Re:To keep Tor hack source code secret, DOJ dismisses child ...
by ChuckMcM on Sunday March 05, 2017 @07:12PM
(#13799755)
The structure is to keep police officers honest which is more important than a particular person going to jail. The operating principle is that a dishonest police force is more dangerous than a criminal who was caught using illegal evidence. Typically the criminal will commit another crime and if you get evidence against them legally, then you can prosecute them for the new crime.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:To keep Tor hack source code secret, DOJ dismisses child ...
by gpm on Sunday March 05, 2017 @09:50PM
(#13800364)
The "we both go to jail" policy would probably do even betting at keeping police officers honest. The threat of the officer going to jail being significantly worse than the threat of allowing the criminal to walk free.
The details are sketchy, who prosecutes the police/prosecutors? But in principle I think it makes sense.
Re:To keep Tor hack source code secret, DOJ dismisses child ...
by Frogolocalypse on Sunday March 05, 2017 @10:00PM
(#13800395)
> worse than the threat of allowing the criminal to walk free.
Alleged criminal. You realize you're innocent until proven guilty, right?
Re:To keep Tor hack source code secret, DOJ dismisses child ...
by Cerium on Sunday March 05, 2017 @10:38PM
(#13800505)
A "we both go to jail" policy would have the same incentives we see in the Wells Fargo example. We need top down incentive to follow the law at all levels. The current situation means that nobody profits from failure to follow the law.
Re:To keep Tor hack source code secret, DOJ dismisses child ...
by Retra on Sunday March 05, 2017 @11:27PM
(#13800703)
>The threat of the officer going to jail being significantly worse than the threat of allowing the criminal to walk free.
Not if the officer going to jail is being manipulated by their superiors or is otherwise arranged to take the fall for someone else.
Re:To keep Tor hack source code secret, DOJ dismisses child ...
by denzil_correa on Sunday March 05, 2017 @07:48PM
(#13799924)
> The operating principal
Wouldn't the right word be "principle"?