All of the interview processes I've had recently have checked I did the exercise by either asking me to describe what I built with no aid, asking me to walk through the code with it in front of me, or asking me to conceptually expand on what I built on a whiteboard.
Whittle down the pool even further and the ones you think look good on paper, and after an interview (or a series of them), have them come in, on a paid basis.
It'd be a sign of good faith that they're both serious about finding a good candidate, and respectful of your time?
I know some companies do paid stuff like that. If only it were more commonplace.
I did an assignment like that for a company once, I'm still waiting for the money for more than one year...
Note that 5-minute-long task is a good pre-filter on its own.
I wonder if the best thing to do is to simply offer the candidate a choice.
Why is that a bad thing? The prospective candidates aren't entitled to anything, the burden should be on them to prove they have any capabilities for the job.
> What is the employer putting up? Generally nothing.
Totally incorrect, have you ever had to hire somebody? The initial phone screens alone to weed out the 99% of complete incompetents takes many hours/days. Even getting to the list of phone screens, involves many hours of sifting through resumes, where each resume is cleverly designed to hide the fact that the prospective candidate is incompetent.
I echo the grandparent's sentiments, myself, from my own personal experience as well.
>If you want the job, you'll find four hours.
But what happens when everyone starts having these 4 hour screens? Now its a 40 hour process to apply for 10 jobs in a week (and this is before any commitment on the part of the employer). It's not sustainable or fair. And yet, there's no incentive for employers not to do it. So we as job seekers just need to suck it up and be thankful for the opportunity, right?
After interviewing 10 (say two three hours spent on each between contacting, scheduling up etc) it was clear every unemployed with 'can use word' as skill boosted their resume and applied.
I'm sorry for the real developers looking for a job but a company can't dump 20 days work on chasing and weeding liers.
I'm not a fan of homeworks myself but this is what it has come to.
I'd be payng but that puts the company and the prospect in a very difficult position them towards tax laws and towards their current employer non competes, the company toward again tax laws and then there's the absurd of paying for contract work delivered that's 99% of times not up to spec.
Beside, the unwillingness to compromise smells itself and given the choice I'd never get a potential troublemaker in that only thinks time=money and screw everything else.
That little empathy for both sided of the problems sure is a red flag.
Edit: well unless it's a contracting job then it's fine.
we used to give out this http://play.elevatorsaga.com/#challenge=3 and asking for solution to level 3 which can be done in a short time + is the first non trivial challenge.
of course solutions can be find in internet etc, but it's pretty easy to look them up if they smell fishy and it'd all come down crashing at the face-to-face anyway
it's also a very good exercise in real world problem solving and a source of endless technical discussion since there's no single good approach, especially with two elevators to schedule.
Most of the places I've been at were desperate for 'good' people and they couldn't seem to find them. It's still a seller's market out there.
If this were true people would be poached a lot more frequently than what we can observe now.
Can you, personally, pay me a salary? If you can and I want to work with you, I absolutely think it's fair to ask four hours of my own time to demonstrate I'm worth consideration for it. If not, then why does your opinion matter?
Furthermore, I already have a job, just as most reasonable candidates do - so if you want to convince me that I should spend many hours on that, you'd better be sure that your offer has a really attractive first impression and seems likely to be better than the job I currently have, otherwise you'll be self-selecting your candidates only from the (generally less skilled) sub-population of workers for whom "If you want the job, you'll find four hours" is true because they actually are desperate for jobs, unlike most skilled people in tech industry.
I have never seen a job posting I was sufficiently interested in to put in 4 hours with no investment from the company.
Regardless, if you have a good job already, why apply to any position you're not particularly interested in and that you wouldn't spend four hours trying to get?
Why would I spend any of my already very limited time if they didn't make sure the process is streamlined?
Also, I don't think it's uncommon to like what a company does and being interested without yet knowing if you're interested enough to put the time aside - most company sites and job descriptions are much too generic and vague, so I'd want to talk to some employees first (remember, interviews are two way conversations). So I might not know if I'm interested enough at the time of application, just that I might be.
[1] for my current job, the interview process was essentially them trying to persuade me to join them, and my previous job I was actively looking for a job and someone I know at the company said I should apply. My "application" consisted of telling him "ok set up an interview"
The standard process where the first two steps are some ordering of a 1-hour interview with someone technical and a chat with a recruiter is perfect for this. With minimal effort (maybe 90 minutes) you find out whether they're interested in you at all, and get to ask both a technical person and a recruiter about the job.
The big time investment typically comes later, and I can easily bail if I decide it isn't going to be a compelling offer. I've done this quite a bit.
I'm glad the homework process worked for you, but my point that it doesn't seem like a good idea for the company stands. If the first thing you do is filter based on how badly applicants need a job, you're losing a significant portion of the best people right off the bat.
So now I'm doing a day and a half of unpaid work for them, taken out of evenings and time with the family.
Not hypothetical. I just described my last job hunt, 16 months ago.
The place I really wanted to go closed the req on me, and then opened it back up the day after I started at another place. My third choice (stars didn't align on the other 2 interviews, in part because of stuff like this).
So you block off 4-8 hours of your life for this job you're really excited about. What is the employer putting up? Generally nothing. They get a sea of responses and they get to pick a few of the best ones. The 100 responses they got cost these candidates 400+ hours of time for no cost to the employer whatsoever.
Take home assignments are fine, but the employer needs to put up something as well. Either pay for the time I spend on it, or have the assignment late in the interviewing process and have employment contingent on passing some known bar ahead of time. That is, I should be the only one doing the assignment and there should be no wishy-washy rejections.