the delivery service is actually a loss leader for instacart's underlying business, which is influencing purchase decisions through their app and getting paid for it. this is where brands compete with each other (just like shelf space in the store, which they also pay for), so it's where the money is. instacart also has fantastic shopping data tied to individual accounts that they can monetize in a number of ways. and then there is a bit of a winner-take-all element in that grocery stores are unlikely to want to integrate with more than one such service.
this last part is where the valuation comes from - it's a bet that instacart can become critical marketing infrastructure for the grocery industry. like many others, i'm skeptical because it's a risky strategy, but if they pull it off, they get a big payday.
Which is why the recently announced a change to tipping, where it would no longer be hanlded separately but instead as part of the regular checkout so as to make their revenue numbers look better.
They could certainly look into an advertising model for virtual shelf space, but that will be a significantly smaller amount of money than what they are doing in grocery delivery.
This is the same play as Seamless/Grubhub, and while they have a "promoted" listing which generates revenue, the majority of their revenue still comes from creating and order and doing the delivery.
The real benefit to Instacart from an investor perspective is that they are taking a distributed market and consolidating it into one single player. So while some stores may do their own delivery, by consolidating that space into a single player they are able to create tremendous volume.
Now, at 33% the value of whole foods that's a different matter. But there are some attractive pieces to Instacart's revenue story.
They don't stock inventory, so there aren't many carrying costs, they are charging 20% on the order which means they directly benefit from customers spending more and you can quickly see that their immediate revenue model assuming they can keep costs under control is definitely enough to justify the price.
The real question is how much money they are losing and if they are able to become profitable in the long run, but that will be a question that is decided well post IPO.
So while some stores may do their own delivery, by consolidating that space
into a single player they are able to create tremendous volume.
OP's point was that shoppers typically shop at 1-2 grocery stores. Seamless/GrubHub is different because people are more likely order from several restaurants across time.clairity makes an astute point that Instacart's personalized data is more valuable than any single grocery store's data. and competing on "store shelves" allows them to negotiate with brands directly, and totally circumvent the grocery stores.
.... but in order to do that, they need to capture the market, and they need their operating model to work well for long enough to meet that goal
Home delivery has been a standard offering from all major supermarkets in the UK for 5-10 years now. It's available in built-up areas and cities, as well as rural villages. They are able to do next-day delivery and give you a 1 hour delivery window. Groceries are the same price and delivery ranges from £1-5 depending on the delivery window you select. I really don't see how Instacart could compete with that if Wallmart and the others start to offer it in the US.
You don't have your email listed, but I'd love to get in touch if you could email me (in my profile). Thanks!
i have been working on the "future of work" problem and so have thought a bit about the business models of on-demand companies like instacart (relative to what they pay their workers). and i've been lucky enough to have people with interesting perspectives to talk to about such things.
If that were true, wouldn't a heck of an easier approach have been to setup an "ad network for retail delivery apps"? I think you might be underestimating both the difficulty of the logistics side of their business, and therefore its value as well. I've never really looked into Instacart (Not available here), but I imagine a more likely Instacart investment thesis is "if local businesses were given the option to not have to manage their delivery fleet, with minimal impact on other parts of their business, would they switch? + How much can we reduce the cost of local delivery due to scale/volume, and therefore is a monopoly position in local delivery achievable?
it's certainly possible that they have a credible story around how they get operationally profitable with the delivery business, but that's a margin-limited business that i don't think investors will get excited about. data and services are relatively high-margin businesses and that's why i think that's the play here.
but i agree that whoever solves the very hard last-mile logistics problem is going to be fabulously well-positioned (amazon, walmart, fedex, ups & uber seem to be the leading contenders). thinking that scale/volume will solve the problem is enticing, but so many companies have chased that holy grail only to fall short that i'm not sure that it isn't a mirage.
the other disadvantage of verticalization is that it limits access to consumer data. an aggregator like instacart will have access to comparative consumer data across stores and i think that should be far more valuable given how competitive the consumer products space is.
In most cases we are helping retailers create a new delivery experience for their customers, not replacing one that exists. It's actually quite complicated to operate our business and there are economies of scale that retailers benefit from by being part of a marketplace.
Also, when we talk to our customers about why they use Instacart, many of them do need groceries urgently, which is one of the reasons they use Instacart over alternatives. Most orders are delivered within 1-3 hours of being placed.
But on the topic of delivery/fulfilment, look at some of our grocers in Canada (Metro, Loblaws, Walmart) who are worth billions of dollars, yet whose only foray into online ordering is for pickup. Wow! Innovation!
A Loblaws near me was applauding itself for setting up the ability for buyers to order products online and pick it up in store, while people in the UK and parts of the US have been able to order groceries online and get it delivered for years. In 2013, Amazon Fresh expanded to SF. Full ordering and fulfilment. While in 2014, Loblaws launched the concept of click and collect, but has not expanded their offering to include delivery.
It's baffling to me that neither Loblaws nor Metro have at least tested online ordering and shipping in downtown Toronto like the way Amazon Fresh expanded into major American cities.
Now I live in downtown Toronto and I have to walk to the store (no car here) a carry groceries home, which means at best I can purchase a few day's worth of food at a time.
I would so gladly pay a reasonable amount for delivery, and I don't mean these bespoke pick-everything-and-deliver-within-an-hour services - I just want to be able to choose a time, pay maybe $5-$10 and have a week's worth of food delivered. Is that so hard Loblaws?
It takes time for the labor- maybe 2 hours of time for someone to get your food, bring it to your house, and go back. So that's probably at least $30 worth of their time.
So yeah, $5-$10 is not reasonable. If you're paying that little the labor is being subsidized by something else, or you're exploiting a desperate underpaid worker.
The marginal cost of one delivery is obviously not 2 man-hours, that'd be ridiculous.
Why not? 1 hour to walk around the store and collect everything, 20 minutes to check it out, load the car, drive the the person's house, 10 minutes to walk the groceries to their apartment, wait for them to sign and open the door, 20 minutes to drive back. At least 2 hours of work.
Yes. $5-$10 isn't a lot to get time critical cargo (spoilable food) that last mile.
Apparently it's at a level of difficulty such that Australia and the UK stores have already been doing this for the past 5-10 years...
[0] This assumes you're in Instacart's target market, aka rich yuppies who don't live in East Harlem
With Instacart, the pricing is extremely blurry with an added-on fee of ~20% or so. I can't justify spending $20 + 20% on groceries. I might as well as just order out every day.
https://np.reddit.com/r/boston/comments/5xj47l/ever_what_ins...
Maybe I'm lucky that I live within walking distance of a grocery store, but I'd be hard pressed to pay anything more than $5 for someone to drive my groceries to me. I could afford to pay for it, but if I kept that mentality my finances would die the death of a thousand papercuts.
How hard is this? Online ordering and grocery delivery is an existing thing and was before Instacart.
>It's similar to why self-checkout still doesn't work well at many stores
Self-checkout is a pain in the butt for things like produce. When you do a large grocery shopping, it is much easier and more efficient to have a clerk quickly scan everything (and there's usually a bagger too).
There are some experiments with shoppers self-scanning as they shop. Maybe something like that can still eventually work and you deal with produce somehow. (And figure out ways to minimize losses.)
This was done several years ago in the UK. American grocery stores are way, way behind the times.
EDIT: relying on anecdata from HN comments, I have never tried online grocery shopping in the US.
https://www.theguardian.com/money/2015/may/02/online-shoppin...
Why have the major retailers here been so slow off the mark?
One of the delivery guys even walked through our (open) door, dropped the food on the coffee table and put the VHS tape in for us.
Sadly, those economics didn't work out.
[ADDED: For example, Peapod is only available in some areas of the Northeast and Midwest]
It's been done for at least 5 years.
This service is not so popular yet (Im having hard time counting one friend who uses delivery services) but make it popular enough and Instacart and others will be out of the door.
This will be similar to LA-Fitness and other chains of gyms like Gold's Gym forbidding outside trainers for training gym members. You can only hire a gym instructor that is employeed by gym you attending.
Of course Instacart can ignore such ban and shop "incognito" but I doubt it would be great sales pitch to shareholders/investors.
BTW, for the grocery market., a $3,4B valuation isn't that large .
edit: update- couldn't find the specific post I was thinking of from hackernews but here's someone downthread who posted similarly outrageous findings: https://np.reddit.com/r/boston/comments/5xj47l/ever_what_ins...
Plus I don't think Instacart is really in the grocery business. They are in the delivery business and grocery stores are their warehouses. I really have a hard time seeing $3+ billion of value there.
Maybe they are thinking about getting into the grocery business though.
http://www.businessinsider.com/whole-foods-biggest-problem-2...
But the bigger issue with Instacart / Google Shopping Express is they're effectively value-add middlemen whom can be cut-out, undercut, gamed and so on. WalMart, Safeway/Vons, Amazon, Costco have the muscle ( distribution and capital) to squash them like Mr. Wonderful's proverbial cockroaches.
What service do supermarkets provide themselves? I think it's debatable. Safeway in CA had delivery, and using it was a guaranteed way to get bruised, nearly un-sellable produce. Safeway must have told its pickers to pick the fruit and vegetables that were about to expire... and the same for milk, cheese, or any limited shelf-life item.
Instacart has only the incentive of pleasing the customer. I've had zero issues with suboptimal produce being picked by Instacart shoppers.
So I'd argue that whatever supermarkets need as a core competency to compete in the existing (pre-Instacart) market, providing high quality delivery and e-commerce experiences are not part of that.
I think supermarkets are essentially market makers for household goods, produce, etc. They must understand demand in order to keep the right items in stock.
Beyond that, they seem to flounder between providing super-low margins (and the corresponding slow checkout lanes) or a more premium expeirence with higher markup and other entertainment features (music, oyster bars, etc.)
In the cities I've lived in, all of the in-house delivery options had significantly constrained delivery options.
So my question is: how do investors project that an intermediary like Instacart can outcompete the same service provided by the supermarkets themselves? Doordash can compete on variety and speed, but most folks shop at the same one or two supermarkets all the time and rarely need groceries urgently.