News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:‘The American dream is not working out here’ by tradersam on Monday February 27, 2017 @03:48PM (#13747856)
> “We make over $1m between us, but we can’t afford a house,” said a woman in her 50s who works in digital marketing for a major telecoms corporation

If you make $1m/yr and are scraping by, I don't care where you live, you're terrible at managing money.

Re:‘The American dream is not working out here’ by exclusiv on Monday February 27, 2017 @08:07PM (#13750255)
So true. And the notion that you must own a home is stupid anyway and oversold.

I currently pay $4500/mo to rent a home in California. Because of it's location, the home would cost $2M+ for me to buy. So the debt service / maintenance / taxes is way more than the rental income. You're either renting the house or renting the money (mortgage). The idea that you're throwing money away on rent never considers the gap between rental income and expenses, vaporized down payments and going underwater from falling prices, tax hikes, etc.

I'll probably move into a smaller house soon because I don't need as much space and I've been buying investment homes instead of worrying about my primary residence. My first investment property pays the mortgage and makes money. It's increased in value too but I don't bank on that.

Why buy a home you cannot rent out for more than the debt service? Also - why buy a starter home in California for $1M+. That's fundamentally messed up to spend that much on a home that you know for a fact is not your forever home. The only way to know if it's a good deal is if you can rent it out for more than it costs, or about the same and you're going to be there for ~7 yrs+.

Re:‘The American dream is not working out here’ by dikdik on Tuesday February 28, 2017 @12:18AM (#13751448)
So your landlord is losing money by renting it to you? This doesn't make any sense to me...
Re:‘The American dream is not working out here’ by ThrustVectoring on Tuesday February 28, 2017 @12:29AM (#13751500)
They expect to make money on the appreciation of the house's value.
Re:‘The American dream is not working out here’ by exclusiv on Tuesday February 28, 2017 @02:14AM (#13751922)
I don't think mine is losing money since it's been in a family trust forever. But most landlords aren't making any money. Everyone has owned properties forever and taxes are really low for them. If you're in that position it doesn't matter but it doesn't apply to a rent or own debate for current renters or potential homebuyers.

But yes most landlords out here are lucky if they break even. They take tax write-offs and hope for appreciation. Cap rates in Cali are super low and prices are really high.

Re:‘The American dream is not working out here’ by sagarm on Tuesday February 28, 2017 @12:48AM (#13751564)
They probably have a massive prop 13 subsidy.
Re:‘The American dream is not working out here’ by exclusiv on Tuesday February 28, 2017 @02:20AM (#13751954)
Yeah it's in a family trust and they haven't done any major renovations. Taxes are lower than they should be. But even if taxes were zero, it still wouldn't make sense to buy this place for 2M+ when rent is only 4500. For 4500 rent you need to be around 900k max purchase price. If it's an investment it should be way less, like 450k.

I've rented 4 different homes in Cali and 3 were owned by family trusts. The one that wasn't made nothing and she ended up selling to get out. I rented that house for $3600/mo and she got 925k for it.

Re:‘The American dream is not working out here’ by undersuit on Monday February 27, 2017 @06:32PM (#13749613)
I wanted to fight you one this. I went out and found how much a couple in the SV making a million a year would take home every month.

It's about $33k. My only friends that make that much money work in tech. $33k is a comfy yearly salary in Montana.

Re:‘The American dream is not working out here’ by reefoctopus on Tuesday February 28, 2017 @12:27AM (#13751493)
33k per month take home on 1 million per year would mean the tax rate is over 60%. There is no way that's right.
Re:‘The American dream is not working out here’ by phil21 on Tuesday February 28, 2017 @12:49AM (#13751572)
Sounds pretty close to me, why would you think that's far off for a $1M/yr couple in CA? Certainly within 10%.

High W2 income earners are heavily taxed in the US.

Re:‘The American dream is not working out here’ by flukus on Tuesday February 28, 2017 @01:01AM (#13751622)
That would be almost the highest tax rate in the world.
Re:‘The American dream is not working out here’ by phil21 on Tuesday February 28, 2017 @01:06AM (#13751645)
I looked and the 40% federal rate kicks in at $500k, I thought it was lower. So you're more correct than I am.

45-50% is a better total estimate for a total tax rate.

The last dollar made is taxed at 53% (40% federal, 13% CA), so that's why the 60% number didn't sound horribly off. This is also ignoring FICA and SS taxes, which it's far too late to do the math on :)

Re:‘The American dream is not working out here’ by Symbiote on Tuesday February 28, 2017 @04:48AM (#13752557)
Is there an online calculator, or is it too complicated for this to be a free service?

Someone earning £1,000,000 in the UK would pay 46% tax.

https://listentotaxman.com/1000000

Re:‘The American dream is not working out here’ by bootload on Monday February 27, 2017 @07:42PM (#13750099)
"I don't care where you live, you're terrible at managing money."

Not necessarily. Everything in SF/Bay Area will require a compromise. Want to save on real-estate? You will pay in time traveled. Want to save on travel, you pay for somewhere to live. Either way you loose.

For all the hi-tech in these companies the question should be asked, "Why do you have to come to work to do your job?" Is it necessary every day?

Re:‘The American dream is not working out here’ by tradersam on Monday February 27, 2017 @08:14PM (#13750283)
You could live in an SF penthouse and drive a Ferrari to work in Oakland everday if you make $1m/yr.
Re:‘The American dream is not working out here’ by bootload on Tuesday February 28, 2017 @03:49AM (#13752325)
"if you make $1m/yr"

I'm pretty sure you'd be able to live in most large cities like a king for USD1M. What is the traffic and parking like?

Re:‘The American dream is not working out here’ by AstralStorm on Monday February 27, 2017 @06:27PM (#13749576)
It takes quite a lot of money or major tricks in some places to actually save anything.

Tricks like buying out of the super expensive area, meaning paying in time.

Plus they probably want a house in San Francisco itself, which has hyperinflated housing prices.

She didn't say it was their net income either.

Re:‘The American dream is not working out here’ by gydfi on Tuesday February 28, 2017 @12:58AM (#13751612)
Journalists love writing this same article over and over again. Find some humble bragging buffoon willing to get quoted as talking about how hard it is to get by on some large amount of money, then farm the sputtering outrage of the readership for clicks.

I've never seen it done with a seven-figure income though.