicity leaves us all using assembler because there's no need for "clever" language features.
I don't think programmers are alone in this problem, however. People by nature tend to get into their own factions and bash anyone else, even if they have more in common than not. (Also note that programmers do tend to be more harsh toward non-programmers than other programmers.) Though I think programmers haven't yet (to my knowledge) resorted to actual violence, which indicates at least a little more maturity than others...
"Maturing" doesn't make a better programmer, either, I don't think, and I'd rather have Linus Torvalds' programming abilities than anyone else I can think of right now. Plus, a lack of cleverness isn't going to save you, for no matter how much work and effort you put into digging a hole for that gold, a little cleverness would have told you you're digging in the wrong place.
Lastly, I really didn't like this bit:
"It is about realizing that the complexity of software dwarfs even the most brilliant human; that cleverness cannot win. The only weapons we have are simplicity and convention."
When you've met the most brilliant human, see which software dwarfs his brain and which doesn't. I bet a lot of brilliant people can handle a lot of different complexities. Finally, while I'm a fan of simplicity (in the Einstein sense), convention should hardly be a rule. Progress can only be made by breaking convention.