Re:Hypersonic aircraft shatters aviation records
by run4yourlives on Thursday May 27, 2010 @05:12PM
(#1384962)
Given that we've been launching rockets and missiles into the atmosphere at speeds much faster than Mach 4 for the better part of a century now, I think we've solved that issue as far as practically required. :-)
Re:Hypersonic aircraft shatters aviation records
by rbanffy on Thursday May 27, 2010 @06:39PM
(#1385140)
It all depends on the altitude. If you are using a rocket, you can avoid the friction problem by going out of most of the atmosphere. Do that with an air-breathing engine and it will not function.
Re:Hypersonic aircraft shatters aviation records
by run4yourlives on Thursday May 27, 2010 @06:58PM
(#1385174)
As I said, solved as far as practically required, as your comment illustrates.
The viability of the scramjet being actually useful for anything is up for debate. Either you can fly slower with a jet, or leave the atmosphere altogether with a rocket.
Flying at orbital speeds within the atmosphere is of very, very marginal utility, given the number of complexities involved.
Re:Hypersonic aircraft shatters aviation records
by AngryParsley on Thursday May 27, 2010 @02:09PM
(#1384473)
The problem is that other countries can't tell whether an ICBM has a conventional warhead or a nuclear one. Russia wouldn't like it if the US launched an ICBM and said, "Trust us, it's just carrying a conventional warhead.. or ten."
Re:Hypersonic aircraft shatters aviation records
by retube on Thursday May 27, 2010 @12:29PM
(#1384138)
a scramjet will only _ever_ be able to operate at high speeds. The compression of intake air for combustion is achieved by the forward velocity of the engine itself (the engine has no moving parts) unlike a normal jet engine which uses a fan to compress the intake.
Any scramjet, current or future, will require some combination of other engines in order to accelerate the aircraft to a velocity at which the scramjet becomes self-sustaining (typically 3000+ mph I think).
Edit: needless to say, a stable self-sustaining scramjet is an INSANELY hard fluid dynamics problem.
Re:Hypersonic aircraft shatters aviation records
by rbanffy on Thursday May 27, 2010 @01:23PM
(#1384317)
You could use a conventional jet engine to pump its exhaust into the scramjet intake. It would have less oxygen, but a turbofan engine could compress enough air through the scramjet fast enough. The trick in this is to transition from subsonic flow in the turbofan to full supersonic engine operation.
Re:Hypersonic aircraft shatters aviation records
by rbanffy on Thursday May 27, 2010 @04:21PM
(#1384838)
You don't keep the turbofans in front of the scramjet all the time - you use them to give the scramjet enough air to start. As the speed increases, the turbofan engines would eventually cease to operate and could be shut off completely, leaving the scramjet to operate freely.
The turbofans are dead weight when you are cruising at Mach 7 in the upper atmosphere, but are useful for take off and landing.
Re:Hypersonic aircraft shatters aviation records
by andrewf on Thursday May 27, 2010 @04:59PM
(#1384934)
The SR-71 Blackbird's engines were hybrids; AFAICT they didn't quite use this approach, but instead had a layout where the same engine could function as a conventional jet and a ramjet depending on how fast air was hitting it.
Re:Hypersonic aircraft shatters aviation records
by rbanffy on Thursday May 27, 2010 @06:37PM
(#1385139)
Hmmm. The J58 is humongous, but it would be kind of cool to use them to start a scramjet (or, better, use it as the basis of another engine that can function in all three modes).
The SJX6 combustion chamber is not cylindrical and would not fit around a jet engine the way the J58 works in ramjet regime, but I bet many people are thinking about how to do it right now.
A scramjet engine that can take off and land like a more or less ordinary plane (it would certainly not look ordinary) is something very desirable.
Re:Hypersonic aircraft shatters aviation records
by retube on Thursday May 27, 2010 @01:45PM
(#1384399)
Yeah but then the turbo fan is blocking the air intake at high speeds. plus the exhaust of a turbo fan is subsonic, whereas a scramjet intake needs hypersonic intake.
the way to do it is either a) have a short-lived rocket engine to take you to the threshold speed, or b) bootstrap the aircraft using separate turbofan, ramjet and finally scramjet engines.
Re:Hypersonic aircraft shatters aviation records
by rbanffy on Thursday May 27, 2010 @04:27PM
(#1384860)
> plus the exhaust of a turbo fan is subsonic
You could funnel it to increase its speed. I am not a jet-engine expert, much less a ramjet/scramjet one, but the vestigial engineer in me suspects there is some practical solution hiding in this space.
Re:Hypersonic aircraft shatters aviation records
by a-priori on Thursday May 27, 2010 @12:30PM
(#1384142)
"A scramjet is a type of jet engine designed to operate at the speeds of rockets. Its main difference from a rocket is that it collects air from the atmosphere to burn its fuel rather than carrying an oxidizing substance on board. More conventional jets (turbojets, turbofans, and ramjets) share this characteristic but are unsuitable for the high speeds at which scramjets can operate." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scramjet#Simple_description
So there is a difference between a scramjet and a rocket, beyond the speed that it travels.
Re:Hypersonic aircraft shatters aviation records
by stcredzero on Thursday May 27, 2010 @02:40PM
(#1384551)
Years ago, on a "hacker-oriented" site, most everyone would've known this automatically through their interest in rockets and sci-fi. Times have changed.
If you carry 100% of your own fuel, you are subject to a nasty Rocket Equation. The fraction of your own weight that can be payload becomes vanishingly small, which can lead to structural and economic problems.
There are two news-worthy items here:
1. The ramjet/scramjet engine. (No moving parts)
2. The lack of a test pilot.
This is what makes this test significant.
The viability of the scramjet being actually useful for anything is up for debate. Either you can fly slower with a jet, or leave the atmosphere altogether with a rocket.
Flying at orbital speeds within the atmosphere is of very, very marginal utility, given the number of complexities involved.
Even at 4000 miles at out it wouldn't it still take up to 3 hours to get anywhere on the planet (24900 mile circumference)?
Somehow I expect the answer to that question to be "yes".
Right now, it can only operate at high speeds, hence the bomber-based launch.
Any scramjet, current or future, will require some combination of other engines in order to accelerate the aircraft to a velocity at which the scramjet becomes self-sustaining (typically 3000+ mph I think).
Edit: needless to say, a stable self-sustaining scramjet is an INSANELY hard fluid dynamics problem.
Looks like an interesting concept.
The scramjet's main advantages are cost and efficiency; to accomplish these gains it comes with a myriad of technical problems and hurdles.
The viability of the technology is actually still very much up for debate.
The turbofans are dead weight when you are cruising at Mach 7 in the upper atmosphere, but are useful for take off and landing.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pratt_%26_Whitney_J58
The SJX6 combustion chamber is not cylindrical and would not fit around a jet engine the way the J58 works in ramjet regime, but I bet many people are thinking about how to do it right now.
A scramjet engine that can take off and land like a more or less ordinary plane (it would certainly not look ordinary) is something very desirable.
the way to do it is either a) have a short-lived rocket engine to take you to the threshold speed, or b) bootstrap the aircraft using separate turbofan, ramjet and finally scramjet engines.
You could funnel it to increase its speed. I am not a jet-engine expert, much less a ramjet/scramjet one, but the vestigial engineer in me suspects there is some practical solution hiding in this space.
So there is a difference between a scramjet and a rocket, beyond the speed that it travels.
If you carry 100% of your own fuel, you are subject to a nasty Rocket Equation. The fraction of your own weight that can be payload becomes vanishingly small, which can lead to structural and economic problems.
Well...not useless, but not really being used to generate any lift.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waverider