It seems like Apple could retain these benefits by including a MobileMe subscription with every iDevice, but not making it outright "free". Once 90% of iCustomers have MobileMe accounts, Apple would be motivated to improve it and add more Google-like cloud syncing.
[edit]Changed suggested price of Find My Phone from $10/incident before someone had replied to it, but then I noticed my edit made his reply not make sense, hence this note.[/edit]
As an aside, I have to say that I can't imagine using an iPhone without MobileMe - it would lose a lot of its appeal for me!
For .Mac, the fact that the service is paid and not ad-supported means that I don't have the awkward situation of my vendor being incentivized to sift through all my information with a fine comb in order to sell me their partners' products.
For syncing of iDevices, the fact that the data goes directly from the device to my computer is much more acceptable than having to make everything pass through Google's servers.
I'm much more comfortable with both of these situations than their equivalents on Google's platform.
I'm of the opinion that Apple made the right choice in keeping their brand clean from all the privacy issues with those free ad-supported services, opting instead for classical b2c relationships (service to client in exchange for money) with the implied privacy protection of typically confidential business to customer relationships.
The author [also] makes the repeated mistake of assuming cloud services are better than the obviously obsolete trail of tears that is syncing to a computer. What if my personal and relationship data is valuable to me, and I don't want to have to upload it to ANYONE WHATSOEVER? What if I want to be able to transfer it directly to another device I own without having it reside on a third party device? That's worth money to me, and that's what I'm paying Apple for.
[edit]Made it slightly more clear that I'm talking about two different topics, .mac and syncing of data from iPhones and iPads.[/edit]