News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber's SVP of engineering is out by ogezi on Monday February 27, 2017 @03:01PM (#13747409)
I also read his post about wanting to do something else, so I was very surprised when I heard that he had gotten a job at Uber.

I think that Kalanick made the right decision by asking him to resign. They can't afford to have any more controversies surrounding them especially at this time.

I hope all that has happened at Uber can overall make the tech industry better for everyone.

Re:Uber's SVP of engineering is out by Arizhel on Monday February 27, 2017 @03:25PM (#13747602)
I disagree. On the face of it, this totally reeks of scapegoating.

Uber has many allegations right now that its current culture tolerates harassment, meaning that current employees (including managers most notably) are alleged to have committed harassment while at Uber.

This guy is accused of harassment not at Uber (according to the article), but at a previous job at Google. There's no mention of any allegations of harassing behavior at Uber. So maybe he did harass someone at Google, or maybe he didn't and someone bad-mouthed him.

If Uber intends to clean up its culture, shouldn't they be first looking at people who have recently been accused of harassment, such as Susan Fowler's first boss, and can those people first? Instead, they find some guy who's been bad-mouthed by a prior employer (which isn't unusual when a company or manager is mad that someone left), and sack him to try to appease everyone and show that they're "doing something".

Re:Uber's SVP of engineering is out by lpolovets on Monday February 27, 2017 @05:26PM (#13749003)
> shouldn't they be first looking at people who have recently been accused of harassment

I'm not sure it has to be either/or. If they found out about Singhal's past and are trying to change their culture, then they should ask him to resign. Letting him stay because they have other higher priority harassment issues doesn't seem like a great solution. They can ask him to resign and keep looking into other recent claims, like Fowler's.

Re:Uber's SVP of engineering is out by Eridrus on Monday February 27, 2017 @04:06PM (#13748049)
If you believe the allegations, then Uber's entire management was complicit. Even without him assaulting anyone at Uber, the fact that he let it happen under his watch is his fault.

If their goal is to show that they've turned a corner they need someone who can credibly lead that change; someone who left their former job due to sexual assault allegations and presided over the cultural failings in their department is not the right person.

Not to say this is isn't scapegoating, but firing low level managers would be the same, since it sounds like the culture of turning a blind eye to transgressions of high performers seems to have stemmed from Travis.

Re:Uber's SVP of engineering is out by kafkaesq on Monday February 27, 2017 @03:31PM (#13747662)
Low-hanging fruit. Generally, it's far easier to get rid of someone for lying ("You lied about about your reasons for leaving your previous company, it seems") than to prove novel allegations against them.
Re:Uber's SVP of engineering is out by softawre on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @05:15PM (#13769050)
Right. You can sack anybody for anything of course, but convincing the HR department there is low liability for a lawsuit is another thing.
Re:Uber's SVP of engineering is out by ASinclair on Monday February 27, 2017 @03:32PM (#13747674)
I don't think they sacked him to look like they're "doing something". How could his subordinates have any confidence the culture would change when he's been accused of the exact problem behavior they're trying to fix?
Re:Uber's SVP of engineering is out by interlocutor on Monday February 27, 2017 @03:39PM (#13747739)
So you think an accusation is all that is needed to sack an employee? I think the bar should be higher than that. There should be some minimal verification that the accusation--which happened in another company--is legitimate.
Re:Uber's SVP of engineering is out by jimbokun on Monday February 27, 2017 @04:16PM (#13748160)
The article says there was an investigation at Google, where they found the accusations against him to be credible.
Re:Uber's SVP of engineering is out by navalsaini on Tuesday February 28, 2017 @12:58AM (#13751610)
How about giving people a second chance? One punishment for one crime or something... Or just give them off time. I think these are personality defects that can be corrected with counseling, does not make them a serial...
Re:Uber's SVP of engineering is out by ASinclair on Monday February 27, 2017 @03:53PM (#13747923)
We don't know the details of the incident but the article states Google was going to fire him if he didn't resign. We also don't know how much verification Uber did.

I don't believe an accusation is all that is needed. However, in a situation like this optics do matter. Employees need to trust that their superiors won't be part of the problem. He clearly didn't have that trust.

Re:Uber's SVP of engineering is out by x0x0 on Monday February 27, 2017 @05:06PM (#13748775)
Did you skip the part about Google finding the allegations credible enough to fire him?

Also, standards are higher for executives.

Re:Uber's SVP of engineering is out by Arizhel on Monday February 27, 2017 @04:12PM (#13748119)
Yep, that's what I'm worried about here. If the guy were accused of inappropriate conduct at Uber, his current employer, then it's entirely appropriate for the HR department to investigate and decide to fire him.

But firing someone for allegations of something that happened at a previous employer, where there is no possible way the current employer's HR department can investigate it, seems entirely wrong. This means that someone can be wrongfully accused of something by some vengeful former employer/boss, and never get a job again because they'll be blacklisted. It is not unusual for employers to badmouth their former employees.

Re:Uber's SVP of engineering is out by msabalau on Monday February 27, 2017 @04:49PM (#13748570)
According to the article he left for failing to disclose the circumstances of his departure from Google. The article further documents that he acknowledges that he left under this cloud. As the article notes "having Singhal at the head of an organization under siege over sexual harassment issues when he was not candid with Uber over his departure from Google was considered untenable."

It is hard to see that this is generalizable to the circumstances of typical employees.

Re:Uber's SVP of engineering is out by anigbrowl on Monday February 27, 2017 @09:37PM (#13750660)
If he was falsely accused by Google then he could have filed a lawsuit against them to clear his reputation. It is fact very unusual for prior employers to badmouth an ex-employee, which is why firms usually limit their communications to confirming the fact of someone's prior employment between certain dates but not making any other public statements.
Re:Uber's SVP of engineering is out by rxbudian on Monday February 27, 2017 @08:09PM (#13750266)
Personally I'd rather Uber fire the HR department who are handling the harassment complaint first. They're the one who are not doing their job.
Re:Uber's SVP of engineering is out by scorpion032 on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @07:52AM (#13763271)
HR department rarely has any discretion. They are the mouth piece of the management. They just put it in nicer words and polished corp speak.
Re:Uber's SVP of engineering is out by dllthomas on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @08:06PM (#13770453)
> shouldn't they be first looking at people who have recently been accused of harassment, such as Susan Fowler's first boss, and can those people first?

It's hard to can someone who (as mentioned in Susan's blog post) already left the company.

Re:Uber's SVP of engineering is out by foobiekr on Monday February 27, 2017 @03:53PM (#13747925)
Well, obviously it is scapegoating.

It's interesting to see this move-before-being-fired thing that happens in the valley quite often as a sort of mirror image of the issues the Catholic church had to deal with for years. It would be interesting to know if the investors at Uber knew about his issues regardless of whether Uber did. They tend to be better connected.

Re:Uber's SVP of engineering is out by fictioncircle on Monday February 27, 2017 @03:54PM (#13747932)
> Uber execs found out about the situation after Recode informed them of the chain of events between Singhal and the search giant this week.

> Indeed. According to multiple sources and internal notes read to me, after discussing the claims of an alleged encounter between Singhal and a female employee first with former Google HR head Laszlo Bock and also Google CEO Sundar Pichai in late 2015, he denied those claims at the time. He also apparently stated a number of times that there were two sides to every story.

> To be clear, Singhal’s dispute with Google has nothing to do with that situation or the recent lawsuit that Google’s parent company, Alphabet, has waged against Uber’s Otto division.

The part that worries me about "perfect storms" like this when two competitors are in multiple disputes (both legal and in the marketplace) is it is a convenient time to leak information that will remove key players from the other company and it does appear that Recode got the information from someone who likely is currently a Google employee.

I'm not saying this time it is false but I have seen that pattern play out before where accusations from a previous employer who is a competitor for the current employer get "released" to ruin someone's reputation at a critical juncture. Although, in that case it wasn't sexual harassment but the same principle applies imo.

I'd like to see something more verifiable than a business competitor's employee acted as a source for a news article. It is like trusting someone's enemy to be honest rather than slip the knife into their back. If that is the standard of evidence we are using to destroy people's careers, it is a lower bar than I'd like.

Re:Uber's SVP of engineering is out by mahyarm on Monday February 27, 2017 @05:16PM (#13748894)
Unfortunately in any war game, you strike when the iron is hot.
Re:Uber's SVP of engineering is out by TorKlingberg on Monday February 27, 2017 @05:29PM (#13749045)
I seem to me that Recode started investigating Uber, and uncovered this.
Re:Uber's SVP of engineering is out by fictioncircle on Monday February 27, 2017 @05:47PM (#13749215)
That might be and it might be my life experience biasing my opinion. I just came away with the impression Recode started to investigate and got spoonfed a line of attack against a commercial competitor.

To me, the chain of events seems to be, Recode goes to sources at Google for dirt on ex-Google employees at Uber, gets fed exactly what it would take to get an employee that is valuable to Uber terminated.

Often, information that is leaked benefits the leaker in some way from their point of view. Deepthroat leaked as part of a plan to advance his career which is quite similar to Uber's culture of getting other people to fall so you can advance as well.

There are just too many odd angles to this that imply it might have been motivated by something other than a genuine commitment to see justice done that I think some greater level of evidence should be expected before you convict someone in the court of public opinion.

Re:Uber's SVP of engineering is out by zigzigzag on Monday February 27, 2017 @04:23PM (#13748261)
Yes. Presumably whoever was reading out those notes is high up in Google HR, as I guess they are not exactly widely distributed internally. Google HR personnel deliberately leaking what appears to be little more than gossip in order to cause problems for a competitor does not really inspire confidence.
Re:Uber's SVP of engineering is out by x0x0 on Monday February 27, 2017 @05:08PM (#13748808)
It could also have been eg the person Amit allegedly harassed, who may not have been entirely stoked about (1) google giving him his grants, (2) letting Amit write a "happy days, I'm retiring" letter, and (3) him going on to a similar job at a new company.

This is a lot more than idle gossip. If that's how you view this matter, I hear Uber is hiring!

Re:Uber's SVP of engineering is out by fictioncircle on Monday February 27, 2017 @05:55PM (#13749294)
Just fyi, generally someone who filed a complaint or being investigated by HR doesn't have access to HR's internal notes on the investigation.

It very much reads as if a HR employee is the source. HR works for the company and only hands that information out if legally compelled or its to the company's advantage. They don't give internal memos on HR issues to the employees involved because it provides them with no advantages.

Re:Uber's SVP of engineering is out by tekromancr on Monday February 27, 2017 @07:08PM (#13749882)
Or it was an unauthorized leak. Someone in HR, with access to the files, deciding for themselves what the right thing to do was
Re:Uber's SVP of engineering is out by fictioncircle on Monday February 27, 2017 @07:27PM (#13750017)
> Or it was an unauthorized leak. Someone in HR, with access to the files, deciding for themselves what the right thing to do was

Yes. I just would have expected it to be closer to the actual event rather than waiting ~2 years.

Re:Uber's SVP of engineering is out by patmcguire on Monday February 27, 2017 @05:07PM (#13748787)
Discussion was in lat 2015 when they both confirmed. I dunno how they kept that under wraps, I guess since she didn't want to go public Recode let it go.
Re:Uber's SVP of engineering is out by patmcguire on Monday February 27, 2017 @05:16PM (#13748896)
NVM, I misread it. Accusation was in 2015, they confirmed it recently.
Re:Uber's SVP of engineering is out by kaspm on Monday February 27, 2017 @03:22PM (#13747586)
It's great that Kalanick moved quickly but between this and the other incidents, I don't think it's going to be enough. Kalanick himself may have to resign. Given a good competitor in Lyft and the relatively low barrier to entry on the core business, it will be difficult to weather this storm.
Re:Uber's SVP of engineering is out by ogezi on Monday February 27, 2017 @03:31PM (#13747663)
I think that after some time people will forget about this. I read an article [1] today about how the anger that a lot of people feel towards Uber right now will not be enough to push them through the discomfort of moving to smaller competitors like Lyft. it's great that Susan Fowler spoke out but it's gonna take more (a much bigger problem) to cause Kalanick to resign (or be pushed out by the board).

[1] http://www.businessinsider.com/why-uber-probably-never-will-...

Re:Uber's SVP of engineering is out by kaspm on Monday February 27, 2017 @03:48PM (#13747852)
I suspect the hits will keep coming [1]

[1] https://medium.com/@amyvertino/my-name-is-not-amy-i-am-an-ub...

Re:Uber's SVP of engineering is out by ProAm on Monday February 27, 2017 @05:08PM (#13748804)
> I think that after some time people will forget about this.

Except that it seems to come up every 8 months or so with Uber, so there's a constant reminder of what kind of company it is.

Re:Uber's SVP of engineering is out by tedmiston on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @01:29PM (#13766676)
Lyft is a great competitor to Uber, and I use it more myself, but the businesses have grown very different in the past couple years.

Uber is very international while Lyft is only in the US, Uber has all of these side businesses beside transportation like UberEATS, which is the most reliable food delivery service in my experience.

I've been thinking about the two like: Uber is building the transit infrastructure, and Lyft is building the best personal transportation experience.