News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Border-adjusted cash flow tax (to replace corporation tax... by thrill on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @07:48PM (#13770325)
Vox should bother to learn the difference between evasion and avoidance if they're going to write on taxes.
Re:Border-adjusted cash flow tax (to replace corporation tax... by __jal on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @07:54PM (#13770365)
Or people could accept that 'politically correct' language is not the province of one side of these battles.
Re:Border-adjusted cash flow tax (to replace corporation tax... by delinka on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @08:04PM (#13770442)
"Legally correct" is what we should strive for.
Re:Border-adjusted cash flow tax (to replace corporation tax... by fnord123 on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @08:12PM (#13770489)
Many of us are in tech. If you exploited a security hole to gain access to an unpatched system, you are still guilty of circumventing the system. Many believe the tax code should be similar: avoidance==evasion.

Of course, I am not a lawyer.

Re:Border-adjusted cash flow tax (to replace corporation tax... by Spooky23 on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @09:32PM (#13770919)
Where's the line?

In New York, a sliced bagel with a smear of butter is a taxable prepared food product. A uncut bagel with a side butter is tax free. Should I be a criminal for going the unsliced route if I wish to deprive the state treasury of $0.10?

Re:Border-adjusted cash flow tax (to replace corporation tax... by hueving on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @08:19PM (#13770526)
There are no laws saying it's illegal to follow the tax laws.
Re:Border-adjusted cash flow tax (to replace corporation tax... by pjc50 on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @08:26PM (#13770576)
Never heard of a GAAR? (general anti avoidance rule)
Re:Border-adjusted cash flow tax (to replace corporation tax... by JoshTriplett on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @10:08PM (#13771089)
GAAR replaces the predictable rule of law with the unpredictable caprice of whoever is currently the arbiter of what qualifies as 'avoidance'. (In practice, in a legal system that respects precedent, that would just replace legislation with case law.)

If you consider something a loophole, fix it. If the law is so complex that fixing loopholes seems untenable, consider simplifying the law to have fewer special cases.

Re:Border-adjusted cash flow tax (to replace corporation tax... by danbruc on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @08:39PM (#13770652)
Forget the law for a moment. A company profits from the infrastructure a country provides and therefore has at the very least a moral obligation to help financing it. It is a deal - company pays taxes, country provide infrastructure the company needs.

If a company then tries to avoid paying its share of the infrastructure, the company is breaking the deal. If doing so does not break existing tax law, that does not mean the company is in the right.

All this is of course fuzzy, but when a profitable company pays zero taxes, you can certainly not claim that you believed the amount of taxes you paid seemed reasonable to you. And the company should of course be held accountable for this even if it did not break any specific tax law. Not paying your share is a breach of the deal.

Re:Border-adjusted cash flow tax (to replace corporation tax... by Spooky23 on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @09:35PM (#13770933)
That's a moral argument for tax compliance. Even Christianity teaches that Caesar gets his due.

You have no moral obligation to pay a tax that is not levied.

Re:Border-adjusted cash flow tax (to replace corporation tax... by danbruc on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @10:08PM (#13771088)
In the case we are talking about, the companies have to pay taxes but they exploit loopholes to avoid it. They may be not in violation of the letters of the law but they are in violation of the spirit of the law.

The moral obligation is to participate in the funding of the system you are profiting from. Making money by transporting your goods on roads built by the state, employing people educated in schools funded by state, and enforcing your contracts by courts established by the state but not paying taxes towards this system is wrong.

And this obligation does not go away if you find a trick to circumvent the written rules.

Re:Border-adjusted cash flow tax (to replace corporation tax... by thrill on Thursday March 02, 2017 @12:39AM (#13771724)
Loopholes are not exploits. They are compliance. The only moral obligation is to follow laws, and then when they are just.
Re:Border-adjusted cash flow tax (to replace corporation tax... by Analemma_ on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @08:05PM (#13770444)
A lot of us believe it is a distinction without a difference, so your view is not universally shared.
Re:Border-adjusted cash flow tax (to replace corporation tax... by kyleblarson on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @08:16PM (#13770507)
Do you take any deductions in your annual taxes?
Re:Border-adjusted cash flow tax (to replace corporation tax... by danbruc on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @08:49PM (#13770693)
The difference is between deducting what just happens to be deductible and deliberately acting in a way to maximize deduction and minimize your taxes.
Re:Border-adjusted cash flow tax (to replace corporation tax... by gozur88 on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @09:22PM (#13770877)
The government would be very disappointed to learn people weren't making decisions based on a tax system that's filled with incentives to change the way people conduct their lives and businesses.
Re:Border-adjusted cash flow tax (to replace corporation tax... by danbruc on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @09:29PM (#13770911)
That are different kinds of taxes. There are taxes especially designed to steer behavior away from discouraged actions or towards encouraged actions and there are taxes that are mainly for funding. That is certainly no absolutely sharp distinction and all taxes can at least at times be used to steer behavior, but income taxes certainly do not exist to discourage having an income.
Re:Border-adjusted cash flow tax (to replace corporation tax... by JoshTriplett on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @10:11PM (#13771101)
> income taxes certainly do not exist to discourage having an income

They do, however, have that effect in practice; people with enough money to do so are incentivized to have long-term capital gains and no income.

Re:Border-adjusted cash flow tax (to replace corporation tax... by gozur88 on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @09:35PM (#13770937)
That's why, instead of trying to figure out what Congress intended, people should just worry about the law as written. Congress can always make changes.
Re:Border-adjusted cash flow tax (to replace corporation tax... by danbruc on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @09:51PM (#13771016)
That would work in an ideal world, but in the real world laws will have flaws. That is essentially exactly the same as with vulnerabilities. You find a vulnerability and responsibly disclose it, you are the good guy and maybe get a coffee mug or some money as reward. You exploit the vulnerability until someone else notices it, you are the bad guy and hopefully get punished.

As any other software developer I would certainly love if all the rules in the world were unambiguous and free of flaws, but that is nothing we can have, at least not at the moment. So we all have to deal with it and we all have to accept that the spirit is at times more important than the words.

And just to come back, nobody can seriously claim that they believed it was in the spirit of the law to pay no taxes at all. That is just not how or system works and everybody knows that, don't be surprised if you get punished for trying it anyway.

Re:Border-adjusted cash flow tax (to replace corporation tax... by gozur88 on Thursday March 02, 2017 @02:41AM (#13772333)
>That would work in an ideal world, but in the real world laws will have flaws.

Well, sure, and it's incumbent on Congress to fix them, not the bureaucracy or the courts. Of course there is some gray area where you can try to gain extra deductions through miscategorizating expenses and such, but that really a question of the letter of the law and not its spirit.

>And just to come back, nobody can seriously claim that they believed it was in the spirit of the law to pay no taxes at all.

That is entirely irrelevant and not even true for almost half the households in the US.

Re:Border-adjusted cash flow tax (to replace corporation tax... by JoshTriplett on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @10:13PM (#13771110)
As far as I can tell, the difference in practice is whether the person speaking likes the entity taking the deduction, which closely correlated with whether the entity taking the deduction is perceived to have "too much" money.
Re:Border-adjusted cash flow tax (to replace corporation tax... by danbruc on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @10:23PM (#13771161)
You are probably in for a Nobel Price in economics if you manage to come up with a viable tax system that allows painting a black and white picture. But at least for the moment we are stuck with a gray scale picture where the border between tax avoidance and tax evasion is fuzzy and at least subject to some kind of subjectivity.
Re:Border-adjusted cash flow tax (to replace corporation tax... by JoshTriplett on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @10:38PM (#13771215)
There's a very clear distinction: one is illegal, the other is legal. If you say someone is engaging in tax evasion, you're accusing them of a crime. If you say someone is engaging in tax avoidance, you're accusing them of following the tax code as written.

And if you just wish someone paid more in taxes than they're required to, then look closer at the things they're legally doing, decide which of them you'd rather not be legal, and argue against that. But that's not an argument about the behavior of that person; that's an argument about desired properties of tax law.

Even if you believe that some part of the tax code is currently immoral (and I certainly think there's a critical distinction between law and morality), it still doesn't make sense to voluntarily pay extra. Pay the legally required amount, and if you decide that the best possible use of your additional funds is to donate them to the government, do so; the Treasury Department (and specifically the "Bureau of the Public Debt") accepts voluntary additional payments, and they're even tax-deductible. Or, perhaps you can find an even better use of that money to have an impact on the world.

Re:Border-adjusted cash flow tax (to replace corporation tax... by danbruc on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @11:07PM (#13771326)
There's a very clear distinction: one is illegal, the other is legal. If you say someone is engaging in tax evasion, you're accusing them of a crime. If you say someone is engaging in tax avoidance, you're accusing them of following the tax code as written.

I am not a native speaker, tax mitigation seems to be the correct term that I should have used instead of tax evasion.

Re:Border-adjusted cash flow tax (to replace corporation tax... by mahyarm on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @09:21PM (#13770872)
I avoid a cigarette tax by not buying cigarettes. I avoid more property tax by moving to a lower property tax state. Will you jail me for tax avoidance in either case?