News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Plummeting Marijuana Prices Create A Panic In California by pstuart on Wednesday May 26, 2010 @12:12PM (#1380618)
I have yet to hear a cogent argument against legalization.
Re:Plummeting Marijuana Prices Create A Panic In California by aptimpropriety on Wednesday May 26, 2010 @12:31PM (#1380686)
Try this thread from a year ago:

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=554166

which links to this article: http://steve-yegge.blogspot.com/2009/04/have-you-ever-legali...

Perhaps not an argument against, but certainly a 'reality' check argument against the "it's so obvious we should do it" mentality that seems to thrive in online forums.

Re:Plummeting Marijuana Prices Create A Panic In California by Retric on Wednesday May 26, 2010 @01:09PM (#1380816)
Work is hard, let's go shopping. Is a poor argument. The real issue is the total difficulty of all issues not simply the number of them.

EX: A "major" issue is it's hard to detect if someone is currently under the effects of pot. Because, apparently drug test are designed to detect if you have smoked not if you are currently impaired. However, an officer can do a road side sobriety test without using a breatilizer so it's not a real issue.

Now if there was some sort of bioaccumulation of pot ever time that caused massive issues then that single issue could prevent legalization on its own.

Re:Plummeting Marijuana Prices Create A Panic In California by moe on Wednesday May 26, 2010 @01:36PM (#1380910)
Now if there was some sort of bioaccumulation of pot ever time that caused massive issues then that single issue could prevent legalization on its own.

I don't see a problem. Pot use can be detected, sometimes days (or weeks) after. The law in most of europe is simple: If you're tested positive while driving then your license is gone.

Seems fair enough.

Re:Plummeting Marijuana Prices Create A Panic In California by Retric on Wednesday May 26, 2010 @01:46PM (#1380948)
My point is if you get high and are only impaired for 8 hours then after 8 hours if you are not impared you should be able to drive. If you must wait 2 weeks after smoking to drive then it's not exactly legal for most people.

The bioaccumulation idea was a separate issue; if smoking pot for 30 years turned people into zombies with an uncontrollable desire to eat brains then it should be illegal regardless of other negatives. (I could not think of any issues like this so I made something up for the sake of argument.)

PS: You can probably detect pot in the blood of 75% of Americans if you set your threshold low enough. (Second hand smoke from 2 blocks away etc.) That does not mean it's impossible to separate smokers from non smokers just you need to set a reasonable threshold and accept you might miss the occasional smoker.

Re:Plummeting Marijuana Prices Create A Panic In California by moe on Wednesday May 26, 2010 @02:05PM (#1381023)
My point is if you get high and are impaired for 8 hours then after 8 hours you should be able to drive. If you must wait 2 weeks after smoking to drive then it's not exactly legal for most people.

Well, the tests are not that precise (yet), but it's the same with alcohol. You may very well be tested positive if you had been drunk the day before.

Imho that's just fair. If I want to smoke then leaving the keys at home for a few days seems reasonable. If I want to be a regular pot smoker then I shouldn't be driving anyways, as my reflexes are permanently reduced.

I can attest to the latter from experience, as I used to smoke quite a bit for a while. The longterm effect on concentration and memory have been fairly small, but definitely noticeable.

Re:Plummeting Marijuana Prices Create A Panic In California by Retric on Wednesday May 26, 2010 @02:39PM (#1381169)
This is way out of my area of expert ease, but as I understand it alcohol tests are focused on the presence of alcohol because they are trying to see if someone is currently impaired. Pot tests are focused on metabolic waste products from Pot because the goal is to discover if someone has smoked in the past not if they are impaired. This is why at least one type of Pot test can get false positives from taking an over the counter pain killer as they both produce the same metabolic waste.

Anyway, as a non smoker I assumed Pot like most drugs had a fairly short term effect, if you are impaired for 3-7 days then that's a separate issue I was not aware of.

Re:Plummeting Marijuana Prices Create A Panic In California by moe on Wednesday May 26, 2010 @05:06PM (#1381695)
Bit surprised about the downvotes (some pot fanatic around? ;-) ).

FWIW, I've been smokin' quite a bit myself for a few years, I'm in no way against it.

I think your reasoning is not correct. I think the quick-tests go for the metabolic waste simply because there is no other reliable test short of taking your blood.

I've not been in the situation but I guess that blood test will take place before you actually lose the license, just like with alcohol.

Anyways, like I said, I know what I was like when I was smokin' frequently and anyone who does will probably agree that your overall performance is slightly reduced even a few days after. For that reason I'm okay with not allowing people to drive during a reasonable timespan.

Re:Plummeting Marijuana Prices Create A Panic In California by ErrantX on Wednesday May 26, 2010 @02:37PM (#1381150)
I have yet to hear a cogent argument against legalization.

I have a couple of pretty simple one (it's worth considering).

The long term affects of pot abuse are pretty easy to develop - I've seen medium-heavy users become fairly "brain dead" after several years of use. This is entirely from observation but it seems to occur faster than the same effect due to alcohol abuse. As a result we could see quite a few problems from more long term users.

It is also harder to determine if someone is under the influence. This would mean some industries would have to begin mandatory drug testing prior to performing sensitive work - random examples: doctors, pilots. That's costly, time consuming etc. And if the long term affects of the drug are as pronounced as I suspect you could see heavy abusers in those fields actually pass drug tests and still fail to concentrate at a critical moment.

It's certainly an area that needs a lot more research before legalization occurs.

Re:Plummeting Marijuana Prices Create A Panic In California by pstuart on Wednesday May 26, 2010 @03:53PM (#1381441)
But this presumes that keeping it illegal prevents people from using it, and it clearly doesn't.

Mandatory drug tests are common already (Home Depot does drug tests on all employees -- don't you feel safer about hardware?) People's performance are also impacted by stress, sleep deprivation, etc. - they should be monitored for performance, not blood chemistry.

>It's certainly an area that needs a lot more research before legalization occurs.

No it doesn't. It's safer than other existing legal drugs: http://www.saferchoice.org/content/view/24/53/

A gallery of loser stoners: http://coedmagazine.com/2009/02/06/the-10-most-successful-po...

And if it is a concern about people's health, why is it treated as a criminal matter?

Re:Plummeting Marijuana Prices Create A Panic In California by ErrantX on Wednesday May 26, 2010 @05:53PM (#1381856)
People's performance are also impacted by stress, sleep deprivation, etc. - they should be monitored for performance, not blood chemistry.

Solid point. I can't disagree. Possibly the only issue worth raising is that cannabis influence may not be as physically obvious as those things you mention. For example a nurse may notice a brain surgeon is looking fatigued and raise concerns, but if on drugs his attention may wander at random moments which are not immediately obvious in the same way.

Re:Plummeting Marijuana Prices Create A Panic In California by marltod on Wednesday May 26, 2010 @01:09PM (#1380815)
The most effective argument is that it is a "Gateway Drug". There is no proof that weed makes people use crack or heroin but it is a good way to scare the public.
Re:Plummeting Marijuana Prices Create A Panic In California by awolf on Wednesday May 26, 2010 @01:48PM (#1380959)
Marijuana is a gateway drug to other illegal drugs because it itself is illegal. In order to get marijuana you need to go see a guy that is ALSO selling other drugs (the kind that are actually dangerous).

Legal marijuana makes it so that people don't start using more dangerous drugs on a whim. They are no longer presented with an easy opportunity.

If pot is on the same level as alcohol which do you think is more of a gateway drug? One that makes you introverted and cautious or one that makes you more confident while simultaneously impairing your judgement?

Re:Plummeting Marijuana Prices Create A Panic In California by pyre on Wednesday May 26, 2010 @09:04PM (#1382343)
It's also a 'gateway drug' in that you don't go crazy and commit mass-murder when you try it the first time, so you start to disbelieve all of the anti-drug propaganda and maybe decide that 'they' were lying about the harder drugs too.
Re:Plummeting Marijuana Prices Create A Panic In California by hugh3 on Wednesday May 26, 2010 @12:14PM (#1380633)
I was tempted to give one, but I don't think this is a good forum for discussing such a boring political issue. Please keep pro/anti drug legalization arguments elsewhere.
Re:Plummeting Marijuana Prices Create A Panic In California by fjabre on Wednesday May 26, 2010 @12:18PM (#1380645)
Why? Flag the posting then. It's certainly relevant to the article.
Re:Plummeting Marijuana Prices Create A Panic In California by jokermatt999 on Wednesday May 26, 2010 @01:00PM (#1380779)
I'm new(ish) here, but I don't see why not. HN tends to have a much better atmosphere for serious discussion than most web forums I've seen. I'd be happy to hear both sides of this argument here, and hopefully to see more reasonable debate than what is usually presented.
Re:Plummeting Marijuana Prices Create A Panic In California by davidw on Wednesday May 26, 2010 @03:32PM (#1381373)
It has a pleasant atmosphere in part because it mostly avoids inflammatory topics like politics. I'd much rather talk startups and business, and maybe living abroad with patio11, for instance, than discuss why he's a Republican and I'm not. The former is bound to be a useful, interesting discussion; the latter most likely not.

Actually, I'd be ok with the latter discussion too, but only in person, not on an internet fourm.

Re:Plummeting Marijuana Prices Create A Panic In California by blhack on Wednesday May 26, 2010 @12:35PM (#1380694)
>Please keep pro/anti drug legalization arguments elsewhere.

Please don't take this the wrong way, but your account is 49 days old...I'm not sure that you're at the "I get to tell people what sorts of discussions they're allowed to have" stage yet, especially not to people that have been here for almost three years.

Re:Plummeting Marijuana Prices Create A Panic In California by hugh3 on Wednesday May 26, 2010 @12:55PM (#1380759)
Would it be okay if I had been around for 1021 days like this guy?

http://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=hugh

Re:Plummeting Marijuana Prices Create A Panic In California by blhack on Wednesday May 26, 2010 @01:10PM (#1380820)
Honestly? Not really. It's an open forum, I don't think it's really ever good form to tell somebody "hey, you're not supposed to talk about that here." (unless it's spam, in which case, just downvote. Saying "don't talk about that" is off-topic and has been specifically addressed by PG in the past.)

I'm sorry I didn't know that you had an alt account, it's just annoying when people start showing up and trying to dictate how things "should be" to established members of an existing community.