News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Blizzard Calls DRM a "Losing Battle" by pyre on Thursday May 27, 2010 @03:44PM (#1384735)
It's nice to see this coming from Blizzard, but it's not the 'full' story. They are just counter-acting piracy of the game by adding value through Battle.net. But they will defend Battle.net to the death.

The statements sound progressive and to a point they are, but this is just accomplished by moving the battle somewhere else. It's a lot easier to squash people trying to create alternate Battle.net servers/networks than it is to squash all of the cracking groups out there.

At least Blizzard is a company that is known for not abandoning their older titles (IIRC, you can still connect to Battle.net from the original StarCraft).

See:

- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bnetd

- http://www.eff.org/cases/blizzard-v-bnetd

[On a side note...] I came across this Battle.net 404 page while searching, anyone know which came first?

- 404 Page http://eu.battle.net/starcraft-universe.shtml?rhtml=y

- Original http://knowyourmeme.com/system/icons/185/original/nickcage.j...

Re:Blizzard Calls DRM a "Losing Battle" by Groxx on Thursday May 27, 2010 @04:14PM (#1384817)
They may not abandon them completely, but they come pretty darned close. Diablo 2, for instance, still pegs my system pretty hard - 100% on a single core. Their display code apparently requires 256 color mode on startup, but not in-game, leading to the Mac launch problems a while back. It also lags occasionally on a single player or local network game and takes a second or two to catch up. And if you've ever tried allowing more than one person behind a NAT to connect to Battle.net, you'd realize just how little they've touched the older games, despite how much money they still get from them.

(For those interested:) The only way to allow more than one person to connect to Battle.net in the older games is to rewrite packets on your router (iptables or similar), because the games steadfastly refuse to communicate on any other ports, and don't even communicate error messages. They just fail to connect, as if the servers are down. How hard would it be to specify a launch parameter which sets which port you use? Even if it's not simple for the average user, a solution is better than none, and this has been an acknowledged problem for many years.

Re:Blizzard Calls DRM a "Losing Battle" by algorias on Thursday May 27, 2010 @07:19PM (#1385203)
Counterexample: Just last year a StarCraft patch (1.16 IIRC) came out which drops CPU usage from 100% to around 3%
Re:Blizzard Calls DRM a "Losing Battle" by Groxx on Thursday May 27, 2010 @11:39PM (#1385633)
Yeah, the latest round of patches was pretty big, and it's nice they keep doing it. But it's also kinda sad they didn't make some of the critical changes earlier / yet. I have a feeling a lot of the motivation behind the updates was to get people to buy them before SC2/D3 comes out.
Re:Blizzard Calls DRM a "Losing Battle" by sliverstorm on Thursday May 27, 2010 @04:56PM (#1384924)
> But they will defend Battle.net to the death.

Of course they will. I should hope they would. It's the best and most successful alternative to DRM (that I am aware of) when it comes to curbing piracy, which they as a company NEED TO DO. DRM may be bad, but preventing piracy is not. I don't think they are trying come across as saying "we don't care about piracy".

Besides, Battle.net has provided some pretty darn good extra value.

Re:Blizzard Calls DRM a "Losing Battle" by mattmaroon on Thursday May 27, 2010 @05:57PM (#1385051)
On the other hand, no LAN games does suck.
Re:Blizzard Calls DRM a "Losing Battle" by timwiseman on Thursday May 27, 2010 @06:46PM (#1385156)
curbing piracy, which they as a company NEED TO DO

Let me state plainly that I believe piracy is generally immoral and I would be happy to see it vanish from the face of the earth. Let me also say that I think approaches like battle.net are much better than DRM.

But, they do not necessarily need to stop piracy. What they need to do is earn a reasonable and healthy profit.

They could (potentially) do this witout worrying about piracy at all. They would benefit from preventing all piracy that would otherwise have been a sale, of course, but if they are earning a profit even this is only beneficial, not necessary. The piracy that would not otherwise have been a sale is simply irrelevant to the company's health. In fact, in some circumstances piracy that would not otherwise have been a sale could be beneficial to them by providing publicity and helping to gain a fan base that will eventually make purchases (again, this should not in any way be read as condoning piracy, but it remains true.)

Re:Blizzard Calls DRM a "Losing Battle" by sliverstorm on Thursday May 27, 2010 @07:43PM (#1385251)
Yes, you are correct; in all likelihood, they technically do not have to fight piracy. I was just conjecturing that the cost of some piracy prevention is probably lower than the gains. i.e. squashing out every last pirate is financially a poor choice, but the low-hanging fruit are worthwhile. Typically I refer to a clearly wise business move as a 'need', though that is technically a mistake on my part.
Re:Blizzard Calls DRM a "Losing Battle" by algorias on Thursday May 27, 2010 @07:22PM (#1385210)
Yes, StarCraft is still alive and kicking on battle.net. Hardly surprising considering that the game is still incredibly popular in Korea, with a pro scene and all.
Re:Blizzard Calls DRM a "Losing Battle" by mquander on Thursday May 27, 2010 @07:32PM (#1385227)
I would point out that no serious or semi-serious players, in Korea or anywhere else, actually use Battle.net for Internet play. They generally use iCCup, a hacked-together custom implementation of Battle.net with its own ladder, anti-hack, and out-of-game integration. Blizzard is not happy about this and is apparently going to work as hard as possible to try to keep total control this time.
Re:Blizzard Calls DRM a "Losing Battle" by algorias on Friday May 28, 2010 @12:27AM (#1385693)
Of course, but the point is that Blizzard is still interested in maintaining the game for the foreseeable future, whether or not battle.net is the chosen medium through which serious players compete.