News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:PEP 308 and why I still hate Python by zimzam on Thursday March 09, 2017 @09:52PM (#13835940)
I generally like python's list comprehensions, but they have some ugly warts. For example, a simple comprehension looks like this:

  foo = [transform(bar) for bar in baz.list()]
Adding an if condition looks like this:

  foo = [transform(bar) for bar in baz.list() if condition(bar)]
But an if/else expression looks like this:

  foo = [if condition(bar) transform(bar) else other_transform(bar) for bar in baz.list()]
Adding an else requires completely rewriting the line! Super ugly and inconsistent.

Edit: formatting... don't know why my the 'list()' in my last example is disappearing

Re:PEP 308 and why I still hate Python by marcstreeter on Thursday March 09, 2017 @10:29PM (#13836123)
maybe it's bad form but I generally prefer to break my list/dictionary/set comprehensions into various lines. For me it increases the readability

    foo = [
        if condition(bar) transform(bar) else other_transform(bar) # 1: storage
        for bar in base.list() # 2: iteration
        if bar_tester(bar). # 3: filtering
    ]

to each his own I suppose, until the PEP8 police come and get us all!!!
Re:PEP 308 and why I still hate Python by dragonwriter on Friday March 10, 2017 @07:36PM (#13843384)
Filters and ternaries aren't the same kind of thing (ternary if/else are analogous to SQL SELECT-clause case statements, filter if is analogous to SQL WHERE-clause; the positions in Python conditionals, which are very much like SQL SELECT statements, follows that analogy.)