As Andy Grove said, "only the paranoid survive" [1]. Good strategy means being prepared for the worst case. As a plus, being prepared for a worst-case scenario goes a healthy way towards deterring it.
Keep in mind that Sweden is neither a NATO member [2] nor a nuclear power [3]. If Russia needed to make a strongman pitch at home or sow confusion abroad, it would be easier (and more meaningful) to cause trouble in Sweden or Finland than virtually anywhere else. Hence the perennial submarine drama [4].
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrew_Grove
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enlargement_of_NATO#Sweden
[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swedish_nuclear_weapons_progra...
[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swedish_submarine_incidents
Also Russia has continually violated Swedens air space. Russian pilots have acted aggressively towards Swedish pilots and Russian submarines have been spotted in Swedish waters.
So while Russia may not be plotting a war against Sweden, they are certainly stirring up trouble. Furthermore a war in the Baltic would be a disaster for Europe. If Russia perceives that they risk a wider war, they may back down.
this bullshit has acquired a life of its own no matter how often it's debunked. Please educate yourself
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swedish_submarine_incidents
there is not a single confirmed case. (But there is one from the distant USSR times.)
Overall this hysteria is an excellent example of Western/Swedish propaganda.
I suspect that "Russia has continually violated Swedens air space" is much of the same.
I mean, it's understandable, right? The military has to be prepared for lots of different situations, and in order to properly prepare you need to know your neighbors defenses. Finding out at what point your jets get intercepted tells you a lot about what you can get away with. It would practically be negligent of them not to do it.
As for the submarine issue, I'm not familiar enough with it, but I believe you are right that there are no confirmed cases in recent history. That said, I wouldn't be surprised if it's common for Russia and NATO to send subs to probe each others defenses for similar reasons.
[0] http://icelandreview.com/news/2016/09/26/russian-bombers-fly...
Russia has nothing to gain in baltic that it doesnt have with Kaliningrad. Same goes for Ukraine w/o Crimea.
Ukraine is special not because Kiev has to be in Russia, but because a lot of the current Ukrainian land was for, again, some hundreds years Russian and have almost no sovereign history. That makes it easy to play by all sorts of powers and Government is really not the main one there. Just look at Alaska it never gets same attention. Or North Kazakhstan. Same would be with Ukraine in coming 50-100 years if they would be able to hold the country together.
I dont get much about NK from anyone but some ultra-right aligned personalities (but i am also getting stuff about Alaska from them, so there is that).
Cant agree. Also this is a slippery slope that could apply to western countries as well and we dont want to go there.
> The "crazy" talk about Ukraine that started even prior to 2004 by "ultra-right" leaders was just 1st phase of prep.
Again, Ukraine problematic is objective. Alaska and NK is not. Not from todays Russia perspective, not from population perspective, not even from historical perspective. You didnt need ultra-right to talk about Ukraine and many legitimate politicians spoke about that for a long time. If anything moving towards Iran and eating up Caucasus nations is making much more sense than messing with NK, Baltics, Sweden or whoever else is trying to justify their actions using Russia as a threat.
In any case there is nothing state can do to please you: censoring specific types from accessing media is bad (and rest assured you would never know if they are ultra-right, libertarians or whoever they are from western media), allowing them is endorsing.
> It would be nice for Russia to have a swath from Crimea to Dontesk up through Latvia, just look at a map.
Why take this land? It does nothing strategically, has population that you need to subsidise, etc. Crimea allows Black Sea control. Kaliningrad effectively makes Baltic inner sea for Russia and if there ever would be any baltic action you would see that, not many (if any) ships would be able to enter.
The only way to get around that is to seize the entire country.
http://bigstory.ap.org/article/a419b994ccf14a42977665a9af966...
>Ms Nyh Radebo said that "70% of parliament is behind the decision to strengthen the military and co-operation with the countries around us".
>The closest co-operation is with Finland, she added.
>Sweden’s prime minister, Stefan Löfven, told a national defence conference this week that he “cannot rule out” Russia trying to influence the country’s next elections, which are due in 2018.
>“We should not rule it out and be naive and think that it does not happen in Sweden. That’s why information and cybersecurity is part of this strategy,” Löfven told the TT news agency.
>https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/jan/11/russia-waging-...
And that's besides the massive russian campaigns to cut off electricity to estonia. It'd probably be something akin to a professional negligence for a military commander not to recommend this, and it seems Swedish politicians for some reason aren't buying the 'put down your weapons and abandon your allies' line of argument.
Here are some recent events:
russian planes flying into Swedish air space
russian sub in water near Stockholm
Norway beefing up their border troops
etc.
Active disinformation campaigns targeting Norway, Sweden.
Let's just say they're thinking in the very, very long term.
In the short-term, the move is most likely intended as a signal to discourage an invasion of the Baltics, rather than their own territory. But in the longer term, what they're signaling to their much larger neighbor is: "Look, we know your history, and we've seen you play this game before. When it comes to Swedish territory -- don't even think about it."
I don't know the real motivation for annexing Crimea, but making a conclusion: first they take Crimea, then they're going to take Sweden and Baltic states - is nonsense.
Putin would be crazy not to take advantage of an opportunity to chip away at NATO and destabilize the EU edges. What else is he going to do, be a good boy and wait for them to drop sanctions?
Why did Russia abduct that Estonian border guard?
He might get his way-we have a "Gorbachev" in the White House or a KGB asset.
This is typical political fearmongering. There're many reasons to create a fear-inducing stories: "Bad Russians are going to take our land and they replaced our president with a puppet. We must unite and buy more guns!".
Relax, nobody wants to take Sweden. It also wasn't ever a part of USSR or even pre-USSR Russia.
Even Belarus and Kazakhstan don't really want to join, forget about the rest ex-USSR countries.
Taking countries by force makes even less sense - there do not exist resources or territory that make it profitable enough to offset military spending and new rounds of economic sanctions.
Military wise you buy large buffer between US ground & air forces based around there.
Not to mention that during the coup itself there were reports of Ukrainian generals sending envoys to Moscow, seeking aid and patronage to throw a counter coup and either reinstate the former president or setup military dictatorship. And they easily had the force too. Kremlin just said no.
RT is external propaganda, TV is the main instrument of internal propaganda.
Very few Russians use that as their information source, even pro-regime ones.
This is tantamount to Americans citing this as their source of domestic news:
For Russia there's no economical reasons to invade Sweden or Baltic states or Kazakhstan. This even sounds funny. There would be no political or economical benefits. It's a propaganda by the western media.
P.S. Actually there's a lot more reasons to invade Kazakhstan than Sweden. There're a lot of natural resources in Kazakhstan.
I think propaganda is necessary to support a war effort (and avoid insurrection). Think of it this way: If you're a soldier and your government tells you to invade a random country with nice people, how willing are you to fight? On the other hand, if your government convinces you that the target country is full of Nazis that eat babies and plan to genocide your people, then suddenly you're a hero if you go kill a bunch of strangers who never did anything to you.
So if you're running a country and you want to invade another country, you better start running the propaganda months, if not years, in advance.
Edit: As another example, take the Iraq War. The US and NATO didn't just randomly invade Iraq without propaganda preparation. Bush was even calling Iraq part of the "axis of evil" for at least a year before the Iraq war.
Ironically Western counties are very good at it.
Propaganda is a very good way to be informed. Precisely because the first law in good propaganda is "you never lie, just do not say anything about what you don't want mentioned". A lie like the weapons of mass destruction in Iraq is going to backfire when people realize, and they will.
I found very useful watching RT propaganda along CNN, or BBC propaganda.
If a group of propagandists fail to state a very important issue while the other do not, let's say they omit the official conclusion about a plane that went down months ago that you accused the other party of shooting down, well you know this party is lying.
not immediately, not if a greater conflict breaks out Sweden is a key chokepoint to enable Russia to get out of the north. They will need it.
https://thebarentsobserver.com/en/2017/03/norway-moves-milit...
http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2014/10/20/1413790933744_wps_...
Also Sweden is has been aligning more with UK in particular lately and Russian media has noticed.
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/oct/19/sweden-search-...
Also there was a sighting in 2015 that I recall:
http://www.reuters.com/article/us-sweden-submarine-idUSKCN0V...
I read Russian news/propaganda occasionally. Over the last few years, Russian news/propaganda prepared Russian minds for interfering in Ukraine. And the propaganda includes arguments to justify a military buildup. And it seems to be preparing Russian minds for a possible invasion of Baltic states one day.
But I don't think I've even seen Sweden mentioned in Russian news/propaganda. I don't think Sweden is a target.