Read on the Toyota Production System for alternative solutions.
I think for any of us to try and go into specifics on that particular case, without a lot more information (unless we were there), is an exercise in pointless speculation. I think it goes without saying that all generalizations are flawed, and I'm sure the company did need more than just "stop giving me excuses". But a culture of no accountability can be a cause that needs to be addressed.
Read on the Toyota Production System for alternative solutions.
I devour everything on TPS / Lean / Kaizen that I can get my hands on. :-)
The way I see it, the symptom is giving excuses the day of, and the problem is people thinking they are entitled to a job with only putting forth minimal effort.
Having a safe work environment isn't the same thing as not holding people accountable.