News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Buried Alive: Stories from Inside Solitary Confinement by IsaacL on Friday March 03, 2017 @08:11AM (#13782586)
Do you know how much people suffer if their house is broken into, if they are robbed at gunpoint, if they are raped, etc? Not just the direct harm, but the ongoing psychological harm?
Re:Buried Alive: Stories from Inside Solitary Confinement by jamescostian on Friday March 03, 2017 @08:22AM (#13782636)
That harm is truly awful. But I believe Gandhi said something like "An eye for an eye leaves the whole world blind."

If you don't care about the people in solitary, why not at least care about their psychological state once they get out? Imagine someone who was in solitary being freed, and then deciding to harm some people. Don't you think the person from solitary, who has had a bunch of psychological issues from solitary, would be even worse than someone who hasn't been in solitary?

P.S. your original Iron Man framing makes me want to respond in kind with a strawman: imagine a person hooked on cigarettes goes to prison for a crime they didn't even commit, and then they are caught with cigarettes and put in solitary. I'd say that's also truly awful

Re:Buried Alive: Stories from Inside Solitary Confinement by MaxfordAndSons on Friday March 03, 2017 @11:39AM (#13784030)
But why does the magnitude of that harm justify harming the perpetrator an equal amount? What is the logic of retribution?

It seems inherently fair to our animal instincts that a victim of violence should received "satisfaction" for their unjust suffering. But do the victims gain anything from this supposed satisfaction? Maybe some of them do experience a reduction in their ongoing suffering; I doubt it makes the pain of loss go away entirely for most.

But more importantly, how does the system of retributive justice impact society beyond the perpetrators and victims? I would argue that its impact is almost entirely negative. The perpetrators are themselves repeatedly victimized, often disproportionately to their original crimes - by the general dehumanization of jailing, violence at the hands of other prisoners and guards, social humiliation and pariahdom, economic and political disenfranchisement. But their victimizations are largely considered just and legal, and thus they cannot redress their grievances through the law. So what do they do? Leave jail wounded, aggrieved and with further criminal training, even more likely to commit crimes (and worse ones at that) than when they went in. Thus they create more victims, and the cycle of suffering is perpetuated and amplified.

Re:Buried Alive: Stories from Inside Solitary Confinement by IsaacL on Friday March 03, 2017 @02:24PM (#13785468)
The logic is based on the needs of any society. Every society needs a set of rules which everyone agrees to follow. History shows that the smaller the set of rules, the better, but you need to at least prevent people from infringing the life and liberty of others.

The simple reason for retribution is deterrence: there should be a negative incentive to committing crimes. The deeper reason is to make the kind of world people can live in. When everyone sees that criminals are punished, it tells would-be criminals to think twice, and it tells law-abiding citizens that someone is looking out for them.

I don't think punishment should be excessively cruel, prison is probably sufficient, and excessive solitary confinement is probably unjustified. But many people on this thread seem to think punishment in general is always unjust.

I think the underlying this is the modern belief that no-one is responsible for their actions, and that criminals are the product of social forces who need compassion and understanding. The argument against that is the standard argument against any form of determinism - if people are determined by outside forces, so are judges and prison guards, who similarly cannot help themselves from punishing criminals, and so should not face moral judgement. It's contradictory to judge judges but forgive criminals.

Re:Buried Alive: Stories from Inside Solitary Confinement by MaxfordAndSons on Friday March 03, 2017 @03:14PM (#13785961)
I'm actually not arguing for an absence of punishment, but rather against punishments whose only end is retribution. Things like solitary confinement, mandatory minimums, inhumane conditions, forced prison labor and more, all very normalized within the US criminal justice system, are all suspect practices whose only definite result is an increase in suffering. Punishment could be educational and rehabilitative (and still austere and undesirable, without being purposelessly cruel).

Deterrence is commonly cited as a justification for retributive justice, but does it actually work that way? We obviously don't have a great control since we've had this system of justice for centuries so it's hard to imagine a radically different system. But the data we do have suggests that increasing the severity of punishments does little to increase the deterrence factor [1]. So we could likely make our criminal system significantly less cruel without reducing the degree of effective deterrence.

Also I wasn't arguing for moral judgements of judges and prison guards for working within the current retributive justice regime (though those who wantonly exacerbate the cruelty of the system should certainly be judged for doing so). It's a systemic issue that retribution and cruelty are the implicit end goals of the US criminal justice system.

[1]http://scholarlycommons.law.northwestern.edu/cgi/viewcontent...

Re:Buried Alive: Stories from Inside Solitary Confinement by IsaacL on Friday March 03, 2017 @04:22PM (#13786736)
People do respond to incentives. Deterrence isn't just about the severity of punishments but also the probability of being caught. The US justice system (I'm not an American) seems to have the worst of both worlds were many people evade justice and others are hit with overly harsh sentences. Countries with effective police forces (e.g. Japan, Singapore) have very low crime rates.

Rehabilitation makes sense for petty criminals and economic criminals, and possibly "crimes of passion". Some individuals are simply beyond redemption, though. I'd say attempting to "rehabilitate" anyone at category 11 or above on the following scale [1] is an injustice to their victims. People like Charles Manson [2] are capable of retreating into a delusional fantasy world and never acknowledge what they've done.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Most_Evil#Scale_and_criminals (warning: no graphics, but extremely unpleasant content)

[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E-qWLlER1N0 (Manson starts one of his monologues at about 8:20)

Re:Buried Alive: Stories from Inside Solitary Confinement by digler999 on Friday March 03, 2017 @03:23PM (#13786078)
> if people are determined by outside forces, so are judges and prison guards,

false equivalency. people are determined by very different outside forces, and thats precisely why some people aren't deserving of the same levels of "moral judgement".

Re:Buried Alive: Stories from Inside Solitary Confinement by IsaacL on Friday March 03, 2017 @03:59PM (#13786476)
The fundamental point is that if determinism is true then morality is meaningless. I think we have free will.

(This will probably be a controversial point on HN so to expand a little: I think consciousness is both non-mystical and non-material - the mind is entirely natural, mind and matter interact, but the mind is not the same as the brain, and is not made of atoms. Qualia and the binding problem [1] cannot be explained in material terms. Furthermore, if our thoughts are merely deterministic neurons firing, then we don't have any reliable knowledge of reality, making any debate meaningless).

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Binding_problem#The_combinatio...

Re:Buried Alive: Stories from Inside Solitary Confinement by digler999 on Friday March 03, 2017 @04:32PM (#13786853)
nice retreat into philosophical fantasy-land. doesn't do much about reality where crime occurs.
Re:Buried Alive: Stories from Inside Solitary Confinement by IsaacL on Monday March 06, 2017 @12:31PM (#13804284)
Nice response to my argument with insults. Once you're talking about moral judgement and people being determined, you're in philosophical territory.

In reality we have free will. If every action was predetermined, there'd be no point judging people.

Re:Buried Alive: Stories from Inside Solitary Confinement by mfringel on Friday March 03, 2017 @11:26AM (#13783928)
Will the perpetrator's suffering make the victim un-robbed?
Re:Buried Alive: Stories from Inside Solitary Confinement by p1esk on Friday March 03, 2017 @12:24PM (#13784402)
It might make some victims feel better, which can be considered a form of a moral compensation.
Re:Buried Alive: Stories from Inside Solitary Confinement by mfringel on Friday March 03, 2017 @12:28PM (#13784433)
It might.... under what circumstances? some victims.... which ones? can be considered.... by who?
Re:Buried Alive: Stories from Inside Solitary Confinement by p1esk on Friday March 03, 2017 @12:53PM (#13784642)
Well, I would've certainly felt better knowing that the guy who robbed me got punished.
Re:Buried Alive: Stories from Inside Solitary Confinement by mfringel on Friday March 03, 2017 @01:53PM (#13785161)
Note that we're talking about a justice system that rehabilitates vs. one that punishes. Do you care which one happens to the perp, with the knowledge that they will be back in society at some point?
Re:Buried Alive: Stories from Inside Solitary Confinement by p1esk on Friday March 03, 2017 @05:43PM (#13787570)
Why do we have to choose between rehabilitation and punishment? The goal should be "If you did the crime, you will be punished, but while you're being punished, we can help you become a better person".
Re:Buried Alive: Stories from Inside Solitary Confinement by digler999 on Friday March 03, 2017 @03:17PM (#13786017)
paradoxically, there would be less total suffering (including inmate suffering) if prisons were more humane. That reduces your statement to "Should the victims be the only ones suffering?" after a violent crime. The part you miss is that there's no PSA video warning the perpetrators about the misery of solitary they face before they choose to commit the acts. They are either mentally ill or high when most of those crimes were committed. The only way you'd have a valid argument is if the criminal had a huge ctrl-z button, and once solitary "broke" them , and caused them to hit CTRL-Z, undo the victims' suffering, and everyone goes home. Then solitary would be an amazing, 99.99% effective punishment.

This is not even touching on the fact that a lot of these solitary inmates never commmitted heinous offenses. They just misbehaved in prison or were mentally ill and ran afoul of prison regs.