News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NASA proposes a magnetic shield to protect Mars' atmosphere by bleair on Sunday March 05, 2017 @08:35PM (#13800111)
Does building a magnetosphere for the purposes of protection require an atmosphere, or is it all about capturing and shaping solar wind?

If it doesn't require an atmosphere, could this approach be used to build a magnetospher around the moon? It feels like colonizing the moon first is a much easier and more useful problem to tackle. Once we have a moon colony you can crack water to make fuel and then go "where ever" you'd like - other asteroids, or mars. The moon is much closer and easier to get to, though maybe people need the "excitement" that travel to Mars connotates.

Re:NASA proposes a magnetic shield to protect Mars' atmosphere by brianberns on Sunday March 05, 2017 @08:59PM (#13800204)
IIUC, the proposal is to build a magnetic shield at a stable Lagrange point between Mars and the sun. Mars would be far away, in the "shade" created by the shield. So there's no magnetosphere around Mars. It's more like a magneto-cylinder. :)

This image explains it better than I can: https://3c1703fe8d.site.internapcdn.net/newman/gfx/news/2017...

I don't think an approach like this would work for the moon, because there's no stable Lagrange point between the moon and the sun. (And even if we did build a magnetic shield for the moon somehow, I think it's still too small to accumulate an atmosphere.)

Re:NASA proposes a magnetic shield to protect Mars' atmosphere by ant6n on Monday March 06, 2017 @01:33AM (#13801053)
L1 isn't a _stable_ Lagrange point. I think only L4, L5 are.
Re:NASA proposes a magnetic shield to protect Mars' atmosphere by kitsunesoba on Monday March 06, 2017 @01:58AM (#13801127)
It's a common misconception that the moon is easier to get to. As far as rocket launches are concerned, getting to the moon is as difficult as getting to Mars. Worse, the moon has no atmospheric drag to assist with landing. The only way the moon is better is it's closer, which is almost a moot point because all the difficulty is tied up in getting off of Earth. And unless dramatic changes in our space flight capabilities take place, it's no easier to mount a timely rescue mission to the moon than it is to Mars - by the time we launch anything it'll be weeks or months after any accident takes place and well beyond the length of time stranded astronauts could survive.

Beyond that, the moon is generally much less suited for long term habitation than Mars is for several reasons. I won't get into details about that right here (unless you want me to) and Mars isn't exactly a cakewalk either, but the moon poses a more significant challenge in many ways.

That said, I welcome any kind of manned missions/outposts/colonies etc, whether the be on the moon or Mars or somewhere else entirely. I just believe that the payoff for starting on Mars could be much greater than doing the same on the moon.

Re:NASA proposes a magnetic shield to protect Mars' atmosphere by jacobush on Monday March 06, 2017 @06:01AM (#13801906)
The atmospheric drag on Mars is a bitch. Too little to help much, too much to ignore. Go too low and you burn up. Too high and you skip on the surface.
Re:NASA proposes a magnetic shield to protect Mars' atmosphere by lutusp on Monday March 06, 2017 @03:10AM (#13801386)
> Does building a magnetosphere for the purposes of protection require an atmosphere ...

No, it's the other way around -- for a sustainable atmosphere, one needs a magnetic field.

> If it doesn't require an atmosphere, could this approach be used to build a magnetospher around the moon?

That would have an effect on surface radiation from charged particles, but the moon can't have an earth-like atmosphere because of its low gravity. So the payoff is smaller.

More details: http://arachnoid.com/restoring_mars

Re:NASA proposes a magnetic shield to protect Mars' atmosphere by Tuna-Fish on Sunday March 05, 2017 @09:58PM (#13800389)
The problem with using this approach with the Moon is that there is no stationary orbit that would keep the magnetic shield properly between the Moon and the Sun. Mars can use the Sun-Mars L1, but no such point exists for the Moon.
Re:NASA proposes a magnetic shield to protect Mars' atmosphere by logfromblammo on Monday March 06, 2017 @10:46AM (#13803397)
Wouldn't it be a halo orbit around the Sun-Earth L1?
Re:NASA proposes a magnetic shield to protect Mars' atmosphere by Armisael16 on Sunday March 05, 2017 @08:58PM (#13800201)
Where does the water come from?
Re:NASA proposes a magnetic shield to protect Mars' atmosphere by criddell on Sunday March 05, 2017 @09:05PM (#13800227)
There's more than a trillion pounds of water ice on the moon.
Re:NASA proposes a magnetic shield to protect Mars' atmosphere by Armisael16 on Sunday March 05, 2017 @09:54PM (#13800376)
Mixed in with rock at low concentrations. Are you proposing shipping massive mining machines to the Moon?
Re:NASA proposes a magnetic shield to protect Mars' atmosphere by criddell on Sunday March 05, 2017 @10:14PM (#13800429)
This is a thread about building a magnetic shield to protect an entire planet. Shipping some gear to the poles of the moon to melt ice doesn't seem that crazy in comparison.
Re:NASA proposes a magnetic shield to protect Mars' atmosphere by PaulHoule on Sunday March 05, 2017 @09:05PM (#13800230)
Mars has a lot of water, it is just solid.