Re:Border-adjusted cash flow tax (to replace corporation tax...
by Spooky23 on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @09:35PM
(#13770933)
That's a moral argument for tax compliance. Even Christianity teaches that Caesar gets his due.
You have no moral obligation to pay a tax that is not levied.
Re:Border-adjusted cash flow tax (to replace corporation tax...
by danbruc on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @10:08PM
(#13771088)
In the case we are talking about, the companies have to pay taxes but they exploit loopholes to avoid it. They may be not in violation of the letters of the law but they are in violation of the spirit of the law.
The moral obligation is to participate in the funding of the system you are profiting from. Making money by transporting your goods on roads built by the state, employing people educated in schools funded by state, and enforcing your contracts by courts established by the state but not paying taxes towards this system is wrong.
And this obligation does not go away if you find a trick to circumvent the written rules.
If a company then tries to avoid paying its share of the infrastructure, the company is breaking the deal. If doing so does not break existing tax law, that does not mean the company is in the right.
All this is of course fuzzy, but when a profitable company pays zero taxes, you can certainly not claim that you believed the amount of taxes you paid seemed reasonable to you. And the company should of course be held accountable for this even if it did not break any specific tax law. Not paying your share is a breach of the deal.