Having a safe work environment isn't the same thing as not holding people accountable.
Read on the Toyota Production System for alternative solutions.
I think for any of us to try and go into specifics on that particular case, without a lot more information (unless we were there), is an exercise in pointless speculation. I think it goes without saying that all generalizations are flawed, and I'm sure the company did need more than just "stop giving me excuses". But a culture of no accountability can be a cause that needs to be addressed.
Read on the Toyota Production System for alternative solutions.
I devour everything on TPS / Lean / Kaizen that I can get my hands on. :-)
The way I see it, the symptom is giving excuses the day of, and the problem is people thinking they are entitled to a job with only putting forth minimal effort.
First, this creates selection for a culture that punches below its weight. Never willing to stetch itself. Underperformers apply here.
Second, this is fine when you don't have external dependencies who you can't simply fire. You may have to work at the speed of an organization that doesn't share these values and this becomes the rate limiting step to your growth.
Third, if your company is a rocketship and you have a lot of leverage over your employees, you may be able to pull this, but in practice you're going to have to pick your battles. Failure to create a safe work environment can erode trust and make for a toxic and fearful workplace.